6 ms·
Impressive amount of data and data reduction...but it all hinges on a 100 ug dose of LSD purchased anonymously from Silk Road? How can the OP be sure that the
by joezydeco 13y ago
Impressive amount of data and data reduction...but it all hinges on a 100 ug dose of LSD purchased anonymously from Silk Road?
How can the OP be sure that the 100 micrograms was pure and accurate? If you can't prove that, what good is all the math?
- NathanKP 13y agoThe OP also wrote a very detailed study of how Silk Road works: http://www.gwern.net/Silk%20Road#lsd-case-study http://www.gwern.net/Silk%20Road#lsd-case-study In it he mentions a potential test to verify that what you receive really is LSD: An Ehrlich test is a reagant for indole alkaloids, a category which includes psychedelics like LSD & psilocybin. As such, it can be used as a kind of quality check. I'd assume given the rigorous treatment I've seen so far in all his posts that he probably did this test.
- Tenoke 13y ago> I'd assume given the rigorous treatment I've seen so far in all his posts that he probably did this test. If he did, he would've said so in the write-up.
- deutronium 13y agoWouldn't the test still come up positive even if it was mixed with other chemicals too?
- joezydeco 13y agoYet, still no calibration. I admire the rigor of his work, really. It's just a nagging detail that's kind of key here.
- leoedin 13y agoThe test addresses the presence of the molecule. It doesn't address the quantities present. If the doses he gave himself were smaller than he believed, even by 50%, then the fact that there's no perceptible effects isn't surprising. Given the tiny quantities that he's dealing with anyway, any slight variation of the input conditions (which he didn't account for) would make a huge difference to the output.
- yock 13y agohe probably did this test The only difference between science and screwing around is writing it down. If the author's goals were less lofty, I might be inclined to make this assumption, too. That said it's equally likely, given that he recorded so many other aspects of this experiment, omitting this from the record indicates that the test was not performed.
- gwern 13y ago> I'd assume given the rigorous treatment I've seen so far in all his posts that he probably did this test. No. See the final section: http://www.gwern.net/Silk%20Road#voi-ehrlich-test http://www.gwern.net/Silk%20Road#voi-ehrlich-test If I had been able to afford more tabs, I probably would've used one (it wouldn't've confirmed the dosage or anything, but it would at least reassure me I wasn't getting an RC), but I only had 2 tabs. I needed 1 for the microdoses, and 1 to trip with, so... Between tripping and testing, it was an easy choice.
- jcomis 13y agoThere was a group of silk road users who regularly tested vendors and posted results see: http://www.theverge.com/2013/10/14/4828448/silk-road-lsd-avengers-drug-inspectors http://www.theverge.com/2013/10/14/4828448/silk-road-lsd-ave...
- gwern 13y agoYes. You can find the SR forum thread for the Avengers archived at http://www.gwern.net/docs/sr/2013-10-15-lsdavengers.maff http://www.gwern.net/docs/sr/2013-10-15-lsdavengers.maff
- tedks 13y agoFrom a comment on the page: """ There are a great many errors in your methodology, and I do not believe you received any of the drug in any of your doses. First off, you have no way of knowing that what you purchased actually contained the drug. The blotter may have had none in it. Secondly, even if there was some drug, you haven no way of knowing what other chemicals were in that paper, including strychnine, and its effects after being mixed with water, on the drug. Thirdly, I'm not sure that 24 hours in a fridge is a sufficient method of extraction. But more damaging is that the drug degrades quickly and is very sensitive to its environment. It degrades in the presence of oxygen, heat and light. A common house fridge provides all three- the door is opened at least once a day (to get your dose) letting light in. The container is open to the air which provides oxygen, and while a fridge is cool, it is does not absolutely prevent degradation of the drug due to heat. I've seen storage recommendations for this drug involving sealed, light opaque containers, kept frozen in an icebox and the admonition that this will only preserve it for a few weeks. You provided less protection, significant dilution, questionable extraction, and stored it for months. Basically, the conclusion from your research is this: The drug war prevents the kind of exploration of the possible positive effects of such a drug, that could be carried out by a well appointed lab. """ LSD is an incredibly volatile molecule and after months I wouldn't expect any to remain. I think this is a bigger deal than the sketchiness factor of buying drugs -- a silk road vendor selling adulterated product would be severely penalized if caught and the economics don't work out.
