7 ms·
Silicon Valley: Feel the Froth
- jyu 13y agoBubble talk and high valuations comes up every month or so. pud's comment sums it up nicely: Generally, being profitable precludes a company from getting "silly [high] valuations" & buzz in Silicon Valley. Unless they're really, really profitable. Big valuations usually stem from not knowing how much a company will make once they start charging for stuff. So the "it" crowd works itself into a frenzy and VCs take a big gamble. But once you make a dollar, all the mystery is gone. You're judged & valued pretty much on your revenue alone. Which is usually low (startups are hard) and unsexy (so not a ton of buzz). Not saying a agree with it. But that's how it is. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5236239 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=5236239
- adventured 13y agoThe most interesting thing, to me, about the current valuations, is where they're going to be in another 6 or 12 months of this momentum. Yellen is highly likely to maintain the negative interest rate environment for years to come, and that should encourage a stock market move even higher. Motivated bull markets never stop at a bit above historical average values. They go a lot higher, become quite irrational, and then crash. As it is already, about 85% of the gains in the market over the last two years have been pure PE expansion, as earnings growth has tumbled to low single digits. I expect valuations for tech companies across the board to get significantly frothier before the music stops again. If a company like Snapchat is worth $3.x billion today, I see no reason to think capital won't bid it up to $5 or $10 billion over the coming year, assuming the very accommodating environment continues.
- jacques_chester 13y agoIt seems to me that the surest indicator that a bubble is underway is people saying that it's not a bubble.
- mathattack 13y agoIs the converse also true? People say that a bull market can't be stop until the last bear has been shot. (Then again, who are these "people" that keep saying things?)
- jacques_chester 13y agoFor example: Technology and finance veterans say this time is different — and it is. -- Rolfe Winkler
- asmithmd1 13y agoYes. "The stock market climbs a wall of worry" http://www.investopedia.com/terms/w/wallofworry.asp http://www.investopedia.com/terms/w/wallofworry.asp It will continue to go up as long as there are people who are afraid and have not put their money in. As soon as it is obvious the market will go up forever, then it will drop since there is no more new money coming in.
- mathattack 13y agoI wish there were an accurate way to measure this.
- jacques_chester 13y agoThere are lots of people who claim they can, under the heading of "technical analysis".
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- StavrosK 13y agoWhat do they say when there's no bubble underway?
- jacques_chester 13y ago
- VLM 13y ago"Some people worry that the looser rules may end up hurting small investors." LOL bagholders will always find a way to set themselves up as bagholders, all you can do is shove them in or out of certain markets. When you look around the poker table and can't figure out who the sucker is, and you're only at the poker table because its trendy and cool to play poker right now, guess who the sucker is? Just like real estate always goes up (until it doesn't) tech IPOs / valuations only go up, so by greater fool theory you should put all your money into whatever is going up because you can always sell to a greater fool at a profit (until you can't) If you use EPA/OSHA/NAFTA/whatever to eliminate all other resource extraction industries, you end up with a bunch of sharks extracting resources (money) from dumb investors. The same folks who would be selling the golden gate bridge to multiple people are stuck selling tech IPOs at this time.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- adventured 13y agoDefinitely a good point. Cisco was worth not quite $600 billion at the peak of the dotcom bubble. They lost about 93% of their value in the meltdown, but that didn't mean routers were going away. The same is no doubt true about mobile software and social networks. I personally don't think Snapchat is worth $100 million, much less the $5 or $10 billion valuation they may eventually command from a VC round before the party is over. I don't think they can monetize the product, or convince a major player to spend that kind of cash. They're stuck in a tumblr-like quandary, but it's even worse, because their valuation removes a lot of potential buyers. That being said, clearly there are going to be a lot of winners in the mobile software market, regardless of Snapchat's individual future.
- michaelochurch 13y agoTo me, the obvious sign of the bubble isn't the high valuations, but the asphyxiating red tide of MBA-culture people who are in technology for all the wrong reasons. They're an invasive species. They come in during bubble times, compete successfully for attention and funding, because they have superior social polish (and, more importantly, can exploit the "just like me" bias of chickenhawking VCs) to the real technologists, build a self-referential junk-pile of nothing, and then leave just before the silly bubble-world they've created collapses. Then real technologists get a few years of relative calm and meritocracy (although there's not nearly as much money in it, then) before the cycle repeats. Technology is incredibly rewarding and I wouldn't want to be in any other career, but it's hard and you gotta be real to get any good at it. It takes years of realness-- hard work (often unrecognized) that kicks your mental ass-- just to get the basics. When people who aren't real try to come in and get the rewards-- Harvard MBA CEOs who don't even understand linear algebra setting themselves up as "data whizzes" because they were able to hire smart people-- it's irksome.
