9 ms·
Wikipedia editors, locked in battle with PR firm, delete 250 accounts
- jedanbik 13y agoCouldn't help but laugh when I saw the Wiki-PR affiliates page: https://www.wiki-pr.com/affiliates/ https://www.wiki-pr.com/affiliates/ OUR AFFILIATES MAKE BIG MONEY. <...> Just leave us your name.
- CJefferson 13y agoI would be extremely surprised if (quoting from article) it is only "as many as several hundred" accounts are being used by people paid to edit Wikipedia. I know at least a dozen people who have a wikipedia account just to edit articles to make where they work look good (I suppose it is not their full time job, but it is the only reason they edit wikipedia).
- jff 13y agoIs it unethical for, say, a company's "media guy" to update Wikipedia if his company releases a major new project? "On October 1, 2013, Initech released version 2.0 of its flagship product IniIDE Pro(tm)" I think there's a line to draw between adding some pertinent information to keep the page from being outdated, vs. fighting to keep all negative information off the page.
- phdp 13y agoIf it's really newsworthy, wouldn't someone else not related to the company do that?
- jff 13y agoI'm not a wikipedia editor, so they may think of things differently, but when I see a news story about a company, I generally think, "Interesting." I don't think, "Ooh, I better check if this is in their Wikipedia article yet." Now, maybe the most devout of wikifiddlers will do that, but why not just make it part of your process? If it's not notable, presumably someone will delete that bit eventually. It's better than going to an article and finding that there's no news since 2009 or whenever the article was first written.
- phdp 13y agoMaybe if there's a process for a pull-request like feature, similar to github, but what a company thinks is newsworthy may not be, or it may be newsworthy for a different reason than the company thinks it is, like a product that exploded on the launch day.
- chris_wot 13y agoBorderline really. There are clear conflict of Internet guidelines for the project, whilst that isn't an egregious example, I would counsel anyone working for a company to avoid editing any articles related to their company. The PR mess you might cause (even for innocent edits) could well outweigh any gains you may have achieved. The best thing is to participate on talk pages. Even there, be careful not to respond to inflammatory comments or trolls.
- smsm42 13y agoWhy? What is unethical about providing the truthful and correct information about company and products? I would understand that if Wikipedia banned all commercial product information, but it does not. So why it is OK for unknown schoolkid (random example) to edit a page with the list of, say, Cisco products (random example), but it's not OK for a person working for Cisco who actually knows what he's talking about and has access to most accurate, correct and up-to-date information possible? Wikipedia requires reputable sources - which means the said schoolkid would be copypasting some info from somewhere anyway - so what's wrong with the most authoritative sources - people actually making things it describes and knowing everything about them?
- chris_wot 13y agoFor the same reason that we frown on politicians from accepting money for making ethical decisions. The issue is that the Wikipedia community do not know whether the information is slanted towards a positive viewpoint by an interested party. In fact, seemingly neutral information may often gloss over important information or give undue positive weight towards a subject. I would suggest reading up on Wikipedia's information on this subject at http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Conflict_of_interest - it's very informative and should answer most of these questions.
- smsm42 13y agoBad analogy. If you want to make better analogy, you'd say it's unethical for a politician to give an interview about his own party or write a newspaper column about his own political platform, because that is self-promotion and creates conflict of interests, and makes him gloss over negative sides of his policies and give undue positive weight towards the subject. Sounds silly, right, politicians do that all the time, that's the name of the game. Of course, editing process can be abused by interested parties - politicians can lie to advance their causes, and wikipedia editors can be (and sometimes are) driven by motives very different from the quest for pure and accurate knowledge. However this can and is happening without any employment relationship, and employment relationship does not add much to it - one can be non-neutral by thousand other reasons (e.g. N happens to be a fan of certain ice hokey team and rewrites its Wikipedia article to extoll its virtues in excess). It seems as one of these reasons - a very real one, but definitely not unique - is being singled out. Is it because money is the root of all evil?
- dm2 13y agoIt's fine to add information. It's not ok to remove negative information. What about listing a company under the product or category page or placing subtle advertisements on the page? An example would be Nest adding links to their wikipedia to the Thermostat wikipedia page. Is that ethical? Is it legal? Is it against wikipedias Terms of Use?
- eli 13y agoSeems like an awfully fine line. What if the negative information is unfair or even false?
- dm2 13y agoNegative information such as criticisms or controversy, such as http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft#Criticism http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Microsoft#Criticism They must obviously have a reputable source.
