6 ms·
A Tour of a Whole Country That Has 'Transformed Itself for Cycling'
- wolf550e 13y agoIs there car access to the houses? for emergency services for example?
- hengheng 13y agoYes. In the Netherlands for example, bi-directional bike paths have to be 4 meters wide, which is sufficient for emergency vehicles.
- Nux 13y agoThis is pretty, pretty awesome!
- roel_v 13y agoActually we haven't transformed, we've never accomodated cars much at all. A big difference.
- Someone 13y agoThat is not quite true. In some cases, the idea of building for cars was abandoned before it got fully executed, but that didn't always happen. Examples: In Amsterdam, the Vijzelgracht was turned into a highway into the centre of town (it's hard to imagine, but about half of Amsterdam's waterways have been filled in to make room for traffic (much of this predates car traffic). Even as late as the '50s, there was a plan to fill many canals to make room for parking garages). Utrecht had plans to fill its outer moat to make room for a ring road. Part of the Catharijnesingel was filled in 1970 or thereabouts to build 'the shortest highway in the Netherlands', but afterwards, the plan was luckily abandoned (the Catharijnesingel will be dug again in a few years) Residential neighborhoods built in the '60s were designed first for cars (http://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2013/08/08/making-a-1960s-street-grid-fit-for-the-21st-century/ http://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/2013/08/08/making-a-1960s-...) Rotterdam, after the bombing in 1940, rebuilt its city plan to accommodate for cars.
- roel_v 13y agoYes I know, of course, and obviously there are ways for cars to get to places, but the mere fact that you can name specific counterexamples confirms my point that in general most places were not designed around wide spread car ownership and -use, and car use was retrofitted where needed. Not to be an asshole about it but I'm a Dutch planning professional, I've lectured and published about the effects of transport infrastructure on urban planning.
- URSpider94 13y agoRoel, since you're an expert -- can you help shed light on the history? From what I've read, other demographically and geographically similar countries in Europe have much lower rates of cycling. These other countries were undoubtably also not designed for cars, they were designed for horses and pedestrians (as I can attest from having driven in Europe). The source materials that I've read suggest that there was a major inflection point in the 1970's where bike transport share stopped declining and started increasing, and also that the linear miles of bike path have increased dramatically (3x?) in the past 20 years.
- Someone 13y agoThat's from http://bicycledutch.wordpress.com http://bicycledutch.wordpress.com (http://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/index-by-theme http://bicycledutch.wordpress.com/index-by-theme is an excellent entry point, too) My layman's view is that both sides are right. Most city centers date from before 1900, so they weren't designed for cars (Amsterdam wasn't even designed for carriages). Up to ~end of World War two~, cars weren't common enough to build 'cars first; all others enter at your own risk' neighborhoods (for example, the first river car tunnel, the Maastunnel in Rotterdam (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maastunnel http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Maastunnel), built in 1937-1942 has separate tubes for cyclists and pedestrians. Traffic jams formed at its escalators in the fifties) After World War Two, there was a period when the USA seemed to show the future. That led to ideas that cities such as LA were the future of city building. Some ideas/attempts to reshape cities were formed/made, but those were abandoned or at least seriously adjusted really soon. For example, the Bijlmer (1968; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bijlmer http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bijlmer) was designed as a paradise for cars, but also as one for pedestrians. In the same period, Ommoord also is very car friendly. Yet, its neighborhoods also have the typical dead end streets that make streets safer for kids to play in, and it has a metro connection to the center of Rotterdam. Almere (1978; http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almere http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Almere) already shows a trend away from 'cars first'. Later, we got Houten (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Houten http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Houten) So, yes, there was a trend towards 'cars first', and there was a turn, but that turn was made very early. That made the turn relatively easy. Changing LA into a 'cars are guests' city would be a challenge on a different scale.
- wsc981 13y agoFrom what I understand, we actually did transform into a much more suitable country for cycling during the 70s (~10 years before I was born). I'll try to look up the video that explains. Ah found it: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuBdf9jYj7o http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XuBdf9jYj7o
- VeejayRampay 13y agoThe Netherlands are at the forefront of thinking for a lot of different social/environmental issues and everybody recognizes that in Europe, but the funny thing is that the Dutch I've talked to have a hard time recognizing that themselves.
- gaius 13y agoThe Dutch are relaxed about sex and drugs, but they are actually a very conservative people with deep and cherished traditions. It's only in America that "conservative" implies prudish, everywhere else it just means that people want to go on living the way they always have.
- coldcode 13y agoThat would work really well here in Texas. My job takes me nearly an hour to reach by car. You can basically fit all of Europe in Texas with a little rearrangement. Scale matters.
