7 ms·
The Octopus That Almost Ate Seattle
- rwbt 13y agoMisleading title! For a moment, I thought a giant marine octopus is attacking Seattle. Joking aside, I'm very surprised that the teenager was able to escape a nine foot giant octopus. I'm sure he'll have a great story to tell for the rest of his life.
- sharkweek 13y agoMy random conspiracy is that octopuses are actually alien life form that crashed into our oceans thousands of years ago. But seriously; if you're ever up in Seattle, despite the touristy nature, the aquarium is totally worth a peek. Watching the G.P.O (https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypaxG8AnTdE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ypaxG8AnTdE) in it's tank is marvelous; quite majestic creatures, despite absolutely being one of the things I would least like to encounter in the wild. Countless reports of them ripping off essential diving equipment. In the video above, if you' watch the whole thing, the aquarium employee says "this one is about half full grown." Interesting article though, it's always fascinating from a social sciences perspective how the perception of a concept can so quickly shift public policy.
- MartinCron 13y agoThe Aquarium docents love to talk about their octopuses. If you get an older one, they'll tell you about the time when they filled the tank near the top and the octopus climbed out and flopped upon an unsuspecting visitor! The water line is kept lower these days.
- Theodores 13y agoComing soon: Braised Stephen Hawking on lightly buttered toast! Speaking as a vegetarian(!) I found the content of this article to be quite disturbing. Octopii are very special creatures and it is lamentable that this article is essentially what they taste like, how to butcher them and where to go to eat them.
- d0ne 13y agoSpeaking as a omnivore I found the content of this article to be quite useful. That said, Octopii are indeed very special creatures for many reasons one of which is they do in fact serve well as the main ingredient in multiple dishes.
- Pxtl 13y agoFellow vegetarian... honestly I find the thundering hypocrisy of store-goers who are offended by the grisly reality of hunting far more grotesque than the gastronomical details of the article.
- judk 13y agoIt is a bad idea to eat a creature with nerve disease.
- Pxtl 13y agoiirc, Hawking no longer has the disease. That is, his disease only was actually "active" for about 5 years... it's just that the damage was irreversible. This is why he survived ALS when most people die of it.
- tehwalrus 13y agoThere are a few animals I'd really like to have as pets, because of their intelligence. Obviously a dog, but also there are a couple of breeds of cat (aby, burmese, bengal,) plus grey parrots and an octopus. If I could get away with them, I'd also be up for dolphins. I wouldn't have space for a whale. I occasionally daydream about hacking up an electronic waterproof octopus toy, kind of like an underwater "bop it" that I can customise as they learn new features on it. It makes me sad to read about any of these animals being hunted. They're too cool, leave them alone.
- jonnathanson 13y agoThey're super cool and ridiculously smart. Quite possibly among the smartest animals on the planet. (It's difficult to say how smart, exactly, because their neural anatomy evolved very different from the mammalian systems we've held up as the gold standard. But they meet certain indicating criteria that a lot of mammals fail.) http://io9.com/5626679/three-arguments-for-the-consciousness-of-cephalopods http://io9.com/5626679/three-arguments-for-the-consciousness...
- judk 13y agoCows are bred to be fat, and they don't need to outwit prey, so it is hard for them to show the fact that they are conscious intelligent animals as well.
- samatman 13y agoWhile intelligent, octopus are dramatically different from other intelligent species. They are, somehow, born with their intelligence. Everything else learns it, all the species you mentioned learn from their parents or surrogates. Octopus are also a K selected species, laying 200,000 eggs on average. Furthermore, they are short lived in comparison to any other intelligent species. We associate intelligence with individuality and hence with rarity: each human intelligence is rare because it was cultivated, not born. Octopus aren't like that.
- tehwalrus 13y ago
- triplesec 13y agoThis is a bait-and-switch title. But while we're here and talking of eating octopodes [side note: octopii is way off the mark, mixing classical languages; octopuses is probably in the end the least obnoxious plural], we might bear in mind our obsession for killing rather than wondering at nature with this cautionary tale: http://io9.com/vacationing-family-finds-exceedingly-rare-hexapus-kill-939989806 http://io9.com/vacationing-family-finds-exceedingly-rare-hex...
