4 ms·
This might be as bad as the time Bush was reelected and all the scientists moved to Canada! Or when all those hardworking small business owners fled the country
by yummyfajitas 13y ago
This might be as bad as the time Bush was reelected and all the scientists moved to Canada! Or when all those hardworking small business owners fled the country after Obama's election - we still haven't recovered from that one.
In all seriousness, the title should be fixed. Scientists telling a survey they might leave != scientists leaving.
Incidentally, here is data on science funding over time. For anyone wanting to make political points (which appears to be everyone else commenting so far), the data probably doesn't map onto your narrative all that well.
http://www.aaas.org/spp/rd/fy2013/hist13pDefNon.pdf http://www.aaas.org/spp/rd/fy2013/hist13pDefNon.pdf
http://www.aaas.org/spp/rd/fy2013/hist13pAgcyRes.pdf http://www.aaas.org/spp/rd/fy2013/hist13pAgcyRes.pdf
- spoiledtechie 13y agoSources for the first two accusations?
- ankushnarula 13y ago/sarcasm
- ankushnarula 13y agoI think that the headline of the article might be link bait but there are much more salient points made within the text.
- timr 13y ago"For anyone wanting to make political points (which appears to be everyone else commenting so far), the data probably doesn't map onto your narrative all that well." Right. Because it's not like you're trying to make a (conservative) political point every time I see one of your comments. The problem with the data you've cited is that it actually shows the problem you're dismissing: science funding has declined in real terms (let alone inflation-adjusted terms) since the end of the Clinton administration. There's been a huge bloodletting -- across the board -- over the last 13 years. An entire generation of US scientists has been decimated by pointless budget cuts. If you don't know anything at all about science, you might look at the overall trend of this graph and say: "science funding has gone up since 1976, so shut up and stop whining". This is the simpleton's interpretation of the graph. A more nuanced interpretation is that we invested billions of dollars into training of new scientists starting in the Clinton administration (~1996), and right about the time those new scientists hit the point in their careers when they needed funding to really get their labs started (~2000), we stranded them. There's an entire generation of scientists with structural under-employment because of this phenomenon, and yes, they're leaving the country (I personally know a few who have, and I can't fault their reasoning. You go where you can work. If I were still doing science, I'd probably be gone, too.) But that's not even the most important story. An intelligent observer looks at this graph and says: the US budget for 2013 is $3.8 TRILLION. We spend $600 BILLION on the department of defense, and nearly $900 BILLION on Social Security (aka: old people who contribute almost nothing to the growth of the economy). Yet we're trying to "save money" by shaving a few tens of billions (that's 0.8% of total federal spending, in case you're bad at math) off of the one tiny part of our government that has consistently delivered outsized real returns to the economy. Any economist -- conservative or liberal -- will tell you that you don't make your budget by nibbling at the smallest line items while ignoring big expenses. This is what we call "cutting off your nose to spite your face". Stupid, pointless, and definitely not conservative.
- yequalsx 13y agoYour response is excellent. I do however have one nitpick. Social Security is not a budget expense. I know it's listed as one but it shouldn't be. Social Security is an actuarially sound self-funded pension system. There is a slight under funding right now however its payments are not budgetary items.
- timr 13y agoA fair point. I just went to the FY2013 federal budget numbers, but didn't think about the fact that social security has a rather large tax of its own, and is therefore (mostly) "funded". That said, every dollar we spend is a dollar that we could be spending on something else, so I think it's still fair to consider the expense of social security relative to other things we buy. We obviously can't abandon old people, but if someone said to me "we should find a way to cut social security by 0.8% to restore science funding", I'd be inclined to think it was a good idea, all other things being equal. I'm definitely not a doctrinaire liberal -- I think we should have a social safety net (including things like single-payer health insurance), but I think we have plenty of other places we can look to balance the books before we start cutting into science and technology.
- yummyfajitas 13y agoThe data is adjusted for inflation - that's what "in billions of constant FY 2012 dollars" means. Funding rose about 50% in the early 2000's and leveled off after that. The only bloodletting has been recent - 2010-2012 or 2011-2013 (the xticks on the graph confuse me). I'm not sure what political point you think I'm trying to make. As for spending on science relative to wealth transfers, I agree with you. I'm not sure why you wish to imply I don't.
- timr 13y ago"The data is adjusted for inflation" Yes, that's why I said "in real terms". The situation is worse in inflated dollars -- even if we'd held the budgets steady in real dollars, we'd be losing to inflation. "Funding rose about 50% in the early 2000's and leveled off after that." Non-defense R&D climbed from 1996-2003, then declined. Defense R&D increased from 2001-2003 (thanks mainly to 9/11), held steady for most of the decade, and began to decline in 2010. Defense R&D is not spending on "science" by any conventional definition (most of that money goes to the defense industry), but it does employ some scientists, so we count it. "I'm not sure what political point you think I'm trying to make." You were arguing that the data doesn't support the thesis of the story, and implied that those who supported the thesis were making "political points" (at the time of your comment, almost all of the other comments were in support of the thesis).
- anigbrowl 13y agoThe main thing that jumps out at me from this graph is that (irrelevantly) that we've tripled NIH spending in real terms over the last 25 years but have seen relatively small gains in life expectancy and things like infant mortality have largely stayed static, suggesting we're into an era of diminishing returns :-/ As for scientists leaving the country, I half-agree with you. It's not a sudden crisis in the US, but has more to do with the improving and more competitive economies of other nations, which in turn makes them more attractive places for scientists to work. In the past, you could assume that people would come to the US because it was the best place for academic freedom and to have a financially rewarding science career. Now that there is more competition, we should probably be looking for ways to maintain that status rather than resting on the assumption that we're #1.