2 ms·
As lbarrow said, I use a credit card. It used to be that debit cards offered almost no protection. I think they're competitive with credit cards now, but that m
by MBCook 13y ago
As lbarrow said, I use a credit card. It used to be that debit cards offered almost no protection. I think they're competitive with credit cards now, but that may only be when you're using it like a credit card. I don't know if this would count towards my fraud protection (which, honestly, I know nothing about).
Really, it's because I use my credit card as a firewall account. If my credit card gets compromised (which has happened twice before), I have to change maybe a dozen things that link to it. It's an inconvenience, but my bank can get me a new card the next day. Worst case scenario I lose my credit card for a week or so.
If my checking account is compromised, things are worse. If my checking account gets locked, not only can I not use it, I also can't pay my credit card. I'd have to setup my paycheck (pain), rent (pain), and some other things. Then I'd have to re-link a couple of other bank accounts. While I like my current bank, I don't want to take the risk of that account being locked for a week.
The idea of giving a random website (in that I don't have an account/relationship with them) a number that provides direct access to my paycheck gives me the shivers.
You could do basically the same thing with ACH. If a payment service asked you to enter your routing and account numbers, would you be OK with that? I see it as the same thing.
- foxylad 13y agoAs a non-USAsian, I'm always puzzled by the American's paranoia about their bank account details. In most countries, bank account numbers are effectively public knowledge, and appear at the bottom of invoices and such. The trick is that with this knowledge you can pay money in to an account, but you can't get it out - for that you need authorisation. This makes paying via echeck or direct credit very easy. Am I right that in the US you can get money out of an account if you know the account number? If not, why the secrecy about your bank account numbers?
- MBCook 13y agoIt may be a historical thing. Whenever you get a receipt from an ATM or a store, your account number if blocked out (so you end up with "XXXXXXXX9585") for privacy reasons. I honestly don't know dangerous exposing my account numbers would be. Consumer protection laws can be hit-or-miss (or, in many cases, just plain missing). It's easier to just be careful.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoYes, in the US you can take money out of an account if you know the number. No, it's not a good system.
- bdegman 13y agoI'm no expert by any means but aren't the account number and routing number both printed on the bottom of every check? Are you saying that simply giving a check to someone compromises your checking account?
- thaumasiotes 13y agoYes, they are printed on the bottom of checks because they are the information that allows conversion of the check into money. Yes, giving a check to someone compromises your account. You're trusting the other person to do nothing other than withdraw the amount on the check, but you're giving them enough information to withdraw whatever you have in your account.
- encoderer 13y agoAnd be charged with a crime for it. That's the other part. Not just trust.
- aioprisan 13y agoActually, you can't just take funds out. How would you do that, counterfeit a check and commit fraud by cashing it in? The bank ATMs/teller machines would reject that check and you'd find yourself in prison very quickly.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoYou use the system backing check processing, ACH. Theoretically, this is similar to counterfeiting a check, except: - these are electronic requests, so there's nothing to distinguish "genuine" from "fraudulent" ones - you really do have all of the information that goes into an ACH payment Really, it's much more similar to forging a check than to counterfeiting one.
- MichaelApproved 13y agoRemember that the person you're replying to said "which, honestly, I know nothing about". To remove money from a US account, you also need authorization. The trick thieves use is to lie about having authorization. In that case, it's fraud. I don't know of many fraudulent transactions that can't be reversed. Even fraudulent/unauthorized wire transfers can be reversed. The bigger problem is the hassle that comes with losing access to cash while the situation is resolved. Can someone with actual banking knowledge correct me where I'm wrong and clear up this confusion?