4 ms·
And this is why competition and effective government regulation[1] are fantastic things. If T-Mobile wasn't in a distant fourth place in the US market, or if th
by aaronbrethorst 13y ago
And this is why competition and effective government regulation[1] are fantastic things. If T-Mobile wasn't in a distant fourth place in the US market, or if they'd been acquired by AT&T we wouldn't be seeing this, nor would we see Verizon and AT&T introduce their own versions of T-Mobile's JUMP program.
[1] http://techcrunch.com/2011/12/19/att-tmobile-merger-dead/ http://techcrunch.com/2011/12/19/att-tmobile-merger-dead/
- eurleif 13y ago>If T-Mobile wasn't in a distant fourth place in the US market, or if they'd been acquired by AT&T we wouldn't be seeing this, nor would we see Verizon and AT&T introduce their own versions of T-Mobile's JUMP program. I'm not an economist, and I haven't looked into the details of the cell phone market in depth, but here's a possible alternative opinion. I'm not asserting that this is the case; just wondering if it might be. Would T-Mobile be able to treat customers as well if they were more popular, or are they only in this position because their ratio of customers to cell towers, spectrum, and other capital is lower? And if the latter is true, isn't that an inefficient use of resources, which market forces (i.e. the merger) would have corrected if not for government intervention?
- aaronbrethorst 13y agoOstensibly, VZW and AT&T enjoy certain economies of scale above and beyond T-Mobile given their significantly greater customer bases. T-Mobile has a perception of shitty service, which means they have to spend a metric shit-ton of money buying spectrum and building out their LTE network. Take a look at T-Mobile's their most recent 10-Q filing. Their EPS is actually negative: http://edgar.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1283699/000128369913000115/tmus06302013form10q.htm http://edgar.sec.gov/Archives/edgar/data/1283699/00012836991...
- tanzam75 13y agoDo note that T-Mobile USA paid $225 million in "Interest expense to affiliates." The affiliate, in this case, is Deutsche Telekom, which owns T-Mobile. If this had been structured as preferred equity rather than debt, then it would turn into dividends and move "below the line" on the income statement. T-Mobile USA would then magically be making a profit. And of course, you're just looking at one quarter: Q2 2013. Q1 2013 was profitable. Q1 + Q2 was also profitable. T-Mobile USA is not out of the woods yet. But they're in better shape than they were in 2011.
- aaronbrethorst 13y agoInteresting, I missed that. Good catch, thanks for the context!
- trimbo 13y agoIt also didn't hurt that AT&T paid T-Mobile $3 billion in a breakup fee. They're spending it wisely, at least. [1] - http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2012/02/t-mobile-takes-3-billion-att-breakup-fee-builds-4g-lte-network/ http://arstechnica.com/gadgets/2012/02/t-mobile-takes-3-bill...
- r00fus 13y agoSounds like that failed takeover bid was the 2nd best thing that AT&T did for US mobile customers in recent history (the iPhone deal with their Cingular subsidiary being the most impactful).
- tadfisher 13y agoAT&T Wireless is literally Cingular, rebranded (announced at the iPhone keynote, no less).
- ErsatzVerkehr 13y agohttp://www.marco.org/media/2007/07/20070720-05-giant-flowchart-showing-at-t-their-monopoly-1.jpg http://www.marco.org/media/2007/07/20070720-05-giant-flowcha...
- adventured 13y agoWould kind of like to see Softbank merge up Sprint and T-Mobile US (if it could be purchased), to give them even greater scale to put serious competitive pressure on AT&T / VZ. Softbank is good at attacking entrenched markets, the more market leverage they have the better.
- aaronbrethorst 13y agoThat could be a short term challenge since Sprint is all CDMA and T-Mo is all GSM. Wouldn't have any short term benefits, but the long term could be big.
- csmatt 13y agoI was going to disagree due to the Tmobile-MetroPCS merger, but it looks like Tmobile was just looking to pick up the spectrum and are phasing out CDMA within it. http://bgr.com/2013/06/17/t-mobile-metropcs-merger-cdma-migration/ http://bgr.com/2013/06/17/t-mobile-metropcs-merger-cdma-migr...
