3 ms·
Were you aware that 23&Me also had an exome sequencing pilot ? https://www.23andme.com/exome/ https://www.23andme.com/exome/ That addresses the "resolution of
by dekhn 13y ago
Were you aware that 23&Me also had an exome sequencing pilot ? https://www.23andme.com/exome/ https://www.23andme.com/exome/
That addresses the "resolution of testing that 23andMe can provide".
The other point is that humans cluster into a small number of haplogroups, and with a small number of WGS or exomes, we can impute many things on the other lower-resolution data based on the fact people are very closely related.
I'm not defending the current approaches (GWAS, etc). They are known-broken. Nor am I defending exome sequencing - also known-broken.
Anyway, it's trivial now to do 1000+ genomes at 4X coverage, which gets you many of the rare variants.
Of course, at the end of the day, the current approaches are unlikely to unlock the full medical potential of the genome. Most people studying genomics and health have very limited mental models of how cells and tumors and organs work, and none of the existing methods really do anything beyond correlation analysis on noisy data.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI was a 23andme.com customer from the very beginning; didn't know they had an exome beta. Thanks for the info, signed up waiting to be in the next batch!
- dekhn 13y agoIllumina does WGS for $5000. It's more than just that, there is a whole conference you attend to learn more about the process and what it means. I think you also get an iPad. :-) http://www.illumina.com/company/events/understand-your-genome.ilmn http://www.illumina.com/company/events/understand-your-genom... It's new business development- Illumina's interested in jumpstarting the clinical WGS/consumer genetics industry, so they hold things like this, expecting other companies will pick up the model and focus on it). Because Illumina makes money on the consumables, having such an industry will be very profitable for them.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoThank you for this info!
- pfisch 13y agoWhy exactly? Did you watch Gattaca and think to yourself: "That is the type of world I want to live in!" It just seems like there is some small chance that sequencing everyone will make the world better, and a much larger chance that it will make it worse. Do you believe that your data is secure with them?
- toomuchtodo 13y agoI believe that my DNA "data" is intrinsically insecure; pop cans, hairs I leave just from being in a spot, etc. If someone wants me genome, it is fairly trivially for them to obtain it; I believe the benefits of sequencing outweigh the risks.
- pfisch 13y agoThat is like saying your bank info is insecure because you shred it and throw it away. It is one thing for someone to steal your hair and run a somewhat expensive genome sequencing on it. It is another to have it already sequenced and stored in an internet accessible database in a easy to read file format next to all of the other relevant data I would want. Of course this is stored next to thousands or millions of other already sequenced genomes that are also in the correct format and accessible without me even leaving this chair. My email address or credit card info generally doesn't get stolen from my shredded trash. It gets stolen from a 3rd party database chock full of tons of other emails making it a goldmine for people who want email addresses/credit card numbers.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoLike I said, I'm not worried about it. My DNA is already publicly available as part of the Personal Genome Project: https://www.personalgenomes.org/ https://www.personalgenomes.org/
- mbreese 13y agoI wouldn't hold your breath... that beta ran a few samples in (I think) 2011-2012, but I haven't heard of anyone getting an exome processed after the initial batch. You're probably better off sending a sample to one of the commercial sequencing companies. I'm sure someone on here has more info about it than I do though...
- berdario 13y agoThis is very interesting... how is GWAS or exome sequencing broken? Wikipedia says about exome sequencing that's a "cheaper but still effective alternative to whole genome sequencing." I have some basic knowledge of biology, but I'm don't know anything about sequencing... do you have some details?
- dekhn 13y agoGWAS is... well, GWAS is just a technique to find statistical correlations between genotypes and phenotypes. It's a very limited (powerful in one way, but limited in many others) way to approach the problem of "to what extent do mutations in DNA cause phenotype changes". It requires fairly large sample sizes to do reliably for diseases which don't have a really strong (mendelian or otherwise) signal, it's fairly poor at working with pairs or larger # of interactions between genes, can't do much with genes and the environment, and is a really simiplified model of how organismal biology works, anyway. there are a few issues with exome: 1) exome prep is a big issue in itself 2) exome leaves out large regions which are likely to be important in understanding many aspects of human biology At this point, I'm speculating: even whole genome sequence at relatively high coverage per individual * large # of individuals is likely to not explain all the aspects of organismal biology. There appears to be a fair amount of state that is transferred from a parent cell to a child cell during mitosis that is not expressed in our current DNA assemblies. The whole chromosomes themselves are complex, enormous structures that undergo massive rearrangements during the various phases of the cell cycle... yet are still capable of maintaining tons of epigenetic state. Very little or none of this is really being analyzed in a systematic or rigorous way, which is frustrating to see because, as somebody with a training in human molecular biology, all of this has been KNOWN FOR DECADES! I mean seriously, Chapter One of Molecular Cell Biology, please!