4 ms·
The Underworked American Child
- chaosmachine 17y agoI grew up with the long summer break (in Canada), and can't imagine how boring my childhood would have been without it. It was a great time to meet and make friends with the neighborhood kids, build forts, go exploring, go to camp, etc, etc. Some things can't be learned in school.
- pyr3 17y agoDo you really think that all people in Europe/Asia lead boring lives just because they don't get 3 months of 'time off' from school?
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- pyr3 17y agoI'm just trying to make the point that while you have fond childhood memories of long summer vacations, it doesn't necessarily mean that you would be a boring person with boring memories if you went through an education system with longer school days and less vacation time. You would have different memories and experiences for sure, but neither you nor I can claim to know how you would have turned out were your situation different.
- ilkhd2 17y agoCanadian schoolyear is 10 days longer than American, none-the-less.
- kiba 17y agoLearning programming or even learning how to operate a lemonade stand have far more economic values than a school system churning out ton of quadratic equation walking calculators. Reading is not that hard to maintain even. What kind of a social environment the school is to discourage such disinterest in maintaining reading skills? Where is the internet? Where is the texting? Where are the blogs, or the twitter even? Literacy should be stronger than ever before. Mathematics? For god sake, what reason do we need to learn useless concept like cosine, sine, and tanget and how to do the quadratic equation? What everyone probably need is an education on how to manage their money and do financial calculation, but beyond that, it is mostly unneccesary. I serously doubt business manager, nails shop, and musicians need to know that. Programmers at the very least need to know algebra. If he want to do cooler stuff, he can learn on his own, just like how he learn all his tools and programming languages. Other field may required lot of mathematics. If you need mathematics for your career, why not take a school specialized in making engineers out of you? Schools, are the very least an hinderance to the economy. It is a test, a fake test at that. It have nothing to very little to do with the performance of our economy. The smartest scientist in the world probably don't need English Literature 101. English literature is probably the scientist know, but is it revelant to his career? No. If schools want to be useful to the economy, than make them churn out skilled work force for whatever their economy may need and do it well. We would still have schools like grammatica and mathematics that will equip people with the basic essential(Let face it, it is hard to go anywhere without learning how to write and read and do basic mathematics) For those who still want a scholar's education(English, Social Science, Alegbra, the work), well...you still have the money to pay for such an education, right? Let forget all the government beucracry, rules, and abritary grading guideline and start schools like the Hacker School where young and old alike get to learn technologies and skills in fast and furious courses like the Art of Unit Testing or Rails boot camp or whatever. Our profession doesn't have guilds or unions, occupancy licensure, and all that bullshits that other professions have. If we program, than we're programmers. If some bold hackers can show the world a successful example of a trade school where teachers teach because they know their stuff and teach well not because of their bullshit degrees and license that said they're teachers. This can be an example to other field to replicate. Than our frailing education system will begin to rebound and starts to produce workers who are not quadratic equation walking calculator but can actually do real work! Now, all we need is a little less regulations(actually just abolish all laws regarding education) and the privization of government run schools and their so called educational standard.
- timwiseman 17y agoTo focus just on your comments about mathematics, let me point out that going through at least algebra at a minimum is valuable for everyone in a modern society. First it is highly helpful in handling even basic household finance. Second, you cannot hope to understand even basic statistics without it (and with the way the media throws out statistics it is very dangerous not to understand at least the basics if you want to be a participatory citizen). But far beyond all that, it goes a very long way to teaching you how to think and how to make reasoned and rational decisions. Also, I think you vastly underestimate the number of jobs that require going far beyond algebra. Virtually all technical jobs of any kind requires calculus. This includes almost all engineers, virtually all scientists, and most analysts. Also, most finance jobs involve math far beyond algebra. Remember that even fully analyzing interest rates involves calculus (or at least formulas derived from calculus, and a good analyst should know where they come from). And that is again before realizing that the mere study of math helps teach you to reason and think. I am focusing only on math here, but I think you will find anyone in an advanced society will benefit greatly from algebra and far more than you seem to expect need calculus. I also disagree with most everything else you said, but I will just focus on math for the moment.
