6 ms·
I seriously don't understand the praise of Hofstadter in the article and in the comments here, and the criticism of the mainstream AI research, especially it is
by joe_the_user 13y ago
I seriously don't understand the praise of Hofstadter in the article and in the comments here, and the criticism of the mainstream AI research, especially it is very hard to find any precise details of what he does and what are the outcomes.
Uh Yeah, you don't understand "Hostadter", you can't be bothered to spell his name right, but you're willing to attack him.
Just FYI, Hofstadter was never in the mainstream of GOFAI but always advocate something of a different path; a path not taken - for good or ill but not the same path as you caricature. You might take notice that your link makes no mention of Hofstadter, for example. Hofstadter's work on analogies, for example, was by no means a pure symbolic approach.
And the rest your post is thus ... ignorant and irrelevant [Edit: by the fact that it's not about Hofstadter, just someone's critique of someone else' AI grr]. Kind of an embarrassment having it here.
- stiff 13y agoI will listen with great interest if you then care to explain to me what is the great discovery Hofstadter made in the field of AI. I believe he is rooted in the GOFAI tradition, because he tries to understand intelligence by introspection, and I happen to believe this is impossible, since what we are aware of consciously is just a surface level result of processes in the brain we are completely unconscious of. Whatever descriptions of his work I can find, sound pretty much like GOFAI too - you just come up with a program that does something supposedly intelligent: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluid_Concepts_and_Creative_Analogies http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fluid_Concepts_and_Creative_Ana... I am also not attacking him, I am just sceptical, as I would be if someone who is not working in mainstream physics and is ignored by it claimed a breakthrough in understanding matter or whatever.