- DanBC 13y ago> It's not ok to remove negative information. Why? The BLP stuff has been clear and firm for years: Anything that is unsourced should be removed quickly, especially if it's BLP. Obviously, removal of suitably sourced material is a problem so I agree there.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- sbov 13y agoDepending upon how far the PR firm goes to circumvent their block, couldn't they be brought up on hacking charges? Could the companies that hire them be found culpable too?
- rhizome 13y agocouldn't they be brought up on hacking charges Which ones?
- DanBC 13y agoThey've been told not to edit wikipedia. They're continuing to edit wikipedia. That seems pretty clearly like accessing a computer system without the owner's permission, which feels like it should be a standard bit of law.
- rhizome 13y ago"Seems," and, "feels," are not enough.
- DanBC 13y agoI'd be interested to hear what US lawyers would say, but using a computer without permission is pretty much the definition used worldwide in hacking laws. http://www.ncsl.org/research/telecommunications-and-information-technology/computer-hacking-and-unauthorized-access-laws.aspx http://www.ncsl.org/research/telecommunications-and-informat... > Hacking is breaking into computer systems, frequently with intentions to alter or modify existing settings. Sometimes malicious in nature, these break-ins may cause damage or disruption to computer systems or networks. People with malevolent intent are often referred to as "crackers"--as in "cracking" into computers. > "Unauthorized access" entails approaching, trespassing within, communicating with, storing data in, retrieving data from, or otherwise intercepting and changing computer resources without consent. These laws relate to either or both, or any other actions that interfere with computers, systems, programs or networks.
- parennoob 13y agoTheir list of services https://www.wiki-pr.com/services/ https://www.wiki-pr.com/services/ looks like a corporate shill's sick mockery of Wikipedia's community standards. I hope every single one of their spurious sockpuppet accounts get deleted.
- pvnick 13y agoIn addition, here is their leadership team (https://www.wiki-pr.com/leadership/ https://www.wiki-pr.com/leadership/): "DARIUS FISHER Co-Founder, Chief Operations Officer Darius co-founded Wiki-PR in 2010 after working alongside a crisis communication consultant in San Francisco. As the crisis unfolded, Darius' clients got libeled online. Darius recognized the importance of presenting his clients fairly, accurately, and professionally on Wikipedia. He has since built Wiki-PR into the largest Wikipedia public relations firm. Darius graduated with a degree in Economics from Vanderbilt University. JORDAN FRENCH Co-Founder, Chief Executive Officer Jordan leads Wiki-PR from its headquarters in Austin, Texas. He heads Wiki-PR's Page Management and Crisis Editing teams. Jordan is formerly an attorney and an engineer. Jordan is licensed to practice law in New York and Massachusetts. He earned his law degree from Washington University in St. Louis and his engineering degree from Vanderbilt. STEVE NEIL Chief Financial Officer Prior to joining Wiki-PR, Steve served as the CFO of Diamond Foods, maker of Kettle Brand potato chips and Pop Secret popcorn. Steve has over 30 years experience managing operations, logistics, and finances for publicly traded companies. Steve acquired his bachelors degree from UC Santa Barbara and his MBA from UCLA. ADAM MASONBRINK Vice President of Sales Adam manages sales and business development from Wiki-PR's office in San Francisco, California. Prior to working with Wiki-PR, Adam held senior sales roles at Google, Intuit, and several Bay Area startups. Adam graduated from University of Kansas with a degree in business communications and entrepreneurship." Hopefully this kind of blatantly unethical behavior follows them around a bit. I don't wish the end of a career upon anybody, but maybe a few doors end up closing for some of these folks that would have otherwise been open.
- at-fates-hands 13y ago>> Darius' clients got libeled online. Darius recognized the importance of presenting his clients fairly, accurately, and professionally on Wikipedia. Yes, because when I have a client who gets libeled online, the first thing I need to do is create an honest Wikipedia page. Seriously, WTF? It's too bad they've suckered so many people into thinking they could control their online brand through Wikipedia.
- swalling 13y agoRelated post previously on the front page: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6580333 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6580333
- DanBC 13y agoThese paid editing services are obviously lousy and harmful to Wikipedia and it's great that they've gone. How well did average wikipedians deal with the editors and their clients? Was anyone turned into a useful editor? Or were more people left frustrated and baffled by the WP process?
