4 ms·
The property taxes cited are fascinating. $3k per year on a 20 million dollar home??? As they say, there's your problem right there. I've come to appreciate t
by foobarian 13y ago
The property taxes cited are fascinating. $3k per year on a 20 million dollar home??? As they say, there's your problem right there.
I've come to appreciate the extent to which property taxes drive a country's culture or system of living. I grew up in an eastern European country where property taxes don't exist, and so there are tons of people who live in quite posh inherited/grandfathered-from-communist-times residences while receiving tiny incomes in comparison. Meanwhile the property tax rates common in the U.S. tend to drive out people who stop being able to afford to live in a locale.
- to3m 13y agoThe UK does not have property taxes. The figure given is presumably council tax, which is a fixed fee per household, vaguely based on the house's supposed value. The highest council tax band is quite low; i pay £2,000 per year, and my flat is worth a lot less than $20m.
- bencoder 13y agoAlso council tax is paid only by the resident, not by the owner, so it's not felt by foreign owners if they are renting it out, or even if it's empty.
- frobozz 13y agoThis is correct about rented properties, but not about empty ones. Empty properties can attract a discounted rate of council tax, but are only exempt under certain circumstances (resident in prison/hospital, house unlivable). Long-term empty properties can even attract a higher rate of council tax.
- chuable 13y agoThat last part is simply incorrect; Councils have a time limit on whether empty properties are exempt from council tax. Also, there's an extra 50% penalty if it's been empty/unfurnished for 2 years or more: https://www.gov.uk/council-tax/second-homes-and-empty-properties https://www.gov.uk/council-tax/second-homes-and-empty-proper...
- objclxt 13y ago>The property taxes cited are fascinating. $3k per year on a 20 million dollar home??? As they say, there's your problem right there. It's very misleading, or downright wrong. Firstly, you'll pay tax on the sale (stamp duty), of 7%. There used to be a loophole for corporations, but that's now been closed (if you buy as a corporation you'll pay 15%). So already you've paid $1.4 million in tax. You then pay council tax, which isn't property tax, but a tax for basic services such as waste disposal, etc, that your local authority provides. It normally isn't very helpful to 'pick and choose' taxes when comparing them to the US, partly because the UK taxes some things very differently. For example, a sales tax in the US of 20% would be political suicide, but yet that's effectively what happens in the UK with VAT.
- Daishiman 13y agoVAT is not a 20% sales tax; it's a 20% tax over the profit the seller has over the final customer. If a seller has a 40% profit margin on a product then he pays taxes over that, not the entire cost of whatever he's selling.
- Luc 13y agoIt's the customer who pays VAT. Businesses don't pay VAT, they only collect it for the tax man (and in cases where they have paid it, they claim it back).
- taejo 13y agoVAT and sales tax have the same effect. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VAT#Comparison_with_sales_tax https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/VAT#Comparison_with_sales_tax
- pja 13y agoFirstly, you'll pay tax on the sale (stamp duty), of 7%. On a £20million property? It'll be owned by a shell company in the Vigin Islands or some other tax haven & only the ownership of the company will ever change hands so no stamp duty will be due in the UK. Yes, this is iniquitous. Stamp duty should clearly be replaced by a better targeted land tax, but good luck getting any UK government to make that change...
- gopi 13y agoI think this phenomenon of using house as a place to park money exists mainly in countries with insignificant property tax. For example in India, China and most of Europe people park their money in property rather than stocks. A 2% yearly property tax may change it!