- msg 13y agoThis article has an interesting meta about the conflict between the gourmet and environmental protection approaches to exotic wildlife, that itself is half food article and half human interest story about octopus punching. Worth the read.
- coldcode 13y agoNo one asked the octopus what it thought. Maybe someday we can communicate - I wonder if we would eat it then.
- slm_HN 13y agoIt's easy to know what the octopus thought. He was up in arms about the situation.
- scotch_drinker 13y ago"If trees could scream, would we be so cavalier about cutting them down? We might, if they screamed all the time, for no good reason." Jack Handy
- hef19898 13y agoRemebers me of the cow at the Restaurant at the Ende of the universe!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jcomis 13y agoThis is so Seattle. Kid does something legal, but frowned upon. Angry mob forms on internet, spreads his personal information around and makes threats. Mob reforms after they realize how shitty they are being and creates petition to make sure no one can do this again, ever. Meanwhile, they all go to the fancy restaurant that serves the exact same item they are so against some kid harvesting and rave about it. Seattle.
- judk 13y agoHow is that so "Seattle"? Do you even know that protesters and the diners are the same people? Or did you mean that Seattle is a city with a politically diverse population?
- rubyrescue 13y agoSeattle is a very religious city, I think he means. I grew up in the South and lived in Seattle for more than a decade and I'd describe Seattle as equally fundamentalist as the South at this point; the only difference being the religion is environmentalism.
- jcomis 13y agoIt's a thing that happens all the time in Seattle. That is, publicly decry one group for doing something, but have zero problem with another group doing nearly (or exactly) the same thing. and as a member of nwdiveclub (the local dive forum) I can say that they have zero problem discussing and participating in harvesting of ocean life.
- judk 13y agoI was hoping this would be about the Northwest Tree Octopus.
- stevvooe 13y agoThat octopus has been at Cove 2 on Alki for years. I got my SCUBA certification there nearly 8 years ago and every greybeard diver raved about this particular octupus. One of the stops on the certification dive was this old, broken sewer line that exposed a cornucopia of marine life, including this huge octopus. May he/she rest in peace. Edit: Probably not the same octopus [1] but it made me nostalgic. [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enteroctopus_dofleini#Lifespan_and_reproduction http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Enteroctopus_dofleini#Lifespan_...
- mikeash 13y agoI'm always fascinated by the psychology of eating animals, and how society decides which ones are acceptable to eat and which ones aren't. Not that I'm any exception to it, of course, but I at least try to look at it from the outside a bit. We have a diver who killed an animal for food, and this generated tremendous outrage. Why? It's certainly not the bare fact that he killed an animal for food. That happens all the time, and people mostly don't care. He ended up doing it in front of a crowd, but that's not the reason either. If he had killed, say, a trout in front of a crowd, nobody would really care. Nor is it the kind of animal that he killed, not alone. If he had done it in private then told the public about what happened, there would have been no outcry. Clearly it's some combination of the kind of animal and doing it in public. There's no particular reason either one should matter, though. There is, it appears, nothing particularly special about this animal that makes it a bad choice for food compared to other animals. But clearly it does matter. I think it comes down to the simple fact that this was an unusual event. And though there was nothing specific about this event that should lead to outcry, the mere fact that it was unusual is enough. A lot of city dwellers are fundamentally uncomfortable with eating meat. Most of them still do it, but they hide behind the various structures that exist between the living animal and their dinner plate to kind of ignore it. I've heard of people seriously saying things like, "It's wrong to kill an animal for meat. You should just buy it from the grocery store." I'm sure most people are not that ignorant, but there's a similar sort of avoiding thinking about the stark reality of slaughtering and butchering. So you have a bunch of people suddenly confronted with that which they try to ignore. Some of them are outraged by the mechanics of killing and eating an animal. But most of them still eat cows and pigs and chickens which are routinely killed in ways not really different from this. What reason could there be for their outrage, then? It can't be that they're outraged at the overall concept of killing an animal for food. But, ah hah! This is an unusual animal, so it must be that! And that, I think, is how you end up with a conservation campaign for an animal that is not endangered and not, ultimately, all that special. I could be way off, but it's interesting to think about.
