4 ms·
>>> A poor person has to buy insurance for his house and car, We're doing pretty good here if a poor person is implied to have a house worth insuring (implying
by smsm42 13y ago
>>> A poor person has to buy insurance for his house and car,
We're doing pretty good here if a poor person is implied to have a house worth insuring (implying either ownership or rental of sufficient value, containing sufficient assets) and a car, and is eligible for bank loans for both. In some countries, a person rich enough to have a house, a car and to qualify for bank loans for both is considered pretty well-to-do.
>>> A rich person can buy things in cash, and then self-insure using his assets to cover accidental losses.
I'm pretty sure most people, not only poor people, use car insurance. It's more convenient and usually (unless you drive exotic or super-expensive cars) cheaper than surety bonds that are usually required, and same with cash deposits (since cash deposited at DMV can't be used for anything else). For businesses having massive fleets, OTOH, it may make sense to self-insure since they get the same risk distribution as insurers, but without the middleman.
>>> overall, being poor is a very bad business policy
It's bad business, but you may have a lot of incentives for it, given that welfare subsidies and services you may get in many US localities pay more than minimum wage job and in some localities more than average wage job.
http://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/why-get-welfare http://www.cato.org/publications/commentary/why-get-welfare
http://www.cato.org/publications/white-paper/work-versus-welfare-trade http://www.cato.org/publications/white-paper/work-versus-wel...
>>> rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer is backed up by simple economics.
It may be but it definitely is not backed up but what you said. The thing is that statistics that talk about "rich getting richer" makes you assume that same people that were rich 20 years ago got even richer now, and same people that were poor 20 years ago are even poorer now. In fact, nothing in this statistics point to it - what statistics can tell you is that some people were rich 20 years ago, and some different people are rich now, but it usually says nothing about how many of people rich today were rich or poor 20 years ago. It is completely normal for a person to be piss-poor while being a young student and become quite well established when retiring. Usually it comes from working hard and making a number of right choices on the way. Including, yes, saving diligently and having long-term view, which leverages the power of compound interest - but for this you need the right behavior.
- e12e 13y ago> overall, being poor is a very bad business policy >> It's bad business, but you may have a lot of incentives for it, given that welfare subsidies and services you may get in many US localities pay more than minimum wage job and in some localities more than average wage job. Wait, what? If you have the choice of making more from welfare, than from a job, picking the (hypothetical) better financial option is an incentive for you to stay poor? How's that? If the alternative is to make less doing more work -- surely minimum wage is more of an "incentive" to stay poor? (Lets not get into the discussion of "rich" welfare receivers and such, I'm just curious how you could see choosing the option to make more money as an incentive to stay poor, vs making less doing something else -- now if the person had the option to get a decent job, then that'd be diffrent?)
- smsm42 13y agoSimple: local maximum. If getting off welfare and into work implies immediate income loss, you are incentivized to stay on welfare, even if working would eventually make you better off, with time. If you are more inclined to respond to short term than long term incentives, you are stuck in a local maximum.
- e12e 13y agoBut there's no guarantee working would eventually make you better off? You're just taking that as a given. If there aren't any real prospect for higher pay -- then the issue isn't just "getting off welfare". Better welfare (say free college or other education/training) might make a difference, however. Now I agree that it would be good if people worked (if they are able) -- but in and off itself that doesn't make them better off.
- ctdonath 13y agoYes, there is no guarantee working would eventually make you better off. Odds are, however, you will work your way up the income ladder beyond what welfare will offer. You ARE guaranteed an income cap if you choose the welfare route: you CANNOT make more than $X or they'll dock your benefits fast enough that the transition to work is a powerful disincentive to doing so.
- lutusp 13y ago> We're doing pretty good here if a poor person is implied to have a house worth insuring ... Basically I agree, but for many people, buying a house on a mortgage is a modern kind of economic slavery. Young people often don't get the big picture, and sign a mortgage or two before appreciating the meaning of compound interest. House loan, car loan, a child or two, and your life is over. And there are forces in society who think that's a perfect outcome -- married people with these kinds of obligations have no political power or options -- they're doing all they can just to stay afloat. >> rich getting richer and the poor getting poorer is backed up by simple economics. > It may be but it definitely is not backed up but what you said. But it is. In a mathematical sense and in the long term, the distinction between rich and poor is a delicate balance, teetering on the fulcrum of compound interest. A few bad choices that at the time may seem trivial, like accepting an unfavorable mortgage rate, over time can decide your economic fate. Also my point about credit cards -- if you run a perpetual balance on a card, you're in essence loaning money to rich people. Over time these and other similar factors cause a widening chasm between rich and poor. There really is some substance behind this folk saying.
- smsm42 13y ago>>> and sign a mortgage or two before appreciating the meaning of compound interest. Signing a mortgage is not that easy nowdays, you have to show appropriate income. Though yes, basics of economics, finance and statistics should be taught in every school right after arithmetic. There's not many things that are as important in modern world and as widely being ignored. >>> House loan, car loan, a child or two, and your life is over I know a lot of people who have houses, cars and children, and their life is far from over. Unless, of course, you understand by "life" the things you did as a freshman in college - but there's more to life than that. >>> married people with these kinds of obligations have no political power Married people with obligations have vast political power in any democratic society. That's why we have mortgage interest tax deductions and healthcare tax deductions - try to mess with those and your political ass would be kicked out faster than you can say "my words were taken out of context". >>> if you run a perpetual balance on a card If you do it, you constantly make irresponsible behavioral choices. That's the point - it's all about behavior. The chasm doesn't widen by itself - it's because you keep digging!