8 ms·
Americans Fall Behind In The 'Getting Older' Race
- scotch_drinker 13y ago"To my surprise, they found our health disadvantage 'could not be explained simply by reference to problems associated with an inefficient health care system, the lack of universal health care coverage, or large racial and socioeconomic disparities in the United States.'" That doesn't seem to address the fact that as a nation, the US seems to be growing more and more obese with worse nutrition and less exercise. I assume the authors of the paper did some analysis based on things other than the inefficient health care system.
- sp332 13y agoI'm not sure that would explain a drop specifically in 55-to-75 year old people, even though we're competitive in other areas?
- Shivetya 13y agoSure, look at how much assistance has increased, especially SSID payments. Plus throw in that getting back in the door post 50 is not so simple. Don't have anything to do all day? Eating is a refuge for many.
- scotch_drinker 13y agoIt might if the reasons we were dying between 55-75 were related to poor nutrition and low activity levels. My assumption (always dangerous) is that the things that kill us in those age ranges are diabetes, heart disease and stroke which are all manageable in some fashion through moderation in diet as well as exercise. Once you make it past 75, you've probably been either lucky genetically or you've been living well or some combination of the two.
- Theodores 13y agoI believe that American diet may have a hand in this. I don't know when it happened exactly, maybe it was when the new Coke formula came in, however, since then an increasing amount of Americans have been 'corn fed'. The meat is corn fed, the breakfast cereal is made of corn, the milk is from corn fed cows, the sugar is made from corn and everything else is made from corn give or take a soy bean here or there. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dBnniua6-oM Robert Lustig is the man to explain all this. He blames fructose (i.e. corn stuff) and fully expects this generation of Americans to have a shorter lifespan than previous generations could expect.
- bluedino 13y agoWe just eat too damn much. Any chain restaurant has 1,4000 calorie 'salads' and you get served 2+ lbs in a pasta dish. That doesn't even count the appetizer or dessert that cram down your throat for the $12.99 3-course meal
- humanrebar 13y agoBefore everyone goes on about American healthcare and obesity, consider what the numbers are actually measuring. As far as I can tell from the article, these life expectancy numbers do not compensate for suicide, homicide, premature births (some countries don't count them as births), and accidental death (as in car accidents). I would like to see more of the same charts, but instead of just graphing life expectancy at birth, graph life expectancy from ages 1, 11, 21, 31, 41, and so on. I would compare the "Life Expectancy from Age X" graph for the U.S. against the same graphs for other countries. Then I would look at leading causes of death for each age group in the U.S. Then I would have a much more quantifiable idea of why citizens in other countries tend to live longer than U.S. citizens. Here's an interesting podcasts where a couple of economists discuss this kind of metric as a measure of longevity and health: http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/07/scott_atlas_on.html http://www.econtalk.org/archives/2012/07/scott_atlas_on.html EDIT: This is important because counting thousands of premature births and having a much higher rate of death due to accidents and violence will really wreck the U.S. average. In that case, talking about how Americans eat too much red meat is mostly beside the point.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I would like to see more of the same charts, but instead of just graphing life expectancy at birth, graph life expectancy from ages 1, 11, 21, 31, 41, and so on. I would compare the "Life Expectancy from Age X" graph for the U.S. against the same graphs for other countries. The article itself notes: In 2011, the National Institutes of Health issued a report that tried to make sense of it all. Right away, they found our weak spot. "U.S. women have relatively high mortality rates at the younger older ages," they said, which means when women hit their 55th birthdays, for the next almost 20 years, roughly 55 to 75, they will die more often than women in comparable countries. Americans get more lung disease, more heart disease, more diabetes. If Americans reach 75, they get competitive again, but that early old age is where we lose ground. American men showed pretty much the same weakness at roughly the same times. And the NIH study [1] linked in the article actually has the kind of charts that you suggest should be done comparing life expectancy at various ages. It would maybe help if instead of reciting canned arguments based assumptions generated by the title, people would actually read the linked articles. [1] http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK62373/ http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/books/NBK62373/
- BetaCygni 13y ago> "these levels represent increases in average life spans of almost five months for women and four months for men compared to the previous year." Let's get it up to twelve months per year!
- sp332 13y agoAs far as I can tell, these graphs only show the average age of people who are dying in a given year. If someone survives, they won't count as an improvement! So to inflate the graphs, we just have to kill off all the really old people :)
- EGreg 13y agoI think life expectancy is increasing across the board in the world, but race plays a difference. America is home to a lot of different races. Look at the races of the population over 80 and how it changed since 1950s.
- drjesusphd 13y agoA lot has changed since the 1950s. Correlation != causation. Besides, race and poverty are so closely linked in the US that, even if this were true, it still doesn't say anything about the intrinsic properties of different races. Implying that it does is a racist statement.