- stevvooe 13y agoYou're not way off, but, in this case, it has more to do with the fact that the Cove 2 Octopi are particularly beloved among the Seattle diving community.
- jaimebuelta 13y agoI find this interesting. Where I'm from (Spain), octopi are routinely eaten and are considered delicious. I guess it depends on the person, but I'd say piscitarians will eat them. What he did will be considered the same as someone fishing for, let's say, trout. I guess it depends a lot on the local culture.
- the_watcher 13y ago>> was just liking to look at it reason enough. This made me think about pandas. I'm not an expert in this at all, so please correct me if I am wrong about any of this, but it seems like the panda bear's evolutionary adaptation is that humans think they are cute. They rarely reproduce, sometimes roll over and kill their own young, and eat bamboo, which I believe they struggle to digest. But, humans love them, so they get lots of protection.
- jlgreco 13y agoThat seems more like luck of the draw than an adaptation. They're not domesticated (like livestock or cats/dogs) and probably have not been relying on humans for very long. Furthermore, IIRC they are more reluctant to breed in captivity than in the wild, so being cute isn't exactly helping their population numbers like it would other animals.
- amac 13y agoI noticed my site (http://octopus.org http://octopus.org) spiked in traffic today - can't be co-incidental. Octopus are fascinating and the more we learn about them, the more they fascinating they become.
- andrewflnr 13y agoI'm concerned a lot less about people eating octopus than about the only legal way to take them being a slow death by blunt trauma. I'm very much a canrnivore, but for pity's sake, make it quick. If the point was to only allow taking them through bycatch, why not just say that?
- scott_karana 13y agoYeah, that's pretty strange. You can't kill an octopus with a swift knife blow, or a speargun? Every hunter I've met prefers a quick kill, for both ethical and culinary reasons (adrenaline-soaked meat).
- ryanisinallofus 13y agoI'm a vegetarian who is supportive of hunting. If you are going to eat meat, hunting and butchering it yourself is by far the most ethical and environmentally sound method of obtaining flesh as food. I simply can't reason with someone who finds it OK to eat an animal, but sleeps with one on the foot of her bed, and rages when someone else hunts. That said eating octopus and specifically the GPO is particularly unethical if you subscribe to intelligence being related to sentience. Additionally it appears that octpus legs contain brain cells, the part you eat is in part brain.
- glitch003 13y agoYes but as someone said above, pigs are also particularly intelligent animals, and we eat the hell out of them. So how can you reconcile those two things?
- scott_karana 13y agoWhy would ryanisinallofus need to reconcile those things? He is a vegetarian. I'd say that we meat-eaters are the ones who have to reconcile them.
- btbuildem 13y agoYou know what.. the kid went into the ocean, and wrestled a friggin' octopus out of it. By hand. As far as hunting goes, that's pretty much the most fair way to do it. Save your lamenting for the industrial-scale mechanized harvest of creatures. His grilled octopus (or whatever he did with it) was orders of magnitude more ethical than that burger you're about to eat.
- jeffblake 13y agoI'm a SCUBA instructor (trained and living in Vancouver BC), from Seattle.. and I can definitely attest to the character of pacific northwest divers as being very pro-environment, "protect the wildlife", to the point of craziness. Oh man, I can only imagine the aggressive and passive-aggressive reactions this kid got when he pulled that thing out of the water... Sure, they're nice creatures. If I had a choice, more often than not I would say let the thing be. But I also own a speargun and hunt on occasion. I like the sport, and it feels good to put your own skills on the table once in a awhile. What irritates me is how irrationally angry people get... it's an act of selfishness, a chance for a relatively passive person to stand up for something. It's not really about the octopus, it's about their beliefs. People have to stand for something... whether that's Obama or an Octopus, it doesn't really matter. The cool thing about running a company, as I'm sure a lot of people here do, is how quickly you get to see the big picture on the world, and sit in the shoes of everyone else's perspective. Wearing a lot of hats and working on hard things really trains you to only give a shit about things that matter, things you can have an influence on, where the goal is not to change people's opinion subjectively, but to prove, objectively, that you can add value and earn a place on this planet.