2 ms·
> overall, being poor is a very bad business policy >> It's bad business, but you may have a lot of incentives for it, given that welfare subsidies and service
by e12e 13y ago
> overall, being poor is a very bad business policy
>> It's bad business, but you may have a lot of incentives for it, given that welfare subsidies and services you may get in many US localities pay more than minimum wage job and in some localities more than average wage job.
Wait, what? If you have the choice of making more from welfare, than from a job, picking the (hypothetical) better financial option is an incentive for you to stay poor? How's that? If the alternative is to make less doing more work -- surely minimum wage is more of an "incentive" to stay poor?
(Lets not get into the discussion of "rich" welfare receivers and such, I'm just curious how you could see choosing the option to make more money as an incentive to stay poor, vs making less doing something else -- now if the person had the option to get a decent job, then that'd be diffrent?)
- smsm42 13y agoSimple: local maximum. If getting off welfare and into work implies immediate income loss, you are incentivized to stay on welfare, even if working would eventually make you better off, with time. If you are more inclined to respond to short term than long term incentives, you are stuck in a local maximum.
- e12e 13y agoBut there's no guarantee working would eventually make you better off? You're just taking that as a given. If there aren't any real prospect for higher pay -- then the issue isn't just "getting off welfare". Better welfare (say free college or other education/training) might make a difference, however. Now I agree that it would be good if people worked (if they are able) -- but in and off itself that doesn't make them better off.
- ctdonath 13y agoYes, there is no guarantee working would eventually make you better off. Odds are, however, you will work your way up the income ladder beyond what welfare will offer. You ARE guaranteed an income cap if you choose the welfare route: you CANNOT make more than $X or they'll dock your benefits fast enough that the transition to work is a powerful disincentive to doing so.
- lutusp 13y ago> But there's no guarantee working would eventually make you better off? Yes, of course, but if you can't buy milk for the children today, eventually isn't nearly soon enough.
- e12e 13y agoFor an example that (sort of) confirms my bias ;-), see: http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2006/07/art4full.pdf http://www.bls.gov/opub/mlr/2006/07/art4full.pdf "The likelihood of leaving low pay decreases dramatically as tenure in a low-paying job increases. Low- wage employment could itself decrease future wage growth if it causes workers to receive less training or skill development, conveys a negative signal to future employers, or provides access only or chiefly to weaker labor market networks. Significant numbers of stagnant low-wage earners could also be visible because of “sorting,” as those individuals with lower employment opportunities remain low- wage workers. The latter finding indicates that, not only is earnings mobility a reality for a substantial number of initially low earners, but also there is continued poverty within a large subpopulation of workers." In other words, it's not quite as simple as "work will always win".
- lutusp 13y ago> If you have the choice of making more from welfare, than from a job, picking the (hypothetical) better financial option is an incentive for you to stay poor? It's not an incentive, it's a trap, and it's why AFDC was abandoned. It works like this -- let's say you're on welfare. If it's a typical program you can stay in the program only if you don't make much money the usual way. Once you start making your own money, the welfare ends, often in such a way that you have a smaller income than before your personal income increased. This was true about AFDC and it killed the program -- it was a powerful disincentive to work, or to rise economically. It kept the poor poor -- they had a disincentive to move upward.