- maxerickson 13y agoDoes the scale matter? I can see the availability of space putting pressure on such projects, because lower property costs will take precedence over something that is considered a fringe lifestyle, but I thought the usual reason it is impossible to bike in Texas was the weather. With less snide, I don't see why a bike friendly neighborhood would cause any extra problems for a Texan.
- bane 13y agoSupposing weather wasn't a factor, yes scale matters a lot. The metro area I live and work covers something like over 10,000 square miles (>25,000 square km or about 12.5 times the area of the Amsterdam metro area or more than half of all of the area of the Netherlands) and almost 10 million people. Jobs and living locations rarely intersect for more than a year or two at a time, plus my wife has her own career and work locations. I do not live near even a top-20 U.S. city. The job I work today has multiple work locations right now, 10.5 miles, 35 miles and 60 miles from my home. The 10.5 mile site, while possible for biking distance-wise, is also the site of my customer's management. Showing up in a sweaty suit from an 17 km ride on a bike simply won't work and it's not like there's a shower and changing area for me there. My previous job had two locations, 5 miles and 15 miles away from my home, but in completely different directions than this one. My next job might have completely different work locations 20 or 30 miles in any different direction. I can't simply pick up my entire family and move a reasonable bike ride away from my work site. Or the contracts I perform work on might change and my work sites will change drastically even with the current job. My wife also works and has her own location dynamics, 12 miles, and 25 miles away. If I were to move close to one of my work sites, it would drastically increase hers.
- maxerickson 13y ago
- slimbods 13y agoIt is ace, but I wonder if you'd get cycling as mainstream anywhere else. That country is almost uniquely and famously flat.
- Pxtl 13y agosigh Every time people post about great cycling cities, the immediate reaction is a pile of reasons why it would never work here because I live in a place that's completely different and special. There are challenges in every task. Either you overcome them or you wimp out. These are not unsolved problems. Montreal literally means Mount Royal - it's a city built around a mountain. They manage to have great cycling infrastructure. Even worse is the moaning about winter cyclists - almost every one of the great cycling cities have bitter winters. You're always going to have an excuse not to do something.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoCycling in Chongqing would be a bit hard; even when China was the "bicycle" kingdom people rarely peddled in one of the world's hilliest cities.
- slimbods 13y agoI'm not looking for an excuse not to cycle, I'm a pretty fit cyclist and spend at least 10 hours a week on a bike. I'm saying that holding this up as an example that others can follow isn't ideal as they have a big natural advantage over practically anywhere else. Unless you can overcome the issues of terrain and climate, it's just not going to become mainstream like it has there. Look at the bikes they're riding, big heavy comfortable clunkers. Most people simply couldn't get those up the hills surrounding my town, they'd have to push.
- MattLaroche 13y agoAs a cyclist, I'm sure you already know this. Properly geared, bikes aren't hard to get up hills - they're just slow.
- 13y ago
- arbuge 13y agoDallas, where I live now, is about as far away from this as one can imagine. For that matter, so is the European country I'm originally from (Malta). My brother is an avid cyclist there and gets sneered at by local-redneck-equivalent motorists pretty much everywhere he goes.
- doorhammer 13y agoI used to do the wind/rain/snow type commuting, and I probably should again, but your brother's experience in Malta is similar to mine in the US. You're definitely doing something that most people regard as a nuisance. I've heard of other cities where it's not like that, but I've just never ridden in them. I live in Atlanta now, and it's almost suicidal riding a bike. Obs my sample size of cities is small, but hey, there it is for what it's worth. The video also made me think, "Man, I'd love to cycle in the places, but I'd have to seriously rearrange my US cycling survival skills and attitude toward a less hostile environment."
- bane 13y agoAlmost seems utopic. Rather than look for excuses as to why it won't work in the U.S., what would it take (years, dollars, planning, infrastructure) to convert a reasonably sized (large, but not top 10) American city built for cars (say Austin, Indianapolis, Columbus, Denver), into a cycling focused city?
- babesh 13y agoWhat do people do when it rains or snows? Do people walk instead, take mass transit, or drive? I think the reality of what people are arguing for is for people to live more closely together. That makes biking, mass transit, and even walking more viable. Some people like it, some don't. Part is what you are used to. People coming from rural areas think that the Bay Area is crowded but the East Coast is more crowded, parts of Europe are more crowded still, and then parts of Asia are more crowded still.
- MattLaroche 13y agoPut on some fenders, rain pants, a rain coat, and ride! Or take transit. Living closer together is great, but cycling infrastructure matters too to get people onto bikes.