- praxeologist 13y agoIf the gov't didn't have its hand in this space for so long, there would be no massive AT&T and there would be way more innovation. You're cheering someone for applying a cast when they also broke the leg.
- masklinn 13y ago> If the gov't didn't have its hand in this space for so long, there would be no massive AT&T I didn't expect to see revisionism in here, let alone of such magnitude. Without government intervention, there would be no AT&T, nor would there be alternate carriers. There would only be Ma Bell. And don't bullshitting about Ma Bell's regulated monopoly, the regulation was put in place because Bell was already a monopoly by the time 1934 rolled around.
- icebraining 13y agoThe regulated monopoly started much earlier, in 1876, when they received a State-issued monopoly (patent) on the use of the telephone.
- praxeologist 13y agoHow about no Ma Bell in the first place... Grampa Graham got his telephone patent in 1876 then in the next 18 years there were 600 lawsuits to defend over 900 patents (state grants of monopoly). When these patents expired, there were soon 80 competing companies which captured 5% of the market, rising to over 3,000 companies with over 50% of the market by 1900. AT&T then lobbied for its monopoly status back, saying the telephone "by the nature of its technology would operate most efficiently as a monopoly providing universal service." Then during WW1, this monopoly was given "for reasons of national security". If you think that the monopoly came about by market forces then government came to save us, yes there is some revision needed.
- masklinn 13y agoGreat, more revisionism. > When these patents expired, there were soon 80 competing companies which captured 5% of the market, rising to over 3,000 companies with over 50% of the market by 1900. And starting in 1907 and the return of Vail, Bell started massively buying them out, attracting the attention of the Justice Department and leading to the Kingsbury Commitment. Kingsbury was essentially repealed 8 years later by the Willis Graham Act, which more or less removed the Commitment's regulatory barriers for acquisition by AT&T, by shifting all oversight to the ICC's rubber-stamping. > Then during WW1, this monopoly was given "for reasons of national security". If you think that the monopoly came about by market forces then government came to save us, yes there is some revision needed. The monopoly was already there, Bell was temporarily nationalized during WW1. > AT&T then lobbied for its monopoly status back, saying the telephone "by the nature of its technology would operate most efficiently as a monopoly providing universal service." And this was given in 1921 by the Willis-Graham, which removed the regulatory hurdles put in place in 1913 when Bell was already a monopoly or near-monopoly.
- skrause 13y agoThis is not really a prime example of good competition. The only reason T-Mobile can do this is because they are basically getting a massive subsidization from the German mother company, the German Telecom, who is behaving in its German home market just like AT&T behaves in the USA. As soon as T-Mobile gains any significant market share it will be just like the others.
- scalenemuscles 13y agoSo how exactly does getting subsidized by a mother company to offer a compelling package not equal good competition?
- gcb0 13y agothink of this as microsoft and sony taking a hit for every console they sell. It's anti-competitive because other console manufacturers can't do that. in the end, you end up with a result like in politics. Whoever has more money wins the whole market. The market pretty much exchanged short term benefits (cheaper console, better phone plans) for worse longer term problems (lame games because you have no choice, more expensive phone plans because you have no choice)
- irishcoffee 13y agoAh, it was always my understanding that Microsoft and Sony did take a hit selling their console, and made the money back in things like controllers and games. Do they make a profit on the console itself now?
- narenl 13y agoThe U.S consumer benefits regardless. if the German taxpayer or German customer of a monopoly subsidizes the U.S consumer that is a German market issue. Your second point has some merit though: that once they gain significant market share in the U.S, T-mobile can become anti-customer. But T-mobile's prepaid plans and now this international texting gambit might force other carriers to follow suit before T-mobile gets to that significant market share. At that point T-mobile cannot afford to become anti-customer because other carriers would have started matching T-mobile's pro-customer offers in the meantime.