19 ms·
D-Wave Computer's Solution Raises More Questions
- woah 13y agoCurious as to why the quantumness matters.
- nolite 13y agoIt's kinda necessary that a "quantum" computer actually be... you know... "quantum"
- bnegreve 13y agoIt is actually a very crucial question: If the D-Wave machine is a just quantum computer emulator supported by classical hardware, we cannot expect much improvement in the future due to the inherent limitations of classical physics. On the other hand, if it does behave like a quantum computer, it may end up being a lot faster than any classical computer.
- blackkettle 13y agojust curious but, why would you expect any appreciable improvement from the emulator version?
- bnegreve 13y agoGood question, I am not sure :) There can be many reasons. But the problem modeling is surely very different in its D-Wave form so the fact that there are improvements doesn't mean that it is because of quantum effects. Other than that, too limited experiments, comparing specialized vs general algorithms, sub optimal classical algorithms are also possible reasons.
- nolite 13y agoYou wouldn't, and right now, it's debatable whether there is any or not. Hence the entire controversy
- sampo 13y agoLet's keep in mind that the D-Wave machine is not a general purpose quantum computer. It only runs the quantum annealing, which is an aptimization algorithm, on its quantum register. This is the only thing the machine is able to do. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_annealing http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Quantum_annealing
- devx 13y ago> One researcher did find D-Wave performed 3600 times faster than a classical device. Well, that was done with the 128-qubit version, right? And now they have one that is 2^384 faster than that one, so we'll see what happens next. If it was the 512-qubit one, then we'll need to wait for the 2048-qubit D-Wave Three that should come out in 2015 (they seem to double the qubits every year, but only release a new model every 2 years or so). That one should be 2^1536 faster than the current model.
- IanCal 13y agoJust like 64 bit computers are twice as fast as 32 bit computers, right?
- gphilip 13y agoMore like 64 bit computers are 2^32 times as fast as 32 bit computers.
- marcosdumay 13y agoThat's a property of quantum computers (but as people already explained, it's not that simple), why do you want classical computers to behave the same way? Or, in a short answer, no, no relation at all with that.
- Strilanc 13y agoQuantum computers don't get twice as fast for every qubit you add. You're confusing the state space required for a naive classical simulation with speed.
- agsamek 13y agoYes they should do. Maybe not 2x with every cubid, but definitely exponentially - for larger "state space" as you call it. This is what makes them different from classical model.
- jessriedel 13y ago
- batgaijin 13y agodo people not understand that this is just fake it til you make it? it doesn't matter if it's an emulator if they are paying the right people and working on it. do you think reddit just hoped it would get better at posting as bots? that's ridiculous.
- nnq 13y agoHow about the more practical question: does it solve any classes of problems faster than an equivalently priced classic computer? What are these problems? ...if they don't come up with answers to this questions that are easy for business persons to understand, then we can only think that they are playing "fake it 'till we make it" on US gov's money. And if, god forbid, they don't make it, we'll be in for a "quantum computing winter(s)" just like we had the "AI winter(s)" because of smart assholes that played a similar game... and boy we have a lot to "thank" them for!
- OvidNaso 13y agoIf the D-Wave is actually using quantum annealing for it's algorithms, how is it playing "fake it till we make it" simply by not having optimized its output to be currently faster than classical systems? I think it's pretty easy to see how the government and private institutions that are purchasing D-Wave Two's (universities and research divisions) see them as potentially great tools separate from their processing output. Business people are a separate entity and I would be surprised, and doubtful of their acumen, if any were actually purchasing any. If they turn out to be quantum in origin, I think you are way off base in this prediction.
- mitmatt 13y agoIt's not able to do full quantum annealing; it's only able to use stoquastic Hamiltonians on a fixed topology. Even if truly quantum effects were present (which is unclear at the moment, see Smolin and Smith arxiv posts), it's not known to be a useful quantum computing model. So it's not just an issue of "optimizing output".
- X4 13y agohhahaha, this question is so ironic!! It's a Quantum Computer and it's not, at the same time. hahaha :) hang on: I know that they proved that it's a quantum computer, so this article only criticizes the degree of it's Quantumcomputerness.