2 ms·
Noted a few other things: Their manual/documentations has no mentioning of BSD licensed software. While its possible that bsd license is included in paper form
by belorn 13y ago
Noted a few other things:
Their manual/documentations has no mentioning of BSD licensed software. While its possible that bsd license is included in paper form with the devices with reference to each software package, it is unlikely. As such, 99% sure that Kogan is violating BSD licensed software too.
Kogan is aware that they are using open source software (http://www.kogan.com/uk/newsroom/kogan-releases-119-android-tablet-55/ http://www.kogan.com/uk/newsroom/kogan-releases-119-android-...), as is indicated by their press releases. As such, if an infringement is found, it likely to be seen as intentionally and willingly regarding that product.
Otherwise, it seems as a common misunderstanding by Kogan in how one provide source code to users. Its not very complicated, but hand waving users towards Google is not enough. Had the kernel been gplv3, then they could just given the user a link, but since the kernel is gplv2, the options are either a written offer for minimum 3 years or to include the source code alongside the binaries. GPLv3 changed the license text regarding source distribution because they did not want to still live in 1990s.
Kernel drivers however are a separate issue as the primary author of the kernel (Linus) has given explicit permission to produce "some form" of drivers without having to follow the license. For most people, that is enough safety against lawsuits, even if copyright do not care who is the primary author, and gives equal copyright rights to each author of a project.
- blueblob 13y agoThis is quite a good answer to my other comment as well. Thanks!
- Dylan16807 13y agoSo if I'm reading you right, they are in full compliance of the improved GPL terms that don't apply in this case. Meaning their noncompliance is an accident of history, not a violation of the spirit of the license. In that case, I don't see why anyone should care.