6 ms·
Basically that (real) journalism will only live in exile? The discussion of journalism in the abstract here is missing the relatively quick changes that Snowde
by joe_the_user 13y ago
Basically that (real) journalism will only live in exile?
The discussion of journalism in the abstract here is missing the relatively quick changes that Snowden's leaks highlighted. A journalism with ties to the established parties can still be "real journalism" if you have a strong democracy in general. American "democracy" has degenerated into a circus the permanent government uses to decide which frontman serves its interest better. As this degeneration has proceeded, journalism as a part of loyal opposition has become more or less impossible.
I mean, Obama's message of "I welcome this debate and I intend to put the person who began it in solitary for the rest of his life" is par for the cynically demagogic course on both sides of the aisle.
Thus, it seems like journalism in the sense of open debate and airing dirty laundry is mostly going to live based on the soft opposition between various states, each of which may find housing it's opponents dissents to it convenience (with the truth depending on this thin and dubious reed).
- magic_haze 13y agoI wouldn't say 'exiled': it seems more like 'distributed', but still feeding off the same pool of legal/editorial/technical expertise. What Bill Keller seems to be advocating for is a central system that tries to be objective; Greenwald's system is more like a cacophony of different prejudices that users can pick and choose individually. Theoretically, the central system is better, but in practice, it has clearly been compromised. Worse is better. Edit: isn't there a sociological theory that basically says that an organization tends to be controlled by the people who care about the continuity of the organization, instead of the goals it represents? Like any bureaucracy, or unions. Omidyar's common pool of expertise will not have the same goals and incentives as the journalists. I'm curious how they're planning to address that issue.
- sker 13y ago> isn't there a sociological theory that basically says that an organization tends to be controlled by the people who care about the continuity of the organization, instead of the goals it represents? Yes, what you describe is the Iron Law of Bureaucracy. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Pournelle#Iron_Law_of_Bureaucracy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jerry_Pournelle#Iron_Law_of_Bur...
- malandrew 13y agoI'd say that the Shirky Principle also fits the bill here: http://www.kk.org/thetechnium/archives/2010/04/the_shirky_prin.php http://www.kk.org/thetechnium/archives/2010/04/the_shirky_pr...
- a3n 13y ago> isn't there a sociological theory that basically says that an organization tends to be controlled by the people who care about the continuity of the organization, instead of the goals it represents? Systemantics has something to say about that: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemantics https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Systemantics It's superficially funny and subversive at first glance, until you start thinking about its observations applied to large systems that you have worked on, and that you work and live within like BigCos and the government.
- detcader 13y agopretty much everything would be different in the US if it weren't for the two-party perpetual anti-motion machine and the buying of politicians through campaign finance and the revolving door. Greenwald probably thinks that to attack these things, we need real journalism, just as we need it to attack militarism and surveillance.
- saraid216 13y ago> American "democracy" has degenerated into a circus the permanent government uses to decide which frontman serves its interest better. Can you actually point to a period of time when things were better? Framing the problem as one of degeneration, rather than as one of inadequacy, is in my opinion one of the most critical problems with our approaches to change. It makes us look for ways to repeal implemented changes assuming that we'll regain a golden era by doing so, rather than actually looking at the situation, operating from first principles, and building something actually effective.
- alan_cx 13y ago"Can you actually point to a period of time when things were better?" Yesterday. And yesterday, the answer would have been, yesterday. And so on. Literally, day by day it gets worse. So, the day before was clearly a time when things were better.
- hackula1 13y agoBefore too long you'll hit some pretty terrible times in American democracy. McCarthyism, internment camps, slavery, trail of tears, witch burnings, and on and on all the way back to the beginning.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- saraid216 13y agoSo which changes, exactly, do you propose to rollback in order to get to yesterday? And which changes to get to the day before that? If you tell me that "day by day it gets worse", then you need to explain day by day how it gets worse, in concrete and specific detail. Otherwise you're just spouting empty rhetoric and doomsaying.
- moocowduckquack 13y agoSounds like something by the Bee-Gees.
- 13y ago
- grey-area 13y agoBasically that (real) journalism will only live in exile? Perhaps a better way to think of this is that journalism will cut its dependence on, and allegiance to, a nation state. When the internet came along, many national newspapers tried to become global papers, but without losing their geographic ties to one location, and their connections with government in that location. A journalism with ties to the established parties can still be "real journalism" if you have a strong democracy in general. I think the strong ties to established parties are exactly the problem with mainstream outlets, particularly in the United States - they inevitably lead to spiked stories, damage control via official leaks off the record, and the management of the news cycle by politicians. This has been the case for a long time, in every country, and is not limited to the current state of the US (though it has perhaps reached an extreme form there). Establishment journalism simply can't afford to take on government of the nation it primarily covers. To take a couple of examples of established news outlets - the NYT and the Guardian, despite their best efforts, are still quite parochial in their view of events across the globe. The NYT is reluctant to significantly and persistently challenge the US administration, because it would make it far more difficult for them to cover domestic news, and because for domestic consumption it's not acceptable to criticise wartime activities (for example) too heavily. The Guardian still vilifies local Conservative right-wing politicians (in the pictures they choose, in the language they use when covering them), and goes easier on those from the Labour or LibDem party - policy is actually irrelevant to this kind of partisan outlook, apparently it's simply engrained in their editorial outlook - it's like a badge of honour, an unquestioned allegiance. It is also reluctant to criticise UK forces abroad or GCHQ involvement in spying (as opposed to the US, which they're more than happy to criticise). These old labels of left and right etc don't mean much, or shouldn't mean much, to citizens, who should be looking at the actual policies. Personally I find the jingoism, nationalism and partisan reporting inherent in national news annoying and distracting. It's far harder for these newspapers to drop their existing ties to physical space, local politics, and a nation state, than it will be for newer companies founded on the internet to ignore national affiliations and become truly global organisations. A new international news won't care what the established political parties and pundits have to say on a particular issue, but does care what reporters on the ground and citizens on the ground in that country have to say, and how it contrasts with the governing party's narrative (and often the stories our governments tell us via news organisations, presented without question or fact-checking, are clearly a constructed narrative, with bad guys and good guys, for example on the killing of 16 year old Abdulrahman al-Awlaki (reported as 21 one year old terrorist), or the cruise missile strike on al-Ma'jalah (women and children reported as a terrorist training camp, cruise missiles reported as Yemeni air force)). It's very difficult to make that kind of news if you also want to be part of the White House press pool (or equivalent in other countries), have limited access, and rely on simply reporting verbatim the unreliable statements of US allies like Yemen. Compare and contrast these reports: http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/18/world/middleeast/18yemen.html http://www.nytimes.com/2009/12/18/world/middleeast/18yemen.h... http://www.democracynow.org/blog/2013/6/7/witness_to_a_massacre_yemeni_tribal_leader_recalls_how_us_attack_on_al_majalah_killed_45_civilians http://www.democracynow.org/blog/2013/6/7/witness_to_a_massa... The lie was printed right after the events, based solely on US and Yemeni gov statements, but the truth was almost the exact opposite of the story relayed by the NYTimes here. They do not often simply relay stories from the North Korean, Russian or Chinese government without question like this. I'm sure there will have been an nytimes article correcting this at some point when the truth came out, though I can't find it specifically, and by then it's too late. Much of the criticism of the administration in the nytimes is written by outsiders (not journalists), relegated to the op-ed pages, and labelled as 'opinion', when it in fact contains more truth than the official reporting.