- nihilocrat 17y agoAlso, in game programming trigonometry is fundamental, and in 3D an entirely higher order of magnitude is required.
- kiba 17y agoI am a game programming hobbyist, even I know how vital trignometry is.
- kiba 17y agoIf algebra is truely neccessary, than it will be taught in some school specializing in basic education. If it is neccessary for higher mathematics to be taught, than you could just go to an engineering school. If you're a truly care about pure mathematican, than you would go to an actual university and study to become part of the scholar class. Beyond that, I don't really care much about being a "participatory citizen" nonsense because I don't believe in democracy or writing pointless letters to politicans, but I do care a lot about civic because I am an anarchist, not an apolitical person. I don't know the approriate place to teach it but I suspect that is simply the duty of parents.
- blhack 17y agoThe problem isn't the time spent in school, the problem is the school itself. We teach people to be the status quo, we don't encourage them to excel. For me, summers were spent learning about computers and all the magic spells that I could cast to get them to do whatever I wanted them to. For some students, school is holding them back. If we want to fix things, we need to abandon this psychotic idea that all students are the same, that there are no dumb kids and that you can just dump 20 similarly aged kids into a room that has somebody standing at the front of it talking at them and that they will somehow come out of the situation better for the experience.
- likpok 17y agoI remember seeing an interesting study somewhere (sorry, don't have the link) that found that (IIRC in elementary school) segregating the better students did not help them. It only made the poorer students perform worse. I think that there have been similar studies which show that elementary school is a very different animal from what we think (i.e. similar nonintuitive results) and that it needs some kind of restructuring.
- tokenadult 17y agoThe problem isn't the time spent in school, the problem is the school itself. That's my take on the issue too. http://learninfreedom.org/ http://learninfreedom.org/ I also tended to learn more in the summer than during the school year. Something needs to be done to make the school year more worthwhile for such students.
- caffeine 17y agoSomething needs to be done to make the school year more worthwhile for such students Actually, it needs to be done for ALL students. You really think the only kids poorly served by school are those that teach themselves math on the side? Nearly every kid has an innate curiosity about the world and more importantly the people around him. Some prefer symbolic worlds, others the physical, and most the social. Schools are currently poor places to learn about any of those. The bizarre hierarchies in place seriously warp most children - witness the daily cruelty that is normal in an average school (others on the internet have made this point better than I can). To most people, Lockhart's lament is a very minor annoyance compared to the social retardation that goes on in these institutions. Rampant alcohol abuse and unreasonable sexual promiscuity in universities are the inevitable backlash to years of social repression, far beyond the young ages at which it might be called for. It was not unreasonable in earlier times to consider someone a "young man" or "young woman" at 13 or 14, and as a fully functional society member at 16. Why does this seem so completely ludicrous now? Has our genetic lifecycle programming changed? Of course not - but our social lifecycle programming has. All this to say that the kids for whom symbolic systems education is too slow are the lucky ones. For them, there is at least the library as an outlet for that spark. Consider the rest, who have no such thing.
- arrrg 17y agoThis article compares the US to a whole lot of school systems. There is nothing wrong with that, it’s just possible that if you constantly change the point of comparison you end up comparing the US to fictional countries – without the reader even noticing. There are huge differences between the school systems in different European countries (and, e.g. in Germany, between the different school systems in different states inside of those countries) that make those kinds of comparisons dangerous.
- asdlfj2sd33 17y agoSpeaking as an immigrant from Europe, I was surprised just how much Americans value summer jobs for kids, even blue collar summer jobs. In Europe working kids is considered a sign of coming from the lower classes, the people that might actually need the income. And upper class families would be embarrassed if their kids worked blue collar jobs.
- deleted 17y ago[deleted]
- nop 17y agoWhat you are saying for about kids working is definitely not true for my part of Europe. I've had plenty of friends from rich families growing up and if anything they tend to be more likely to get a summer job and I can't in the slightest imagine anyone getting embarrassed over their children having a blue collar summer job. Just because you are rich it doesn't mean you get everything you point at and even still it's quite satisfying for any young person to know hes earned something. I on the other hand come from the lower classes, pretty much as low as it gets in Sweden and I've never felt the need to have a summer job because of income.