- arethuza 13y agoThat's a new difference between US and UK English for me - "fenders" here are things that are used to stop boats/ships bumping into things, across here we call them "mudguards". Having said that, I know some people who could benefit from fenders (UK) on their bikes...
- yoodenvranx 13y ago> What do people do when it rains or snows? Do people walk instead, take mass transit, or drive? I live in Northern Germany and for the last 20 years I used my bike to first drive to school, then to university and now to my workplace. On average I drive about 10 to 15 km a day for commuting and perhaps another few km for shopping and going out in the evening. I can not remember a single day were I did not drive bike because the weather bad. Even two or three winters ago when the streets were covered with ice for 4 weeks driving to work with a bike was not a problem at all. Some stuff I learned: * buy high quality mudguards * use a hub dynamo (Shimano or SON) and not these horrible cheap one which touch the wheels * invest 80 euro in a really really good LED front light (I am a big fan of Busch & Müller, those things are really bright and switch on automatically when it is getting dark) * for snow and ice buy some spike tires. If you are a bit careful and experienced you can drive over pure ice without any problems. They cost 60 euro per piece but you can use them for 3 or 4 winters * for normal weather buy some tires with protection against glass and other sharp objects. I have a pair of Schwalbe Marathon Plus and I never had a flat tire in the last 6 or 7 years * buy the most expensive lock you can find (Abus or Kryptonite) and always lock your bike to something * always have a set of dry clothing at your workplace just in case the rain is really bad. * some people buy special rain pants but I personally don't like/need them * buy and wear a helmet * install a fender rack to which you can install some bike bag (I am a big fan of everthing from Ortlieb) With the right gear driving in bad weather is not a problem. Sometimes it isn't fun but I am grateful that I am not dependent on a car! But what matters most is the infrastructure. Driving bike in Germany is really nice most if the time. But when I lived in the midwest in the US in a smallish town I was one of very few ciclyst in town and driving bike there sucked a lot.
- URSpider94 13y agoI spent three weeks in the Netherlands with my family this summer. The cycling experience is truly magical. To add to some other comments made in this thread: -- Roel appears to have knowledge in this area, so I don't want to contradict him, but it does seem that the Dutch went at least part-way down the path towards a car-focused society and successfully pulled back. Read http://www.roadswerenotbuiltforcars.com/netherlands/ http://www.roadswerenotbuiltforcars.com/netherlands/ for more history. -- The "bike path" in my town that we celebrate as amazing would be derided as complete crap in Holland. It's too narrow, not well paved, not lit at night, and it's mixed-use, which means you have to dodge pedestrians, roller bladers, dog walkers, etc. Bike paths in the Netherlands are BIKE ONLY. Not only are you separated from cars, but also from pedestrians. One of the worst crimes as a pedestrian (and a sure sign of a tourist) is to stand in the bike lane. -- Cycling is not just a fair weather activity. Nearly all bikes are equipped with dynamos to power lights, which are legally mandated for riding at night and are useful in the fall/winter fog and gloom. Yes, people ride in the rain, and even in the snow. For most people, biking is the one and only way to get around, so it's not an option, it's a requirement. -- It's hard to comprehend how thoroughly bikes are integrated into society. Every office has a bike parking shed with racks and locks. Apartment buildings have storage rooms in the basement, with special ramps built into the stairways so you can roll bikes down the hill. Train stations have massive bike storage areas, and most stations have both bike rentals and also repair stations. For an extra 6 Euros, you can take your bike on the train with you to go anywhere in the country, and if you have a folding bike (very common), you can take it on the train for free. -- Cycling is integrated into daily life. No Lycra and clipless pedals -- you cycle in street clothes. Bikes are upright and comfortable. Nobody wears helmets, even kids (our kids went nuts because we made them wear them ...) People ride at a good clip, 10-12 mph, fast enough to get there, but not so fast that they get sweaty or out of breath. When you run across a friend or co-worker on the bike path, you'll typically pull up next to them and ride two-abreast (the paths are wide enough) so that you can talk and ride. My favorite thing: you'll often see older couples riding side by side holding hands. Man, I would love to see this take hold in the US, but it will take a major change not just in public opinion, but also in city planning and infrastructure investment.
- slimbods 13y ago
- pontifier 13y agoI was there in June, and I have to say that riding around on a bike there really changed my perspective. Riding there was a joy. The "Share the Road" programs here in Utah are a joke. The bike lanes there were amazing. Most roads I saw there were dark brick, the "lines" were usually white bricks, and the bike lanes were red brick and were wide where they weren't actually separate altogether. The other best part? There were no angry SUV drivers swerving around you at 60 MPH. People were courteous.