3 ms·
Higher taxes on income can help with the deficit, no question. However, you realistically can't raise taxes enough in America to fill the $750 billion deficit.
by adventured 13y ago
Higher taxes on income can help with the deficit, no question. However, you realistically can't raise taxes enough in America to fill the $750 billion deficit.
To balance the issue, I like to ask a simple question: what did America get in exchange for doubling the size of its government between 2000 and 2012? (during which population increased by a mere 11%)
Is our economy better off? No, we have the greatest amount of poverty since the great depression (15% U6 unemployment, 46 million on food stamps, etc). Do we have less debt? No, twice as much. Is our military stronger? No, it's worn out, we've lost thousands of good soldiers and our weapons are destroyed, having lost a small war machine in the desert. Is Social Security more solvent? No, it's bleeding red ink now. Is our infrastructure better? No, it's in shockingly horrendous shape. Is our electrical grid, and energy production improved? No, it's collapsing, with black-outs ten times higher compared to 20 years ago. Are we safer, with a hundred billion in added domestic security spending? I'd argue not, that it's mostly security theater. Do we have a higher home ownership rate? No. Do we have less consumer debt? No, more. Is our education system flourishing? No, it's an absolute disaster, from K-12 results, to the trillion dollars in college debt. Do we have more full time jobs? No, seven million less since 2007, and about 92% of the jobs being created over the last year are part-time jobs. Do we have more manufacturing jobs? No. Has the long promised manufacturing boom from cheap natural gas arrived? No. Is Washington DC functioning properly, such that we can trust them to be responsible with our hard earned tax dollars? No. Do we have a lot less people committing welfare fraud? No, SS disability has enrolled millions in just six years that are lying about their inability to work. This list doesn't stop going.
So what did we get for the extra $18 trillion above population growth in spending over 12 years? What did we get for all the debt? Absolutely nothing. So we should just keep spending more? That's going to have an obvious outcome.
- millstone 13y ago> what did America get in exchange for doubling the size of its government between 2000 and 2012? That's a valid question. Working from www.usgovernmentspending.com, I found the increase to be about $1.7 trillion. $300 billion is health care, mostly Medicaid; $500 billion from increased defense spending, and $300 billion in transfer payments, including unemployment, food stamps, SSI, and the child tax credit. Inflation accounts for about $500 billion as well. So to answer your question, "what we got" is that we are able to pay for the increase in medical costs, the increase in the number of people needing assistance, and the War on Terror. With the exception of the military, these increases are mostly in reaction to the changes in the economy, not due to new policies. Hopefully an improving economy will lift incomes and reduce the need for these programs.