- dimitar 17y agoMy observation is that richer kids do find jobs more easily because they and their parents usually have plenty of connections. They usually do this so they would have more money to party :-). Also regulation in many places in Europe effectively limits teenage employment - until I turned 18 I had to either get something like 9 documents or work for money paid under the table for someone I knew before. Please remember that Europe is far from homogeneous, so observations may vary wildly. :-)
- nihilocrat 17y agoIt's shameful for our children NOT to work because it suggests they are spoiled and lazy. During college, there was an unspoken resentment towards students without jobs because most of us schlubs had to work to pay our own tuition / rent / spending money / whatever, while some people were just given everything by their parents.
- nostrademons 17y agoThis seems to miss an important point: choice. Most middle-class Americans get to choose their jobs, within reason. Most American schoolchildren do not get to choose their schools. I went to a charter high school whose curriculum focused on letting us do individualized projects catering to our interests. Its 7-hour day (8:30-3:30) seemed far less oppressive than the 6-hour-and-20-minute day at my public middle school. I've kept up with it after graduation, and they now offer after-school classes and programs until 5:00, and summer courses. And kids go, even though they don't have to. Why not, when their friends are there and the programs are stuff they're interested in anyway? Similarly, I don't mind working long hours at the Googleplex, because my friends are there, they give me food, and the work is interesting and meaningful. When those conditions aren't met, you'll find many fewer people bragging about how much time they spent at work. Some working-poor people will work two jobs to make ends meet, but they don't brag about it, they complain about it. It's only because a relatively large number of Americans can now work in jobs that they find challenging and stimulating that we get the workaholic American.
- Locke1689 17y ago"On top of that, American children do only about an hour’s-worth of homework a day," Haha what??
- pyr3 17y agoThat average has no meaning. Are they averaging the homework loads of grades K-12? Obviously kids in higher grades will have higher workloads, while kids in kindergarten will have little to no homework.
- jazzyb 17y agoRight. Between sixth and twelfth grades I averaged about 4-5 hours of homework per school night. A lot of those numbers in the article aren't reflective of my experience.
- ShabbyDoo 17y agoIn the US? Wow. In retrospect, do you think this workload was helpful or harmful?
- jazzyb 17y agoLooking back on it, I think it was neither; it was just superfluous. Take calculus for example: why would a teacher assign 60 or so integrals to calculate when 20 would have been enough? Maybe it prepared me better for college -- I can't say.
- tokenadult 17y agoBetween sixth and twelfth grades I averaged about 4-5 hours of homework per school night. What kinds of subjects were you studying, in what kind of school? What kind of university education were you aiming for with those studies in grades 6 through 12?
- jazzyb 17y ago
- GeneralMaximus 17y agoSo what is the point? Force children to work harder when you could revamp the entire education system in a way that motivates them to work harder? This article is just plain silly. Here's a summary: "South Korean/Chinese/India/Foo children work harder than American children, hence American children are doomed to a life of misery". (I'm Indian, BTW. And no, Indian children don't work any harder than American children.)
- enomar 17y agoIt seems like everyone would benefit if we spent our entire lives splitting time between work and school (or perhaps back and forth in cycles). I've always found it odd that kids don't spend much time working and adults don't spend much time learning (in a formal setting).
- diN0bot 17y agoright idea, but the beginning of the article erroneously focuses on quantity not quality.
- asorbus 17y agoI transferred from a 200 school day per year charter school to a 180 school day per year public high school, and I found that I learned a lot more at the public school, so I have first hand experience with the differences. Also, the charter school's days were about an hour longer than the public school's. I found there were no advantages to going to the charter school for longer days and longer school years. It's hard to stay alert as a young kid during such a long school day, with class times being so long. When I transferred to public school, I met a lot of very intelligent people my age, and I was surprised to see that. For the first year after transferring, I felt that I was too smart to be there, since I had just transferred from a charter school. It turned out that I had met people who were much smarter than me and just as insightful. Sure American kids don't do so well on international tests, but maybe that's because they're not taught to take tests, they're taught to learn and apply what they learn. I don't know about you, but I'd rather my kids grow up knowing how to learn new things and broaden their horizons, rather than grow up knowing how to write answers down on a piece of paper.