- joezydeco 13y agoMissed that comment, and very well expressed. Thanks.
- gibwell 13y agoThat comment doesn't seem well informed given the casual way that it references the strychnine myth, nevertheless it's true that there is uncertainty about the dose.
- duaneb 13y agoRegardless of strychnine, LSD remains very volatile. I wouldn't term it "uncertainty", I would term it "near total lack of certainty" given small sample size and lack of (any) proper verification that the drug was even active anymore. At the very least, he could have taken a dose to serve as this purpose after the experiment (so it would not interfere, and would provide a "later" bound)—it's fairly easy, given certain high contrast imagery, to create certain visual effects that a placebo (or degenerated drug) could not.
- lsd_dose_ta 13y agoExactly. Even within a single sheet, the dose per "tab" can vary. Outside of that, even from the same vendor, the dose might vary by a factor of 5. The only remotely reliable method is to take enough to be psychoactive, then wait a week and take it again, trying to hit the point where you have threshold effects (a binary search over dosing strength). Even then you might be off on your dose guessing be 30% or more. He may have gotten far less LSD than he believes.
- gwern 13y ago> He may have gotten far less LSD than he believes. Or more. In the absence of any reason to believe one direction, the expectation of the shift is zero...
- Someone 13y agoI also find the methodology lacking. "This suggests the following design: a randomized dose on day 1, followed by days 2 and 3 off, then on day 4, drinking the second container; on day 7, examine the containers recording whether active/placebo and finally, starting over as day 1 of a new pair of 3-day blocks." That means that, during the experiment, the subject can learn correlations between the test and the control ("So, I tend to go to the bathroom in the middle of the night in the test.") If the subject has some (conscious or unconscious) prejudice for the result, he can use that information to adjust his self-reporting (again, consciously or unconsciously). For example, a subject may report a silly thought as a creative one instead of as a stupid one. Also, given that the period of the experiment is exactly a week, I also would control for 'LSD is the first thing exactly as often as the test"
- javajosh 13y agoGiven the fact that he had a null result, I don't think this criticism could possibly be valid.
- Someone 13y agoMost importantly, the criticism of a _design_ is independent of the results of the experiment. Secondly, he may have wanted a null result.
- gwern 13y ago> Most importantly, the criticism of a _design_ is independent of the results of the experiment. Flaws can go in any direction, and make a design conservative or optimistic. In this case, the identified flaw does not undermine the actual result of the experiment - though it would have undermined the opposite (hypothetical) result of positive effects.
- Someone 13y agoIf you design an experiment in such a way that outcome A can be explained away by "yes, but the design is flawed", while outcome B cannot, I don't think it is fair to do the experiment.
- elwell 13y agoI also think a distinction needs to be made between Walt and Jesse's production methods.
- gwern 13y ago> but it all hinges on a 100 ug dose of LSD More than that. > How can the OP be sure that the 100 micrograms was pure and accurate? If you can't prove that, what good is all the math? I cannot be sure, any more than anyone getting LSD from a non-lab source (which is everyone) can be sure. All I can say is that the seller, VitaCat, was reputable; the Avengers regularly tested wares to keep sellers honest; the FBI reported high quality levels for their purchases of LSD among other drugs; the price was not too good to be true; the physical small size of the tabs meant that it had to be some highly psychoactive chemical; the trip matched reports of LSD trips very closely, and did not match many of the RC trips I've read; and so on. > If you can't prove that, what good is all the math? The math is there so that if I took LSD, as I highly likely did, I don't then waste the data by a screwed-up analysis.
- stuaxo 13y agoIf you just took a bigger dose at the end of tje week you would know if there was any in it or not.