3 ms·
>It's true that when submitters change titles, their new titles often contain more information than the article's original title. But a significant percentage o
by pbhjpbhj 13y ago
>It's true that when submitters change titles, their new titles often contain more information than the article's original title. But a significant percentage of the extra information added in this way is false. The only way we can tell if a newly created title is accurate is to read the article, and we're not about to read every article submitted to HN. The only option is to revert to the original title, which is at least what the author intended. //
This doesn't make sense.
If the extra info added to the title is false, how did the moderator know without reading the article? If they didn't read the article what basis do they have to revert the title? If they did read the article then we shouldn't be getting issues like the "leaving twitter" reversion unless it's a mistake in a moderation interface or something.
Seems like a crazy way to do moderation - gather user submitted title, assume those titles are wrong and revert them, then return to the title and re-instate when there's objections.
There's sub-optimal and then there's eating soup with a fork.