5 ms·
One of the really surprising things about Microsoft is that despite all the caustic internal politics, CEO antics, missteps, misfires, a business model designed
by bane 13y ago
One of the really surprising things about Microsoft is that despite all the caustic internal politics, CEO antics, missteps, misfires, a business model designed to extract maximum money from everybody, and even questionable development and design practices, on occasion really great software (and hardware) comes out of there.
World class, amazing, top of the industry with no true peers.
For example, despite all of the good ideas and theory and philosophy, open source, after 13 years of effort, (while there's definitely been good work done in the area) has yet to produce an office suite that's at least as good as MS-Office is in all areas.
I'm sure the MS-Office codebase is a horrible mess, but the end user bits are good enough for nearly all of the weird edge-cases that 99% of users want and 99% of users can learn to use it to some level of effectiveness in a couple afternoons.
That's amazing.
- quesera 13y agoI'd be interested to hear what your other examples are, but that doesn't surprise me at all. If OpenOffice (etc) ever had comparable staffing (quantity and variety, not even questioning quality) that MSOffice has had for 15-20 years, I'd expect more comparable results.
- wslh 13y agoif openoffice... It does not work that way since neither Apple nor Google can beat Microsoft Office with big budgets. Beyond talking about the technical aspects of Office what also matters is the marketing/sales machine. For example, I was present in negotiations between Microsoft and big (non US) state agencies, and you know what? The Microsoft guy was surely at more than 6 degress in the Microsoft organizational chart to Bill Gates but he could negotiate as if he was Bill Gates, he had that freedom. The agency was pushing open source and the guy said something like: the Office $ XXX price does not work for you? What about $ 5 per license?
- jmcqk6 13y ago>If OpenOffice (etc) ever had comparable staffing (quantity and variety, not even questioning quality) that MSOffice has had for 15-20 years, I'd expect more comparable results. Isn't that sort of the point, at least from their perspective?
- sliverstorm 13y agoThe Microsoft Hardware division in general makes a lot of good stuff. Microsoft makes some of my favorite mice & keyboards, and the Xbox has been an impressive business venture- only one generation to go from brand-new to top-dog. Windows Media Center was quite good, although it has been allowed to wither on the vine somewhat as market research apparently found it just wasn't used much Internet Explorer has of course picked up a lot of slack quite quickly. Has not surpassed open source, but they have done a pretty good job with it in recent times. Yes, it's still behind, but they started from behind. They are much less behind now.
- mtinkerhess 13y agoVisual Studio is probably the best way to write C++. Windows is probably the best operating system for the enterprise and is ahead of OS X and Linux in bringing a desktop OS to tablets and touch laptops. C# is arguably the best language for writing enterprise applications. Xbox arguably won the console war of the current generation. Kinect is the only consumer product like it. Surface Pro is probably the best desktop replacement tablet. (disclosure: microsoftie)
- pjmlp 13y agoActually C++ Builder is way much better, thanks to its RAD extensions, that have only now seen similar functionally appear in Visual C++ with their C++/CX extensions. But Borland/Imprise/Codegear/Embarcadero lost track long time ago and is currently only relevant to a few enterprise customers.
- vetinari 13y agoYou don't seem to notice that many of the categories you mentioned are irrelevant. Maybe being microsoftie clouds your view? Windows may be best _desktop_ operating system for enterprise, not _best_ operating system. Subtle difference. OSX and Linux are not bringing desktop OS to tablets and touch laptops, because nobody wants desktop OS there, everybody wants tablet optimized OS. C# may be syntactically best language for enterprise, but it's ecosystem is lacking compared to other languages (for too long, it was use-MS-only-frameworks-and-products-land, so nobody bothers now). It is disputable whether Xbox won the game console war, but even if it did, this is a niche market. Kinect may be very unique, but we are talking niche in the niche. Surface Pro may be the best desktop replacement tablet, but nobody wants to replace desktop with tablets, just like nobody wants to replace truck with sport car.
- bane 13y agoI find it hard to take a comment seriously that says the console video game market is a niche market. I mean, it's only a what, >$70 billion dollar a year industry (bigger than the entire film industry) and the fastest growing segment of the entire media market globally?
