5 ms·
> "I don't know where that leaves you, but you're still deceased as far as the law is concerned," Davis said. When even a Judge recognizes that common sense sh
by grecy 13y ago
> "I don't know where that leaves you, but you're still deceased as far as the law is concerned," Davis said.
When even a Judge recognizes that common sense should prevail, but isn't willing to do anything about it, courts start to be pretty useless.
- tikhonj 13y agoIs it common sense though? After all, the limit's been put in for a reason. A good solution could be to create a new legal identity for the person in question rather than trying to undo the death ruling. This could also be used to account for the Social Security benefits already paid out and such. After all, this is not a matter of life and death. It's a question entirely of bureaucracy. So "common sense" isn't applicable: the real question is not "is this guy dead" (he isn't, obviously) but "how to rectify this fact with existing systems".
- marcosdumay 13y agoI'm a bit sorry for the wording, but WTF! He is alive. Recognize that. Will he (or his family) go broke because of some law that shouldn't apply? Then make him exempt. Will he go broke because of some law that should apply? Then lead him to a bankrupcy court. Anyway, he's alive, and he's still himself.
- protomyth 13y agoI get the feeling that it has more to do with protecting Robin Miller from having to pay back the SS benefits received because of Donald's being declared dead. I really don't think the article has the whole story. I believe in logic first, but it looks like a judge trying not to punish the innocent.
- nknighthb 13y agoYokel judges don't get to control the actions of the Social Security Administration. There is absolutely no hope that this ruling would have any effect on federal benefits.
- protomyth 13y agoWell, it's a might bit hard for the SSA to collect if the guy is not alive. You would be surprised how a local judge can muck with a federal agency.
- nknighthb 13y agoThe man is alive. Federal law and federal courts do not care if state law decides to ignore the patently obvious. They are not bound by state law.
- protomyth 13y agoNope, he is still legally dead. Logic outside the law has little effect on logic inside the law. Unless the SSA decides to challenge the ruling (doubtful) or he wins an appeal or other avenue, he is dead. "They are not bound by state law" That's not really true, the US Constitution has a different interpretation, the state still has rights and areas of responsibility.
- nknighthb 13y agoOhio, for the moment, thinks he is dead. Absolutely no one outside of Ohio is required to recognize this absurdity. And specifically as to federal law, the US Constitution is crystal clear on this matter: "This Constitution, and the Laws of the United States which shall be made in Pursuance thereof; and all Treaties made, or which shall be made, under the Authority of the United States, shall be the supreme Law of the Land; and the Judges in every State shall be bound thereby, any Thing in the Constitution or Laws of any State to the Contrary notwithstanding." Go get the Social Security Act -- a federal law -- declared beyond the powers of the federal government (not going to happen), and you'll have a coherent argument. Until then, you're just speaking nonsense. And before you tiresomely drag out the full faith and credit clause, try looking it up and actually reading about it.
- anigbrowl 13y ago
- kcorbitt 13y agoIn his defense, it isn't the judge's primary responsibility to change law, it's the legislature's.
- javajosh 13y agoI was prepared to think that before reading the article. However, after reading it, I understand: Reversing the man's death status will hurt innocent people badly. In particular, it would force his abandoned wife and children to pay back the Social Security benefits they claimed after he disappeared. The real problem is with the Social Security Administration rules. They should not force the woman and her children to give back the money. I suppose the ideal situation is that the man is dead as far as the SSA is concerned. Honestly, I am totally unsympathetic with this man. He abandoned his family. He abandoned them and was dead to them. He should have just stayed dead. No driver's license? Tough shit, asshole.
- peterkelly 13y agoYes... but he's actually, you know, alive
- mcv 13y agoIt might be better for him to really start over from scratch. If he's alive, then doesn't he also have to pay his debts and his child support again?
- pekk 13y agoI don't see how you are blaming the government for this. Why not just give out the same social security benefit any old time to anyone who asks? That's what you're going to do when you formalize this as a loophole for getting benefits. When someone is discovered alive, obviously that should automatically reverse their 'death status' - not to mention that they do not forfeit rights as a citizen because they were thought dead. Instead of even thinking about the legal issues you are making this about your own emotional reaction to what a bad man he is and how bad the government supposedly is.
- aquark 13y agoI don't think I'd characterize it as a loophole per se, since it requires being legally declared dead in the first place. That is a pretty big hurdle to have to jump through!
- anigbrowl 13y agoThe legislature is the appropriate place to address thort of problem, and micro-fixes for corner cases like these pass through legislatures all the time, usually without signficant opposition because they are pragmatic rather than ideological problems. The judge is not in a position to write new laws, all he can do is invalidate some part of the existing law, which would throw the baby out with the bathwater. I'm betting you're the kind of person that gets really annoyed about 'activist judges' when a judge does act in a way that you disagree with.