- EGreg 13y agoSaying that members of some races are shorter on aberage than others may be "racist" in some sense, but it's also informative. Same with life expectancy. Now how much of it is genetic vs lifestyle and cultural is a different story. It's not easy to tease apart genotype vs phenotype arguments or nature vs nurture. But I don't think I would take offense to ACTUALLY 90% TRUE generalizations about MY race and ethnicity, and I don't think others should, either. That's different than saying POTENTIALY UNTRUE things based on anecdotal evidence, such as that Mexicans are usually bad at physics, that women bad at programming or that Jews are averse to taking low paid menial jobs. Disclaimer: I am Jewish. But I have no issue discussing things dispassionately like that. However I am sensitive to how they are presented, and MORE imporyantly careful ny to perpetuate harmful stereotypes that are possibly untrue or may cause people to actually suffer as a result.
- jandrewrogers 13y agoI am surprised that the article did not really mention why American life expectancy is relatively low. The answer to this question is well-known and is a related to a unique negative bias in the American statistics rather than older Americans dying earlier. Put simply, Americans have an anomalously high rate of dying when they are young due to homicide and accidents, particularly vehicular. These are large statistical outliers compared to the rest of the industrialized world. This negatively alters the average life expectancy but does not say much about the life expectancy in the individual case. If you control for just homicide and vehicular accidents, Americans have among the highest life expectancy in the world despite issues like obesity, and many Americans have negligible risk of those causes of premature death. In terms of deaths due to medical issues (cancer, heart disease, etc), Americans have the highest life expectancy in the world, which offsets the homicide and accident death rates among the young. There used to be a saying by the people that study life expectancy statistics that the only people on Earth that live longer than Japanese women are Japanese women living in the US. Which is true and captured an essential point about the mixture of factors in life expectancy statistics.
- tptacek 13y agoAs I understand it, life expectancy is also skewed by misreporting of infant deaths in other countries, which biases infant mortality stats against countries that reliably report them.
- stusmith1977 13y agoThe article compares to other first world countries, where I seriously doubt there is a problem with (under-)reporting infant deaths.
- tptacek 13y agoAre you sure about that? The issue isn't that people don't care if infants die, but that infant fatalities occurring quickly after birth can be declared "stillbirths", and that there aren't standards for that distinction.
- michael_nielsen 13y agoA little research (sources at end) shows that the many commenters pointing to vehicular accidents, homicide, infant mortality, and suicide as the "reason" for lower US life expectancy are flat-out wrong: Each year the chance of someone dying in a vehicular accident is about 1 in 10,000 in the US. Over 80 years that means a citizen has roughly a 1 / 125 chance of dying in a vehicular accident. The total reduction in life expectancy from vehicular accidents is thus well under 1.0 years. Assume, for example that such an accident cuts an average of 60 years off a person's life -- they would have lived to 80, say, but their life was cut short at just 20 years old. That works out as a 0.5 year reduction in life expectancy due to accidents. This is without taking into account the vehicular fatality rates in other countries. When you do that for, e.g., Japan (1 in 20,000 per year), the difference in life expectancy is likely around 0.25 years. The homicide rate in the US is about 1 in 20,000 people per year, or about half the vehicular fatality rate, so perhaps a further 0.25 year reduction, without factoring in homicides in other countries. For infant mortality, the chance of dying at birth is a little over 1 in 200 in the US. That translates to a reduction in life expectancy of about 0.4 years, without factoring in infant mortality in other countries. A similar analysis shows suicide rates are probably not a factor -- in fact, in some countries, such as Japan, the rate is higher than in the US, while in countries such as the UK it is comparable to the US. So the contributions from all four of these sources is very unlikely to be more than a 1 year difference in life expectancy. It's probably quite a bit less, since I've ignored (e.g.) infant mortality in other countries. Certainly, the contribution from all four of these is nowhere near the dominant effect to explain differences in life expectancy. A caveat: some people pointing to infant mortality are claiming that what's going on is that a large number of stillbirths simply aren't being reported in some countries outside the US, and this is skewing the results. That possibility isn't accounted for in my analysis above. I doubt it's true - in my many years living in Canada and Australia I've known quite a few people who died in car accidents, and none of whom had a stillbirth (to my knowledge). But while this suggests to me that this effect isn't large, it's of course only anecdotal evidence. Sources for rates: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentional_homicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_intentiona... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-related_death_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_traffic-re... http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mortality_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_infant_mor... And if you want to look at the details of the suicide statistics: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_rate http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_countries_by_suicide_ra...
- 16s 13y agoReminds me of an answer my old boss gave to a terminally ill patient... "How long does it take to die?" "A lifetime."
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]