- adventured 13y agoThis. Along with the banks / bankers that start drooling over the crumbs they can pick up and 'making deals happen.' These parasites mostly only show up when the money is flowing in a big way, and they start pushing everything higher and attempting to generate absurd mega deals (eg AOL + Time Warner; HP + Compaq; Nortel + Bay Networks; Microsoft + WebTV; Yahoo + Geocites & Broadcast.com; endless others).
- seivan 13y agoThis... I've met them, I've seen them. They are scum. I've noticed they tend to ingrain themselves into startup news and blogs or similar things. I know some MBA's that run some startup news site in Stockholm/Sweden as well as their own startup. Really disgusting personality. Really fits into the mild of "superior social polish and exploitation".
- MortenK 13y agoI don't entirely understand. Is it wrong of them to run a startup news site while having their own startup? If so, why? Or is that unrelated, and it's just that these particular guys are not very nice?
- jt2190 13y agoOriginal article here: http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB10001424052702304470504579161880453868414#printMode http://online.wsj.com/news/articles/SB1000142405270230447050...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- pg 13y ago"This year, shares of newly public technology companies are being valued at 5.6 times sales, estimates University of Florida professor Jay Ritter, who tracks IPOs. That is well short of the median of 26.5 times sales in 1999." At least the WSJ feels obliged to put facts in their articles, even if they contradict the headlines.
- hnal943 13y agoThe article and the headline are typically written by different people anyway, so this title-article dissonance is certainly possible.
- 7Figures2Commas 13y ago1. Pick an arbitrary financial ratio. 2. Compare today's median value at IPO to median value at IPO in 1999. 3. If today's median value is less than 1999's median value, there cannot be a bubble. Interesting approach, but one that I would inevitably expect to create more pain than profit.
- pg 13y agoExcept that's not what they did. They looked at what's probably the most meaningful ratio, and they found that it's not merely lower but around 5x lower. (This sort of comment is a good illustration of a problem with forums, incidentally. Once a forum has users who reply by mischaracterizing what you say, every comment is twice as much work. First you say what you want to, and then you have to make another comment saying in effect "no, what I said was...")
- 7Figures2Commas 13y ago> They looked at what's probably the most meaningful ratio... Says who? While price-to-sales can be a very useful metric, I don't know any experienced market participant who invests or trades off of fundamentals who would argue absolutely that price-to-sales is the most meaningful ratio off of which to determine whether a company is undervalued, overvalued or fairly valued. And using the median value of this ratio at IPO alone with a small subset of companies in an effort to argue for or against the notion that there's a "bubble"? That's simply not credible. For what it's worth, if you do want to look at price-to-sales, and in a more meaningful context, it's worth considering that the median price/sales ratio in the US markets is at a record high and exceeds the mean by a near record margin as well[1]. [1] http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/imageroot/2013/10/AE%20Price%20Sales%20Median.jpg http://www.zerohedge.com/sites/default/files/images/user5/im...
- arbuge 13y agoValuations on AngelList certainly seem to be creeping relentlessly higher for Valley companies. The typical pattern seems to be the following: - first a seed round of $500k with a convertible note - next a valued equity round of $1m at a premoney valuation of $6m The general impression I get from this is that valuation has become divorced from reality. What seems to be driving it is that the founder/s just don't want to give up more than 25% of the equity for around $1.5m funding. In that sense they're kind of pulling numbers out of their nether regions to make the math work out.
- bandy 13y ago"Froth" as in lots of bubbles? One little bubble collapsing wouldn't necessarily blow out the rest, unlike a singular bubble. Or "Froth" as in "frothing at the mouth" (from insanity and/or rabies)? Given the silliness, this is equally applicable. From having worked on a trading system in the late 80s, I know that investors (and traders) at the retail level work at a gut level and would see market moves very shortly after news items would tick across on the Reuters feed. I would argue that this article is intended to be like spraying valium into the zeitgeist for the inevitable collapse. If they can grab mindshare with this "foam" concept, they may very well be able to isolate failed IPOs to companies (without real profit) in limited segments.
- oscargrouch 13y agoMeanwhile, the amazing Nokia, was traded by bananas (7B) , while Twitter has a market value of 11B ?? WTF
- MortenK 13y agoWell if not an IT bubble, surely there's a housing bubble. "Home prices in San Francisco and surrounding counties rose more than 15% in the past year". That's the kind of increase we saw year after year just a year or two before the bubble popped, and prices fell by 50% or so (around 2005-2006 I guess). It's funny how the majority just assume prices will keep on climbing (I was one of those merry fools by the way), and in hindsight it becomes so obvious that such increases are not sustainable.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> That's the kind of increase we saw year after year just a year or two before the bubble popped, and prices fell by 50% or so (around 2005-2006 I guess). IIRC, while prices in many parts of the state fell by that much or more, prices in San Francisco did not (and the much smaller amount they did fall in SF was much later than the general bubble collapse, around 2008-2009, as a result of the general economic slowdown caused by, among other things, the collapse of the real estate bubble nationally, not because there actually was a bubble in SF particularly -- SF prices were pretty flat, IIRC, 2005-2008.)