4 ms·
Some reviewers do (voluntarily) do that[1]. I would seriously consider doing so once I'm tenured (i.e. when I feel I am immune to blowback). I would hope that
by arjunnarayan 13y ago
Some reviewers do (voluntarily) do that[1]. I would seriously consider doing so once I'm tenured (i.e. when I feel I am immune to blowback).
I would hope that those cursory reviewers resulted in feedback from the other PC members that fix the issue (either through improved future reviews, or not being invited back to be on the PC.)
[1]: http://se.ethz.ch/~meyer/publications/online/whysign/ http://se.ethz.ch/~meyer/publications/online/whysign/
- scott_s 13y agoI've heard of others who do that, too. The difficulty is that those who self-select to sign their own name are probably not part of the problem.
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoI sign my reviews unless I'm involved in some sort of post paper evaluation. It seems only fair since the reviews aren't double blind (given double blind, I would not sign). I also publish reviews on my own papers as a matter of interesting record.