4 ms·
It's fascinating that so many of them are ex-KGB. These guys would have been painstakingly vetted for their impeccable ideological purity before being recruited
by gaius 13y ago
It's fascinating that so many of them are ex-KGB. These guys would have been painstakingly vetted for their impeccable ideological purity before being recruited in the first place, let alone promoted. These were the ultimate guardians of the Communist system, and they turned hyper-capitalist overnight. I guess it's like we see in the West when holier-than-thou politicians are enmeshed in a corruption scandal but like everything Russian, executed on a grand scale. Have you seen the size of their novels?!
- delinka 13y ago"... vetted for their impeccable ideological purity ..." Rather, vetted for their impeccable ability to wax lyrical about "ideological purity." I'd suggest that these guys are personalities that learn how to survive in the current climate regardless what that climate happens to be.
- auctiontheory 13y agoI'd suggest that these guys are personalities that learn how to survive in the current climate regardless what that climate happens to be. Well said. And that's a great skill to have. (I often wish I had more of it.)
- znowi 13y ago> survive in the current climate It helps when the president is your fellow KGB pal :) Proper affiliation and loyalty is all you need. It's common folk that really have to survive.
- ecdavis 13y agoThere was a lot of tension between the KGB and the senior party officials in the USSR. In fact, in an interview I watched recently a KGB defector described them as "hating" each other. It's not necessarily true that all KGB operatives would have been die-hard communists, particularly members of Putin's generation - i.e. those that were born and grew up in the USSR rather than actively participating in revolution.
- Someone 13y agoI think they were less vetted for their impeccable ideological purity than filtered out on basis of their ambition and utter pragmatism ("If that is what it takes to become part of the establishment, so be it")
- vidarh 13y agoThe prominent communists in the Soviet party had largely been murdered after the Moscow processes, left the country, or been exiled to Siberia, by the mid '30's. To the extent there were any communists left in the party by then, it was people who were too afraid or too weak to stand up to the regime. To the extent the KGB were selected for ideological purity, they were initially selected for adherence to the ideals of a Stalinist party machine that was mostly concerned with the protection of privilege. It's totally unsurprising that they "turned hypercapitalist overnight" - you had a group that was built on accepting that using pretty much any means necessary to maintain power and privilege was perfectly ok.
- mseebach 13y agoEnriching yourself on stolen goods - even when you've enlisted state power to legalise the stealing - isn't very accurately described as capitalism, hyper or otherwise. Being super-rich in Russia is all about receiving privileges from the regime in exchange for loyalty. Ceasing your loyalty has consequences: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mikhail_Khodorkovsky http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mikhail_Khodorkovsky http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boris_Berezovsky_(businessman) http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Boris_Berezovsky_(businessman)
- rdtsc 13y agoThere is interesting book called "Spy Handler: Memoir of a KGB Officer" written by this guy: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victor_Cherkashin http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Victor_Cherkashin He talks how KGB agents after the fall of the Soviet Union were in the best position to get into high power positions, plunder and pillage the best stuff available. They went from supposed devout communists to the most ruthless capitalists. They (KGB agents) were really a different class of people. They had knowledge and understand of all the details, they were also selected to be the smartest, then trained on top of it.
- varjag 13y agoThey weren't selected from the smartest, that's a myth. Sure they didn't recruit imbeciles, but any average man with determination and a penchant for servitude could become a KGB officer.
- rdtsc 13y agoI guess you are right. It seems they were selected based on family ties. I.e. those whose fathers were in the party or worked in the secret police or high ranking army officials. At some point Cherkashin kind of mentions how he was fairly average and he was sent to the foreign language training academy and how it was at first very hard for him to pick up languages. But they just had very good teachers and eventually he mastered them. So I guess I should correct it and say they picked what where thought to be "loyal" and "patriotic" people and then they trained them well. So if some got smarter it was often as a result of having to work with the best teachers.
- democracy 13y agoThis is not entirely true. The majority of oligarchs are either related to ex-top soviet officials or some black market thugs who got freedom in post-collapse chaos. My grandfather was a KGB colonel, in 90s he lost all his savings because of crazy inflation. I cant recall any of his friends i knew who became rich, most of them retired or had to leave and are getting miserable government pension and a letter of appreciation for good service once a year. As I said the oligarchs are ex gov officials sons or cousins and thugs who spent time in soviet jail for black market trade. Hey, even ukrainian president did a few years in jail for stealing some merchandise, what would you expect.
- adventured 13y agoThey turned the opposite of Capitalist. Cronyism via leveraging the state via force to plunder assets is not Capitalism.
- gaius 13y agoCapitalist in the Marxist sense, as in, private ownership of the means of production.
- tsotha 13y ago>It's fascinating that so many of them are ex-KGB. It's not that surprising, really. Positions in the KGB were highly prized, and the organization only took people with high intelligence and demonstrated competence. They really were the best and the brightest the USSR had to offer.
- znowi 13y ago> painstakingly vetted for their impeccable ideological purity You watch too many Hollywood spy movies :) > turned hyper-capitalist overnight What happened in the 90s had little to do with capitalism, though some may argue it did :) It was mass theft of state property (with a fair amount of murder) out in the open among chaos and disarray. First, there was the gang of "liberals", who heroically put an end to the Soviets and stole what they could on the ruins of the collapsed Empire. Then in 00s with Putin came the KGB gang, who took away the loot from the "liberals" and put private sector under control. They recently ousted the opposing military gang in a big embezzlement scandal. They're the ruling elite at the moment.