- Nicholas_C 13y ago>"I'm much more worried about what happens when an unethical outfit manages to start getting major clients and start controlling articles that our average reader assumes are not written by corporate flaks." Or worse, if Wikipedia's trustworthiness is tarnished beyond repair. I remember when I was in high school 5 or 6 years back Wikipedia was kind of seen as a joke by my peers. Now it's taken as near fact. Although I think skepticism of anything read on the Internet or elsewhere is healthy, I would hate to see it revert to the first state because of greedy "PR" firms.
- mjn 13y agoA hope that's admittedly probably wildly optimistic is that Wikipedia could help people get better at critically evaluating sources, since everyone knows you are not "supposed" to take it completely uncritically on the basis of the publisher's authority. If you get some familiarity with it gets reasonably easy to spot which articles have something strange about them. Sometimes it's the writing style, sometimes the tone that clearly sounds like advocacy or PR copy rather than encyclopedia copy, sometimes the absence of or particular choice of references, etc. I tend to also start with strong prior skepticism depending on the area, e.g. articles on present-day companies, but not ones big enough to attract a lot of real editors (unlike Google, Microsoft, etc., which do) are inherently suspect for paid editing, while articles on mathematics, whatever other problems they might have, typically don't ring my "might be a PR shill" warning bell. Can be useful even outside of Wikipedia! Distinguishing between trade-nonfiction books honestly trying to cover a subject, versus trade-nonfiction books that are thinly veiled ads for a piece of technology (or the author's management/diet/etc. consulting gig), has some similarities.
- eru 13y agoArticles on math and physics might just be plain wrong, though. (Especially the `entropy' article, since every armchair physicist wants to contribute.)
- makomk 13y agoThat might not be such a bad thing. Wikipedia isn't exactly trustworthy even without paid editing by PR folks; the Wikipedia pages of journalists who criticise them tend to turn into hatchet jobs for instance.
- tokenadult 13y agoI hope, as a Wikipedian since April 2010, that this is the beginning of a thorough change of culture on Wikipedia in the interest of making Wikipedia more of a genuine free online encyclopedia[1] and less of a publicity platform for everyone who doesn't want to pay honest cash money for a paid advertisement. There is currently a proposal discussed among Wikipedians for a tighter policy against paid editing,[2] and as long as the new policy, whatever it ends up being, makes for less promotional content on Wikipedia, I'm all for it. People who want to help Wikipedia improve as unpaid volunteers have a number of channels for doing that. One thing that would help Wikipedia's goal of better content quality[3] is adding more reliable sources to articles. I try to help that process by compiling source lists in user space that any Wikipedian can use for updating articles.[4] It's a long slog to fight the rot on Wikipedia. Reading Wikipedia takes a sharp eye for propaganda and advertising in disguise. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Here_to_build_an_encyclopedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia:Here_to_build_an_enc... [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:Paid_editing_policy_proposal https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia_talk:Paid_editing_po... [3] https://strategy.wikimedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Plan/Movement_Priorities#Improve_Content_Quality https://strategy.wikimedia.org/wiki/Strategic_Plan/Movement_... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia#Accuracy_of_content https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Wikipedia#Accuracy_of_content [4] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:WeijiBaikeBianji/IntelligenceCitations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:WeijiBaikeBianji/Intellig... https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:WeijiBaikeBianji/AnthropologyHumanBiologyRaceCitations https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/User:WeijiBaikeBianji/Anthropo...
- snowwrestler 13y agoI hope that Wikipedia's culture someday acknowledges that money is not the only corrupting influence in a society. Some of the most egregious examples of biased editing I've seen on Wikipedia were almost certainly not paid for; they were the result of deeply held personal beliefs about politics and religion. Inaccurate or blatantly false edits of this type are easy to get into Wikipedia articles because politics and religion have thousands of highly biased third party "news" sources, so almost any ridiculous claim can be supported with a citation.
- raganwald 13y agoThis should be fixed the old-fashioned way: By cutting off teh flow of money at the source. When clients are caught directly or indirectly using sock-puppetry and astroturfing on Wikipedia, banners should be added to the affected pages naming and shaming the clients. "This page has been locked by Wikipedia in response to deceptive practices paid for by Engulf and Devour to circumvent our community standards and mislead readers." If you want this to stop, you have to give the clients a disincentive. That will drive the good clients out and these firms will be left with erectile dysfunction flim-flam as their market.
- candybar 13y agoThis goes into libel territory - Wikipedia presumably doesn't have the resources or authority to investigate and fully ascertain who paid for what.
- asperous 13y agoThat's why it's important to have a 3rd party publish the rumor first, then they can cite that and pass the literary libel liability laterally.
- 0xndc 13y agoCitogenesis.