- bane 13y agoBear in mind, I have no particular love for the company (I'm typing this on my rMBP right now). But I like to acknowledge good work when it happens. I know that all of these can be argued against, and some of my choices below are easy to argue as not great software -- but compared to any other competitor is still better (e.g. if mail and calendars are so easy why aren't there loads of Outlook/Exchange competitors?) - Remote Desktop is really good. VNC is "ok" but my God I miss Remote Desktop in the Apple world - Pretty much any MS-Office product, highlights are Excel, Powerpoint, and Outlook. (Much better on Windows machines than Macs BTW, in much the same way iTunes is better on Macs than Windows) - Visio, not without it's quirks but other competitors are all "ok" - Project - are there any serious competitors? - OneNote - Explorer, I've yet to see a file manager as good. It's lightyears beyond the abomination that is Finder for example. I could go on, but it's probably one of the reasons alternative media organizers are not as common on Windows machines as Macs - Visual Studio - I can see some arguments one way or the other, but it really is a world-class dev environment. - Online Office apps are easily the best office web apps by far - SQL Server is actually very good. - Flight Simulator now outdated, but top of the game for many years - Midtown Madness as an open world driving game - Encarta was awesome - Halo series and hardware - the Xbox systems - really nice mice and keyboards - Xbox controllers - Kinect - the surface pro is actually a pretty amazing full fledged portable PC, I'd put one up against an Air anytime, except it has the slight edge of the much more robust Windows software ecosystem
- TheLegace 13y agoOh my gosh the days I remember playing Midtown Madness, it was the only game I ever really bought and played endlessly. It was such an addictive game. I can't believe it was made by MS.
- berntb 13y agoOh, how things change. Time was, that comment wouldn't need to be written. Let me note that Halo was made by Bungie, a Mac company. It was going to come out for Macs, but it went Xbox after Bungie was bought. Everyone with monopoly money can buy good products late in their development. My problem with MS is the monopolist strategy. A monopolist need to keep the APIs hard to reimplement on another OS, to lock applications (and their users) to its platform. Complexity is needed for that -- and also to keep the OS API base a moving target with bug compatibility etc. You see this horror of complexity throughout the whole ecosystem, not only for the suffering heroes working with compatibility with the Office file formats or the virtual file systems. This extra complexity lowered my personal life quality, when the world was a dinosa... cough, Microsoft world. That makes it personal -- my personal pain.
- wsc981 13y agoFor what it's worth (probably nothing :P), I find Office a horrible piece of software that I avoid like the plague. I think the interfaces of apps like Word, Excel is too crowded (too much buttons, options) and rather use more limited alternatives, even if they're a bit crappy (looking at you, Google Docs). With regards to PowerPoint, I think Apple's Keynote is a much better designed and usable app for presentations.
- bane 13y agoI don't disagree. I fire up much simpler ASCII editors quite frequently to just get stuff done. But they're really worth learning beyond the surface level use-cases as extra tools in the toolbox. re: Keynote - I think Keynote tends to just produce better looking presentations, but you'd be impressed with some of the ways I've seen Powerpoint pressed in to service that had nothing to do with presentations. A few of them are so useful to me (e.g., Powerpoint is actually a pretty decent easy-to-use graphics and chart maker, vector graphics tool, logo designer, UI mockup tool etc.) that the ability to do those things are so important to me that I won't switch to another presentation tool until they can do them. edit for example, I made this entire image out of nothing but powerpoint vectors and a few power point vector effects http://i.imgur.com/qK7XxM5.jpg http://i.imgur.com/qK7XxM5.jpg
- melling 13y agoYou're really looking at this from so many incorrect ways that I'm not really sure where to start. First of all, "good ideas, theory and philosophy" only go so far when we're talking thousands of more developers and billions of dollars. Excel, is pretty awesome but it's not perfect. I often find myself using Open Office because of some UTF8 issues when importing data into Excel. I own Excel but I use Open Office just as often. Visio, Access, and PowerPoint were purchased by Microsoft. Sure they continued to develop them, but at one point I used Access for 5-6 years and it hardly got any major features when Microsoft upgraded Office. So, these great innovations didn't originate with Microsoft. The major reason that you don't see much competition with Office is because of their proprietary formats have basically won. People don't want 99% compatibility, they need 100%, so other vendors have fallen out of the game because they can't make the same level of investment. As for being easy to learn, I think if you Google "Microsoft Office classes", you'll find that lots of people still require training. Just switching to the Ribbon Bar caused problems for many users.
