54 ms·
Liquidity has certainly gone up. Also, it is hard to prove a causal relationship, but with the rise of electronic trading and HFT, price spreads and fees have
by kasey_junk 13y ago
Liquidity has certainly gone up.
Also, it is hard to prove a causal relationship, but with the rise of electronic trading and HFT, price spreads and fees have come down.
I can't prove it, but I believe that insider trading is also much less rampant in modern electronic systems than it was in the older pit based markets.
- selmnoo 13y agoThe liquidity it provides is often very low quality. When liquidity in the old days was added, the players involved had to operate under stricter regulations -- they had to post a quote that was part of the National Best Bid and Offer a minimum percentage of time. With HFT it's a wild west scenario. There's a lot of uncertainty and risk of failure in many of its steps.
- sseveran 13y agoThat is categorically incorrect. HFT firms like Getco are official market makers and have all the same responsibilities.
- beagle3 13y agoRe: spreads & fees: Price spreads and fees have come down as a result of electronic trading being open to everyone, and is probably independent of HFT (at least, modern HFT): E.g., The decreased spreads and fees were happening in europe in the early 2000s, when fastest updates were at 1/4 second, and slower updates were at 2 seconds. The nanosecond scale was not the reason for this. Re liquidity: it depends how you define liquidity. If you define it by "the average size at the bid or offer and next few price levels" or "volume traded", then yes - HFT has helped liquidity tremendously. If you define it as "the probability that a large order can complete", then liquidity has NOT gone up. With HFT, it's the same 100 shares/futures changing hands thousands of times per day, and they disappear often in times of uncertainty. If you need to execute a large order, you observe that you do not have the amazing liquidity everyone in HFT is talking about. Re insider trading: I wouldn't bet on it. With electronic trading, it's now easier to do insider trading slowly without attracting much attention. Furthermore, HFT has created new forms of fraud, so far unregulated: see e.g. http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4329.html http://www.nanex.net/aqck2/4329.html
- AndrewBissell 13y ago> If you define it as "the probability that a large order can complete", then liquidity has NOT gone up. People seem to have this idea that back in the days of floor-based trading you could just call up the NYSE and say, "sell 1 million shares of Citigroup!" and the market makers would just kindly oblige you, without widening their spreads or trying to eke out a bigger gain from a transaction which inherently carries significant risk for them. It's possible that the situation for executing giant orders in one fell swoop hasn't gotten any better under HFT, but it hardly seems to have made it worse. And as the large flow traders become more sophisticated and start to implement algos of their own, they'll get better at moving volume at a fairer average price. > With HFT, it's the same 100 shares/futures changing hands thousands of times per day, and they disappear often in times of uncertainty. I don't know about "often," unless you're talking about trading individual issues where news events introduce a high degree of uncertainty. There's really only been one case of a market-wide drying up of liquidity, which lasted for about 15 minutes during the flash crash. There's also nothing new about market-maker liquidity drying up in times of uncertainty or severe volatility. Plenty of stocks went "no bid" during the 1929 crash. Floor-based market makers are no more interested in standing in front of freight trains than algos are. If you're looking for someone/something to blame when markets crash and there are no bids to be found, focus on the Fed and its attempts to manipulate the credit cycle, which periodically fail in spectacular fashion.
- tanzam75 13y ago> It's possible that the situation for executing giant orders in one fell swoop hasn't gotten any better under HFT, but it hardly seems to have made it worse. Plenty of stocks went "no bid" during the 1929 crash. 1929 is an obsolete example. Heck, the SEC didn't even exist in 1929. A more relevant example is 1987 -- how many stocks went "no bid" on Black Monday? Here's how HFTs operate today. Bid furiously while the going is good. If you find yourself on the wrong side of a trade, you can always hit up the actual market-makers for a penny loss. And if the markets collapse, you pull out. What could be better? Supply liquidity when it's not needed, and stay out precisely when liquidity is most needed. Meanwhile, the registered market-makers are pulling back, or pulling out. And why not? They used to count on having the good times to balance out the bad. But now, the HFTs are siphoning off their profits during good times. Thus, the cross-subsidy has gone away. In periods of market stress, the HFTs go hide under a rock and don't participate in absorbing losses. The effect is: There are now fewer market-makers in periods of market stress. That's how HFTs have made things worse.
- pedrocr 13y agoI seem to recall that the research on this says that HFT is actually a net taker of liquidity and that their profits are fully funded (and then some) by other investors not really by making the market more efficient (they actually reduce efficiency). I've also heard stated many times that an exchange that only matches trades every X seconds would retain efficiency while eliminating HFT. This isn't the article I remember but goes into detail on most of these issues: http://www.demos.org/publication/cracks-pipeline-part-two-high-frequency-trading http://www.demos.org/publication/cracks-pipeline-part-two-hi...