3 ms·
TBH I've always thought that variations in skulls unearthed and labelled as different genus seemed not to be that varied next to the variation in modern people.
by pbhjpbhj 13y ago
TBH I've always thought that variations in skulls unearthed and labelled as different genus seemed not to be that varied next to the variation in modern people. About a year ago I tried to unearth a visual comparison that would show the variation of "modern" skulls so it could be compared - anyone know of such a work?
It's the same mistake made with the dinosaurs (see eg http://www.ted.com/talks/jack_horner_shape_shifting_dinosaurs.html http://www.ted.com/talks/jack_horner_shape_shifting_dinosaur...) assuming that one can tell how an animal grew by analogy and that heterogeneity necessarily shows speciation.
Is this really the first time that differently formed skulls have been found together in an archaeological dig. That's surprising isn't it?
Equally well, just because 5 skulls were found together why does one then have to declare them all to be H.Erectus, presumably there are other methods of categorisation relied on to establish that point?
- waps 13y agoBecause if they died together, they're part of the same group. If some are small skulls (ie. children) and some adults (a family that died in a natural disaster, landslide, ... say), then they obviously interbreeded, at which point they would be re-classified as only one species, and maybe something other than genetical differences account for the differences in skulls.