4 ms·
Since you are defending this kind of practices, I must ask you: Can you name a single other service or product in the world that include such restrictions, and
by belorn 13y ago
Since you are defending this kind of practices, I must ask you: Can you name a single other service or product in the world that include such restrictions, and "up to X" quantity?
If I only got 50% of the actually contracted time of an rented apartment (say they wrote "up to 1 month"), I would sue. If the fine print said apartment had restrictions such as only 10 enter/exits, no commercial activities inside it like programming, no more than 2 visiting friends per month, and only allowed using the apartment for 12hrs per day, I would sue.
Why do we still allow this for Internet connectivity when we wouldn't for any other kind of utility service?
- jiggy2011 13y agoWhy would you sue? You signed the lease. Most rentals have some agreement for the tenants , terms that forbid business use , redecorating or changing furniture are fairly standard. Also in houses with multiple tenants you have to agree to share communal facilities.
- adestefan 13y agoPower companies do the same thing.
- datasage 13y agoYour analogy doesn't hold up very well. There are rentals that are restricted much more than your average apartment, they are called hotel rooms. There are different options available, because there is demand for it. The same applies to ISP service. In general residential service is over subscribed. This allows the company to discount the service in return for restrictions on how it can be used. There are also dedicated bandwidth options, which are much more expensive. But you can use it pretty much however you want.
- enneff 13y agoAll you can eat buffets don't let you fill up takeaway boxes.
- maxsilver 13y agoTo be clear, I'm not defending most of it. I'm only defending 'ISP's can charge less to home users in exchange for them agreeing not to do specific things'. I'm not defending the anti-competitive nature of laws in the USA. I'm not defending overzealous use of 'home/business' seperation. And I'm not defending overselling backhaul - - - In your example, you use an rented apartment. This is a perfect example, a rented apartment is like the 20x20 MetroE line I described above, you can do whatever you want, you paid for the whole thing. A timeshare is what your looking for -- a timeshare also a rented apartment (or house, ect), but you dont get all the time, you only get a piece of it (say 'up to 1 month per year'). You get a significantly lower rate (in theory) on a timeshare, because you only get a part of a time. Timeshares are cheaper than a full apartment lease. You got the cheaper rate because you agreed to the restrictions. - - - Even ownership doesn't absolve you of these restrictions. For example, if you buy a condominium, you usually agree to the condo boards rules (many of which include things like "no guests for more than 7 days" or "no commercial / industry / business / trade activity") http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2002-12-08/business/0212080039_1_board-members-scope-unit http://articles.chicagotribune.com/2002-12-08/business/02120... - - - If you want me to name 'other services or products that include these restrictions', I can name a bunch : - Rental Cars (mileage restriction, modification restriction) - Leased Cars (mileage restriction, modification restriction) - Hotel Rooms (limits on number of people present, not allowed to use it for commercial activities, ect) - Electricity (limit to how much you can use at residential rates, if you exceed this, your price usually jumps.) - Commercial Libraries, e.g. Universities (time limits on checked out books, if you exceed them, you pay late fees. Not allowed to re-lend-out books you've borrowed from the library. Not allowed to make copies of books you've borrowed from the library. Ect.) - - - EDIT : Full disclosure, I'm trying to start an new Internet Service Provider that isn't evil, from scratch, using our own network. (Not re-selling DSL / Cable). It's really really difficult. I'm as pro-user pro-net-neutrality pro-open-internet anti-censorship pro-EFF as they come. But from a mathematical standpoint, the numbers don't work out. There's no way to cover expenses selling dedicated 50x50mbps uncapped, completely unrestricted internet connections for $30-60/month (unless your Google, and can subsidize the whole thing). Normal home users are fine. People who just want burst fast speeds, but push some number less than 300-600GB total each month, no problem. I don't care if your running some webcams / Minecraft servers / web servers / SSH / VPN / programming for your business / accepting orders / selling ETSY stuff / ect. But "power users" who want to host small data centers on their $30/month residential plan, or are seeding terrabytes of Torrent data each month, or are trying to resell that connection -- it can't happen today. Your making your friends and neighbors pay more for your crazy high usage. You need to be on a business plan, and pay for dedicated internet. Remember, 600GB is a huge amount of bandwidth for a home user. That's enough to stream 25 days straight of tv-quality video (or 214 hours of HD Netflix) I have no problem with heavy bandwidth users. But I do have a problem with heavy bandwidth users who insist they pay only the bare minimum rates because of their flawed interpretation of 'network neutrality'.
- VanillaCafe 13y ago"Can you name a single other service or product in the world that include such restrictions, and "up to X" quantity?" Sure. Semitrucks pay greater highway tolls (and are subject to greater usage scruitiny e.g. weighing stations) than light vehicle traffic.
- count 13y agoTechnically, commercial activities in a rented apartment ARE generally restricted, either by zoning ordinances or lease terms. Residentially zoned areas generally do not allow 'business' to be conducted out of a home. Those ordinances are worded differently everywhere, so sometimes 'coding', where you don't have lots of foot traffic or visitors, is 'ok', and other times it's not allowed anyway. Just because it's unenforceable doesn't mean it's not against the law...