- dlitz 13y agoI don't think the law of libel works that way.
- asperous 13y ago"Congress specifically enacted 47 U.S.C. § 230 (1996) to reverse the Prodigy findings and to provide for private blocking and screening of offensive material. § 230(c) states "that no provider or user of an interactive computer shall be treated as a publisher or speaker of any information provided by another information content provider," thereby providing forums immunity for statements provided by third parties." http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_defamation_law http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_defamation_law
- logicallee 13y agoI've always thought Wikipedia is like the true prophecy of Isaac Asimov (encyclopedia galactica) - but not even old Isaac could have predicted this!!
- dragonwriter 13y agoIMO, Wikipedia has more in common with Douglas Adams' Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (the fictional book featured in the series of the same title, not the work of fiction in which it featured) than Asimov's Encyclopedia Galactica.
- logicallee 13y agoMy point still applies :) Could you imagine PR companies warring to get their 'native content' into the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy (the book featured in the series)? Now that would have been prescient.
- rrrene 13y agoThe main problem here seems to be: Why must every company on earth have its own Wikipedia page? That said, I can see why e.g. Microsoft, the East India Trading Company and BMW should be recognized in an encyclopedia. And there are examples of products (lines) that could/should be mentioned in a vast online encyclopedia as well (e.g. Windows, BMW 3 series) because they influenced industries/trends/zeitgeist and/or lifes. But why, for the love of god, should every consultancy, contractor, forrester and his second cousin have an entry on this site? EDIT: typo
- adamdavis 13y agoWhat good are any of our acts if they aren't recorded for others to see? /s
- logn 13y agoBecause wikipedia long ago decided that 'notable' had a fairly low bar. There's really no going back now and personally I very much like the abundance of articles, even on relatively minor people/companies/events. The storage/serving costs for these articles is negligible, but the value to our society (and maybe especially future ones) will be enormous.
- Ras_ 13y agoSome language versions have higher requirements for notability. It's hard to set a clear cutoff point for example in sports, entertainment and companies. When does something become wiki-notable? Everyone has their own admins, deletion policies and arbitration mechanisms, which have and will influence content. Statistics show clearly that some have opted to include as many stubs as possible via the use of bots (for example Swedish wikipedia). Tens of thousands almost worthless stubs (like all US townships and communities) could be machine-added at any time, but most wikis have steered clear of this kind of doping. German wikipedia is quite the opposite in regards to pictures. They don't allow any fair use / citation pictures, which leads to de.wiki articles having considerably less photos than other languages.
- guelo 13y agoWhy doesn't Wikipedia sue this company and their clients?
- ChrisNorstrom 13y agoWhy are we passing this opportunity up?!?!?! Oh Jesus Christ, common now we're a community of entrepreneurs & hackers, someone just create a new startup that's wikipedia for people. PeoplePedia.com is taken but here, but I've got http://www.infopag.es http://www.infopag.es so it's perfect for something like InfoPag.es/ChrisNorstrom. If someone wants to join in reply to this comment. So basically I'm envisioning a wiki for people. However, there's 2 routes I can go down: a) Anyone can create a page on a person and anyone can edit and add onto or delete content from that page. (lots of growth, but lots of potential for abuse) b) People must register to create a page on themselves, anyone can edit that page and add onto or delete content but the registered owner must approve the edits. Which sounds better?
- chris_wot 13y agoNeither. Both sound like recipes for disaster, and impossible to administer. In all seriousness, it's taken close to a decade for Wikipedia to develop policies, guidelines, enforcements and practices to deal with abuses and get decent information into articles about people. Anyone who thinks it's easy to allow anyone to edit articles about people hasn't tried to do it before, or are just plum crazy!
- ChrisNorstrom 13y agoYou've only further encouraged me. I'll start work on it this weekend.
- chris_wot 13y agoBest of luck - the greatest inventions were created by those with blind optimism :-) interestingly, it's also how they started Wikipedia...
- mung 13y agoThought off the top of my head so it's not developed or thought through, but wouldn't Wikipedia do well to find a way of somehow connecting itself in with academia? It might gain better resources to knowledge and people and more credibility as a result. And make it more difficult to "just get access" to editing a page.
- malandrew 13y agoSince these companies (or at WikiPR) are refunding the money when things don't work out they should just hire these PR companies directly via friends and family and watch those accounts that are editing the pages they paid to edit. Once they catch the people, they ban the accounts, revert the changes and then demand their refund. It's a basic honeypot.
- GhotiFish 13y agobased on experiences by previous clients, they would not refund the money.