7 ms·
See a lawyer. Seriously. See a lawyer. People on the internet are not lawyers; if they are lawyers, their main advice is go see a lawyer. Law is a profession
by jacques_chester 13y ago
See a lawyer.
Seriously. See a lawyer.
People on the internet are not lawyers; if they are lawyers, their main advice is go see a lawyer.
Law is a profession of tiny details with huge consequences. Those tiny details vary from place to place and from subject to subject. Even lawyers have lawyers.
If I learnt one and only one important lesson from my time in law school, it's this: If you have a question of law, go see a lawyer.
I mean it.
- badclient 13y agoEven doctors have doctors and barbers have barbers. So?
- jacques_chester 13y agoYou've added an example in doctors, actually. If a GP has cancer, he or she will go see an oncologist instead of just going on dimly recalled med school courses. The oncologist will see a sports physician about the shoulder injury from rugby, the sports physician sees an opthamologist about their slight ocular degeneration and so on and so forth. Law is a sufficiently large field (remember, the problem domain is "all interactions between humans") that it requires specialisation and so, in fact, lawyers must frequently consult with other lawyers. OP may get an answer from a general practice solicitor. Or that lawyer may need to consult another lawyer. Until he or she sees a lawyer it's not clear to us lay folk. Does this ever annoy you? You're good with computers, can you make a poster for me? It annoys me (well, these days I find it funny). Special subjects require specialists.
- ratsimihah 13y ago> tiny details with huge consequences. This reminds me of tax filling. > Even lawyers have lawyers. Do accountants have accountants too?
- DonPellegrino 13y agoYes, many (most?) accountants that don't specialize in personal accounting and tax filing recognize the value in having someone more knowledgeable than them take care of documents with a large impact on their lives.
- jacalata 13y agoYes. A friend was recommending her accountant the other day- she said initially it put her off that he didn't do his own taxes, but he explained that doing your own taxes is like representing yourself in court - even if you're qualified to do it for others, you should never do it for yourself.
- rwallace 13y agoSo why exactly are you advised not to do your own taxes or represent yourself in court even if qualified? (Not a rhetorical question; I'm curious about the answer.)
- nitrogen 13y agoThe penalty for you making a mistake is higher than the penalty for your accountant/lawyer making a mistake. By "penalty" I mean negative consequences, not just explicit fines.
- rwallace 13y agoOkay, what sort of negative consequences? And why does having someone else make the mistakes on your behalf protect you from the consequences?
- jacalata 13y agoI've never heard specifically, but I always assumed that you are less rational when handling your own problems than someone else's, and these fields both require pretty clear thinking.
- zobzu 13y agoWhile this is the safest thing to do and people should probably do so, I think this shouldn't be used as a "hey, we DONT want you to know". The simple fact that we have to tell people to go see a lawyer for protecting themselves just shows how wrong the society is (in the USA in particular) regarding laws. But more than that, people should at least be able to get an educated answer on what to do, other that "go pay money to that guy, he knows AND this will shield you from legal issues that could ruin your life." I mean, seriously.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI think this is availability bias. You notice the disputes and tricky questions that get referred to lawyers because these are unusual. The law almost always goes on without anybody having to notice or take additional action. We are always moving through and interacting with the invisible web of the law. It works so well that we only notice it when something goes awry or something unusual happens (like OP's situation -- if it were normal, people would have a better idea of what to do). Yesterday I entered into several legal contracts. We went through all the legal formalities under common and statue law, created mutually binding obligations, discharged our legal requirements and then went on our respective ways. These variously took the form of buying groceries, hailing a cab, buying dinner, picking up laundry (with the added bonus of bailee-bailor relationship) and getting a haircut. Because nothing unusual happened, I didn't think about the law. At all. But it was there.
- jfoster 13y agoActually, even consulting a lawyer won't shield you from legal issues.
- srgseg 13y agoIf our only understanding of the law came directly from consulting a lawyer, we'd all be very poor and very ignorant. There is nothing wrong with asking about the experiences of others who may have asked lawyers similar questions, as long as we understand that we should directly seek a lawyer's advice in proportion to what is at stake. By sharing our legal experiences, we'd all become better at understanding the specific questions we should ask a lawyer, should the need arise.
- logn 13y agoExactly. And it's not as though the OP or us reading necessarily want to go out and act on forum advice. Many of us are just curious and want to understand our laws and country better.
- jacques_chester 13y agoI disagree. As I said, law varies by place and subject. Those differences matter. Some subjects are generally consistent across jurisdictions. Some are not. Who knows which is which? The professionals. Who has the knowledge and experience to correctly interpret different experiences in different circumstances? The professionals. Intelligent people frequently form entirely inaccurate views of subjects in which they are not experts. We mock TV shows for having VB GUIs that track IP addresses. Lawyers feel a bit like this when non-lawyers begin swapping legal advice. > By sharing our legal experiences, we'd all become better at understanding the specific questions we should ask a lawyer, should the need arise. Lawyers are not unapproachable gods. They are service professionals like any other. You ring, make an appointment, and talk to them. It's really very simple. They will ask some questions and take some notes. If it's a simple matter they will give a simple answer. If it's more complicated they will ask to get back to you. Self-help and Stack Overflow is fine for writing most low-risk software, where bugs can be patched. It is a risky strategy with law. Some actions cannot be undone. You can't just revert to the "before I made that legal blunder" branch.
- srgseg 13y agoIt is important that we all have a broad understanding of what is legal, what is not, and where we need to seek advice and proceed with caution. We can then supplement that knowledge with specific legal advice from a lawyer when appropriate. We cannot possibly achieve a broad understanding of the law if the only knowledge we have about how the law works comes directly from our own personal conversations with a lawyer. I'm thinking of purchasing a 50 euro piece of software from a company in Germany. Do I need to obtain customs authorization to purchase software from countries other than the US? Perhaps I need a permit to run German software? Maybe it's against the law to even visit a site in Germany unless I'm an EU citizen? Perhaps I need to start paying some of my income and corporation taxes to Germany if my business uses any German software? If we are completely clueless about what is legal and what is not, the costs of running all of these questions past a lawyer would bring the economy to a halt.
- Dylan16807 13y agoThe answer might be "no way in hell", in which case a lawyer would be nothing more than a waste of money.
- AznHisoka 13y agoSaul Goodman never had a lawyer.