13 ms·
What happens when a language has no numbers?
- etherealG 13y agoIn science approximation is so common there's a required notation for experimental measurement for it. Perhaps they're just accept that sooner than us.
- koala_advert 13y agoHere's an interview with a Pirahã speaker: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHv3-U9VPAs http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SHv3-U9VPAs
- w1ntermute 13y agoI don't see any (English) subtitles, do you?
- apostlion 13y agoWhy would a culture that has no trade need numbers? Approximate buckets are good enough for the hunter-gatherer lifestyle. After all, it were Sumerian traders and bureaucrats who gave us both figures -and- numbers -and- a way to write them down.
- curiousdannii 13y ago"How many children/pigs/dogs are in the house? Did we forget any?"
- adamnemecek 13y agoYeah, or alternatively how many wolves are approaching? It seems like it would be advantageous to be able to communicate whether 5 or 50.
- Theodores 13y agoThree. You must be referring to the legendary 3 Wolf T-Shirt available on Amazon: http://www.amazon.co.uk/Original-Three-Wolf-Adult-T-Shirt/dp/B002DGFYFA http://www.amazon.co.uk/Original-Three-Wolf-Adult-T-Shirt/dp... Just get the T-Shirt and read the reviews - famously funny. There aren't any wolves in the Amazon rainforest - not enough bins for them to go through, apparently.
- petsos 13y agoWhat would you do differently if it was 5 or 8 wolves? Having concepts like "a few" and "a lot" seems to be enough for this case.
- prof_hobart 13y agoDecide whether to send one or two of your group of 8 hunters after each of the wolves?
- apostlion 13y agoFuzzy buckets are wonderful for exactly this kind of case. If you're alone, it doesn't matter whether there are 5 or 50 wolves - you're fucked anyway. On the other hand, if you're a scout for an armed band of hunters, 5 are no longer “a lot”, it is “some” - and 50 is a lot.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoThat seems to be where the distinction between hói and hoí would come in.
- petsos 13y agoDid we forget any to our way to the mall maybe? Animals seem to be able to handle their young ones without counting them too.
- joe_the_user 13y agoOh Gawd... Read: http://web.mit.edu/linguistics/people/faculty/pesetsky/Nevins_Pesetsky_Rodrigues_Piraha_Exceptionality_a_Reassessment.pdf http://web.mit.edu/linguistics/people/faculty/pesetsky/Nevin... Edit: and sure this is the Chomskians debunking the "upstart" Danial Everett but this is thorough, clear and convincing in contrast to the haphazard novelty that most Piraha discussion involves. A language with future? How...? Well, actually the answer would be just no, that's not how it works. And sure, this headline says "number" but all the discussions are interlinked.
- einhverfr 13y agoI don't now. I read it. It seems that given that most of the documentation of the language was done by Everett, the Chomskians have some difficulty getting around some points. I found the discussions of anumeracy in that PDF quite problematic because they basically argued we don't know enough about the language to say one way or another. Some of the difficulties, particularly adding vs removing spoons posed significant interpretation problems for me. Of course if I was differentiate between a few spoons and a bunch of spoons, the lines would be different if adding spoons vs subtracting them. This is because the relative frame of reference is different. It seems to me that the problem is fraught with insurmountable epistemological problems which can't be solved and therefore people get to make best guesses. In general though I would trust the one who speaks the language more fluently than the one who doesn't. This isn't to address novelty claims. Bahasa Indonesia, for example, mostly lacks relative tenses as well, and Proto-Indo-European probably did as well.
- Pitarou 13y agoIt's clear that Everett has a lot more work to do before any of his claims will stand up to scrutiny. Like I said earlier, it all sounds a little too perfect. Unpolluted by outside contact (because they refuse to learn a language that can't be whistled), the Piraha have no need for past, future, creation myths, kinship systems beyond the first degree, numbers, and so on. It's a dream of what we might be like if we were freed of our corrupt culture. Is Everett an heir to Margaret Meade?
- riffraff 13y agotrivia: there are some languages out there which don't have different concepts for PIROS and VÖRÖS, and just bunch them together under a single color ("red" in english).
- elnate 13y agoRed is a broad group of colours. There are plenty of more specific names for types of red, like scarlet or ruby, does that qualify?
- tehwalrus 13y agobut when you ask a non-specialist[1] "what color is this", pointing to a scarlet object, they'll say "red". They will also take longer to tell the difference between turquoise and blue than between proper green and blue, where (I think it was) Thai-speakers wouldn't[2] (who have a primary-colour word for turquoise). [1] specialist = (color-theorist, decorator) [2] http://www.pnas.org/content/104/19/7780.full http://www.pnas.org/content/104/19/7780.full actually, this article seems to talk about Russian, I'm getting the Thai thing from a discussion I remember (a video by the authors at the Long Now foundation[3].) [3] http://longnow.org/seminars/02010/oct/26/how-language-shapes-thought/ http://longnow.org/seminars/02010/oct/26/how-language-shapes...