- bane 13y agoI didn't downvote you, but I think you deserve a point-for-point >First of all, "good ideas, theory and philosophy" only go so far when we're talking thousands of more developers and billions of dollars. Excel, is pretty awesome but it's not perfect. I often find myself using Open Office because of some UTF8 issues when importing data into Excel. I own Excel but I use Open Office just as often. True, it's not perfect, but it's OO is simply not comparable. I'm not saying OO is bad either, just that Excel really is fantastic as far as software goes. The more important question is why haven't the thousands of developers and billions of development time spent on open source software not only built comparable software, but better software? > Visio, Access, and PowerPoint were purchased by Microsoft. Sure they continued to develop them, but at one point I used Access for 5-6 years and it hardly got any major features when Microsoft upgraded Office. So, these great innovations didn't originate with Microsoft. So? When was PowerPoint purchased? 1987? I'd be willing to wager one entire American dollar that there aren't more than 100 lines of original "Presenter" code in today's PowerPoint. More importantly, in all that time they've managed not to drive it into the ground, but keep it at the pinnacle of presentation software. Keynote is probably the closest thing PowerPoint has to a reasonable competitor after almost 3 decades. >The major reason that you don't see much competition with Office is because of their proprietary formats have basically won. People don't want 99% compatibility, they need 100%, so other vendors have fallen out of the game because they can't make the same level of investment. Again so? OO has had it's own format for many years now thank you and still isn't as good of a piece of software. The format the tool uses is orthogonal to the quality of the software. And OO simply isn't as good. It's not bad, it's good even, but not as good. > As for being easy to learn, I think if you Google "Microsoft Office classes", you'll find that lots of people still require training. Just switching to the Ribbon Bar caused problems for many users. There are <insert topic> classes for just about everything Google "how to use a mouse" and you'll find a few million helpful sites on them. Fact is, a computer illiterate person can learn how to write a reasonable document, or do basic spreadsheety things with a little prompting. To fully invalidate your point, believe it or not, there are actually Open Office classes and even iWorks classes. No software is so easy to use that somebody who's never seen it before can walk up to it and start using it and it's a delusion that software can be that's a continuous problem with many tech communities. It's an issue that goes back to the late '70s, and if somebody hasn't learned to use a computer decently in the last 40 years I'd submit that no amount of work in software interfaces will ever overcome that barrier.
- nemothekid 13y ago>World class, amazing, top of the industry with no true peers. I'd argue you could say company with billions of dollars and the prestige to hire world class programmers. Windows Phone is an amazing piece of software, and if we got it 3-4 years earlier, it may have stood a chance.
- adventured 13y agoIt could still stand a chance. Microsoft needs to do two things. 1) Give the mobile group vastly more independence to escape the dying desktop business. 2) Make Windows Phone compatible with Android applications. Bribe every major hardware vendor to put out a big new line of Windows Phones to launch with said compatibility. There would no doubt be big tradeoffs in doing this, but it'd be worth it, and would make use of the classic Microsoft strategy of embrace and extend that they seem to have lost an appreciation for after dominating for so long. It's a trojan horse approach superior to their goofy dual booting idea. I see no reason Microsoft couldn't acquire 20% of the mobile market. Their currently mediocre strategy has delivered some success in Europe, so imagine what a good strategy could deliver. The real question is, can owning 20% of mobile ever be worth the cost if you don't own the hardware (Apple & Samsung)? I don't think so.
- throwawaykf 13y agoThe desktop business is not dying, it's just reaching its natural equilibrium in a world where tablets are sufficient for casual use. But no way are smartphones and tablets going to replace the machines that are used to do most of the work, so the "workhorse" market is pretty safe. One way to leverage this (and pretty sure MS is doing it) is the opposite of what you suggest: to make their smartphones an effective auxiliary device for PCs, beyond just email and exchange and Office. Something like SmartGlass for productivity. Interestingly, there's already work from MSR along these lines, but it seems some way off. As for Android compatibility, BlueStacks already goes a long way there. If they want to, they could snap them up anytime, but I'm not sure they'll want to capitulate on that front.
- kbart 13y ago> Their currently mediocre strategy has delivered some success in Europe, so imagine what a good strategy could deliver. I would argue that this "success" is Microsoft's achievement. It happened just because Windows Phone was made by Nokia, which has (had) a good name and market share in Europe. And we know how it turned out for them..
- ZeroGravitas 13y agoIf you had a team of the best programmers on earth, and big money backing, could you build a Facebook competitor? A new video codec? A new Free Software kernel? Presumably one of the first discussions would bring up "network effects" and you'd conclude that a frontal assault on these markets would be suicidal. Then you'd find some other project to pursue. Same goes for Office. It's not "good" any more than a private railroad/electricity/telephone system is "good", it's just sheltered from direct competition by network effects. And without direct competition you really have no basis to judge it on.
- bane 13y ago> a Facebook competitor actually yes. There's lots of things that I, and many of my friends wish, Facebook did that it doesn't do...and many things it does that we wish it didn't. Enough to build a competitor? Definitely. Would it be popular? Who knows?