5 ms·
The ITER project's lifetime cost is currently less then the California rail system or a British rail extension. When people start talking about cost, let's put
by XorNot 13y ago
The ITER project's lifetime cost is currently less then the California rail system or a British rail extension.
When people start talking about cost, let's put those numbers in perspective.
The AIG bailout alone would've bought 6-7 ITERs.
- tezza 13y ago> AIG bailout alone would've bought 6-7 ITERs. I agree with your other points. But the AIG bailout not only saved filthy rich bankers, but saved the entire world economy. Private pensions would have been wiped out, who own 95% of the stockmarket. The pensions were chasing gains and were quite happy while the returns were fat. The government cannot afford its own pension promises anyway and would have been wiped out. Big science projects are paid in installments over many years. If the financial system collapses, for sure the big projects will be mothballed immediately.
- XorNot 13y agoThe point is that governments have this type of money. In spades. Pretending we're not properly prioritizing one type of research or another is a farce - if you can convince anyone to invest in nuclear fission reactors, whether they do that won't really be affected by how much fusion research is happening. That's not why we don't have nuclear fission right now, but shutting down nuclear fusion might just ensure we never get either.
- tezza 13y agoThe government guaranteed AIG's losses. They opened themselves up to earth shaking liabilities. But very little was actually required in the end ( their hope / educated guess at the time it was entered into ). If the losses had been spectacular, the situation would have been desparate and the US would've had to take further evasive action. This is a far cry from stumping up that amount of actual cash required for research.
- dekhn 13y agoYou think governments have this type of money in spades? The US does not. We're in a major debt crises and have issues funding our fundamental operations; beyond the immediate government funding, we have severe problems with spending (IE, we can't pay the interest on our spending with our tax revenues).
- XorNot 13y agoYou're not in a debt crisis, US interest payments on existing debt is about 4% - at most - of the national budget, and your government is shutdown because of a procedural issue. I strongly suggest you actually lookup the budget figures.
- dekhn 13y agoI'm familiar with our economy. We're in a debt crises. I didn't mention the government shutdown at all.
- XorNot 13y ago"immediate government funding issues". Seems pretty immediate to me.
- dekhn 13y agoAre you really this pedantic? I used an 'and' and a 'semicolon'. If you parse my sentence you will see I made no such implication directly that the current issue with the House of Immature Children is the cause of, or effect of, our debt crisis. Anyway, do you disagree with Wikipedia? """"Debt crisis is the general term for a proliferation of massive public debt relative to tax revenues, especially in reference to Latin American countries during the 1980s, and the United States and the European Union since the mid-2000s.[1][2][3][4]""" "We're in a major debt crises and have issues funding our fundamental operations; beyond the immediate government funding, we have severe problems with spending "
- 13y ago
- dekhn 13y agoactually, big projects often have to be maintained because otherwise, huge numbers of highly paid scientists are let go. It's easier to shut down short-term, small-employee projects (like annually funded grants).
- dekhn 13y agoyes. I think the california rail system is also an overpriced underperforming system. It will never be finished (it will never make it all the way to SF), so it will never be completely useful, and the history of all large projects like this show huge cost overruns. Do you really want to allocate capital like that for something that's unlikely to be finished, nor likely to achieve its actual goal? When we could spend money to make cars more efficient (electric batteries with central generation) and reduce our total energy consumption, fairly cheaply?