- whatusername 13y agoAnd for the nerd comparisons: http://blog.xkcd.com/2010/05/03/color-survey-results/ http://blog.xkcd.com/2010/05/03/color-survey-results/
- tehwalrus 13y agomost popular colour names from guys: Penis Gay WTF Dunno Baige I feel quite embarrassed for my gender at moments like this. EDIT: I didn't realise that Randall actually typed "I weep for my gender." a few lines lower down...
- 13y ago
- dm2 13y agoIt's not much different than most people rarely using Greek characters as formulas or constants.
- seandougall 13y agoPretty different, actually -- the point is that they (supposedly) have no counting system at all. They lack the concept of numbers, not just the words.
- Theodores 13y ago...they spark up conversation with the neighbouring tribe that has no concept of time! http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-13452711 http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-13452711 ...and then it all falls to pieces because they have no concept of god! More to the point, what is the big deal with counting if there is no concept of private property?
- peteretep 13y agoWell, you know, science and computers and medicine and all that stuff.
- prof_hobart 13y agoI left the house with a somewhat largish amount of children. I've still got a somewhat largish amount of children, so I can't have left any of them behind.
- meepmorp 13y agoI left the house with David, Susan, Steve, Kate, Alice, and George. I still have David, Susan, Steve, Kate, Alice, and George, so I can't have left any behind. I've got issues with a lot of (Dan) Everett's work, but you don't need counting to handle that scenario.
- prof_hobart 13y agoYou've now got to remember all of the kids' individual names (and hope that you haven't got a somewhat largish amount of John Smiths in your group), rather than remembering "I had 6. I've still got 6". It's also even more of a challenge when the things you've got to remember aren't easily individually identified - a flock of sheep or apples or whatever.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoIt's not that hard to remember individuals' names, when there aren't all that many of them in your society to begin with, and you've known them all your life. After all, you remember your parents' names, and your grandparents' names, and probably your uncle and aunts' names. If you went on vacation with them, would you count your family members at the start and end of the plane ride, or would you just look around, and think, "Marina, Richard, Victor and Mila, Irina and Alex - okay, everyone's here!"
- michaelfeathers 13y agoAnyone interested in the Pirahã should read 'Don't Sleep, There Are Snakes: Life and Language in the Amazonian Jungle' by Daniel Everett ( http://www.amazon.com/Dont-Sleep-There-Are-Snakes/dp/0307386120 http://www.amazon.com/Dont-Sleep-There-Are-Snakes/dp/0307386... ) There's quite a bit about the language, but the backstory of Daniel going over as a missionary and losing his faith (and family) while trying to convert a happy people in no need of religion is stunning.
- andyjohnson0 13y agoEverett gave a very interesting talk [1] to the Long Now org a few years ago in which he describes some of his experiences working with the Pirahã. Video is available at [2]. [1] http://longnow.org/seminars/02009/mar/20/endangered-languages-lost-knowledge-and-future/ http://longnow.org/seminars/02009/mar/20/endangered-language... [2] http://fora.tv/2009/03/20/Daniel_Everett_Endangered_Languages_and_Lost_Knowledge http://fora.tv/2009/03/20/Daniel_Everett_Endangered_Language...
- agumonkey 13y agoCan't help but to think abotu lambda calculus encoded numbers.
- Pitarou 13y agoNothing to do with the Piraha, I fear. Get some sleep.
- favadi 13y agoI use a language has no numbers every day (Bash).
- pavel_lishin 13y agofor x in {0..3}; do echo $x; done
- Pitarou 13y agoI really don't know whether to believe this article. The whole setup sounds a little too ... perfect. We have: * a language where "speakers can dispense with their vowels and consonants altogether and sing, hum, or whistle conversations" * a language that "contains no words at all for discrete numbers" * a tribe too arrogant to learn any other language There are stranger things in the world, but I'd take a long, hard look at the guy reporting these facts before I took them at face value
- JonSkeptic 13y agoI am surprised that no one has mentioned the Sapir–Whorf hypothesis[0]. It's incredible, the effect that language can have on the mind. Given that they can communicate in whistles and hums, I'd also be interested in a study about their music as well. [0]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Linguistic_relativity
- Pitarou 13y agoEverett argues in the other direction. He believes that the unusual aspects of their language stem from their unusual culture.