8 ms·
Prediction Markets
- normloman 13y agoSince your not really investing in anything, prediction markets are like gambling. You might as well bet on sports games. As for their utility, the predictions are about as accurate as any other prediction, which is usually completely worthless. Might work ok for the boring stuff, but show me evidence that prediction markets can forecast the next 9/11, the next iPhone, or the next Arab Spring.
- benmanns 13y agoIf there is a better method for prediction, and a prediction market exists, you can arbitrage the difference to make money and bring accuracy to the market.
- LanceH 13y agoThis is the essence of prediction markets. Prediction markets pay for information to become public (if not the source).
- joosters 13y agoBut you are investing with something, namely your own money, and it is this that gives the prediction markets value. Anyone can shout out their silly predictions, but if they have to back them up with cash, then the predictions tend to get better. The article has a quote that sums it up well: "The usual touchstone of whether what someone asserts is mere persuasion or at least a subjective conviction, i.e., firm belief, is betting. Often someone pronounces his propositions with such confident and inflexible defiance that he seems to have entirely laid aside all concern for error. A bet disconcerts him. Sometimes he reveals that he is persuaded enough for one ducat but not for ten. For he would happily bet one, but at 10 he suddenly becomes aware of what he had not previously noticed, namely that it is quite possible that he has erred."
- pdonis 13y agothe predictions tend to get better Only if there is some actual predictive skill out there to begin with. For example, the article gives the example of a prediction market on coin flips: the winning strategy is to take any bet for less than $1 (assuming that the payoff on a successful prediction is $2). But in short order, everyone who does not play that strategy will go bankrupt, and then there will be no more betting, because everyone remaining in the market will only take a bet at less than $1, but nobody will be willing to offer one. In other words, if there is an obvious limit to how well something can be predicted, the market will reach that point and then stop--no further betting will happen.
- joosters 13y agoNot true at all! A golden example is Betfair's 'exchange games' markets, where they let players bet on fair, computer-managed card games. The markets are always exactly prcied-up. Some punters are playing, but even without the 'mugs' you can just look at the order book to see the predictions. For the coin flip, you'd still have people asking for odds of 50.1% and others offering odds of 49.9% - you then can just look at the spread to discover the market prediction.
- pdonis 13y agoThe markets are always exactly prcied-up. Isn't this in agreement with what I said? I didn't say that the market prices would not reflect the expected predictions. I said that once that happens the market will stop moving, which appears to be exactly what you're saying: you can just look at the order book to see the predictions. In other words, there is a limit to how accurately people can predict the outcomes of these card games, and that limited predictive accuracy is what the market reflects. The real question is, how much betting volume is there for a given, fixed card game, once all the players in the market learn the odds? My expectation is that volume will decrease over time for a given, fixed card game, because if the game is fair, the betting is zero-sum, so players who know the optimal strategy will never bet among themselves (since you can't make money on average at zero-sum bets), and players who don't know the optimal strategy will go bankrupt. Obviously if you introduce a new card game, the above doesn't apply; that would be the equivalent of adding, say, six-sided dice to the coin flip betting site: now there's a new set of odds to be learned, so there will be a new period of trading as market players learn the optimal strategy for this new game. For the coin flip, you'd still have people asking for odds of 50.1% and others offering odds of 49.9% Would any actual bets happen at these odds? What makes you think so? An occasional new player might try this, but he would end up losing money, and all the long-term players know that would happen, so they won't try it. Why would they? Or do you just mean that people would be posting these asks/offers, but nobody would be accepting them? If so, then, once again, this is in agreement with what I was saying; no actual activity would be taking place in the market, but the asks/offers would accurately reflect the market's best available prediction--which is the best possible prediction, hence no money can be made in the market because trades are zero-sum.
- hannibal5 13y agoNirvana fallacy. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nirvana_fallacy
- normloman 13y agoI realize there's not a perfect solution. But in this case, the imperfect solution isn't even helpful. The events they can predict reliably are things already obvious to most people. And the events they can't predict are usually the ones that carry the most impact. What's worse, they give us a false sense of security, letting our guard down because we think we have the answers. There is a better solution: Accept that most people don't know anything, and reasonably prepare for any disaster looming in the future.
- gwern 13y ago> As for their utility, the predictions are about as accurate as any other prediction, which is usually completely worthless. Might work ok for the boring stuff, but show me evidence that prediction markets can forecast the next 9/11, the next iPhone, or the next Arab Spring. See the IARPA geopolitical prediction contest, on exactly that sort of topic. I am an active participant in the GJP prediction market ( http://www.gwern.net/Prediction%20markets#iarpa-the-good-judgment-project http://www.gwern.net/Prediction%20markets#iarpa-the-good-jud... ). The contest is not yet over, but there's already clear rankings of skill (contrary to what you say,most people cannot predict worth a damn) and IIRC, IARPA has said that the aggregate predictions from GJP & DAGGRE (more prediction markets) are better than its existing experts.
- tunesmith 13y agoWell, part of the point is that by predicting, you get better at predicting! And the utility there is getting better at recognizing biases and being a more rational human being, which pays dividends in all sorts of aspects of life.
- Permit 13y agoI'd never really heard of prediction markets before this post. Does anyone know the reason prediction markets are legal but other forms of online gambling such as poker are not? Edit: Apparently they've just recently started using real money at some prediction markets: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prediction_market#Legality http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Prediction_market#Legality
- spindritf 13y agoIt's a big idea of Overcoming Bias'[1] Robin Hanson[2] along with a proposed governing method based on it called the futarchy[3]. [1] http://www.overcomingbias.com/tag/prediction-markets http://www.overcomingbias.com/tag/prediction-markets (easily one of top 5 blogs on the Internet) [2] http://hanson.gmu.edu/ideafutures.html http://hanson.gmu.edu/ideafutures.html [3] http://hanson.gmu.edu/futarchy.html http://hanson.gmu.edu/futarchy.html
- pdonis 13y agoThere's a big difference between a prediction market and a decision market, which is what futarchy is. Mencius Moldbug expounded on this quite a while back in this post: http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2010/02/pipe-shorting-and-professor-hansons.html http://unqualified-reservations.blogspot.com/2010/02/pipe-sh... I won't go into much detail (the post is worth reading), but his basic point (which I agree with) is that the reason a prediction market works (when it works) is that the only incentive governing people's bets is their beliefs about the expected probabilities of outcomes. But this can only work if the bets people make are themselves statistically independent of the outcomes, and in a decision market they obviously can't be, since people's bets determine the outcome. (In the post Moldbug gives an actual real-world example of a market which gets manipulated in exactly this way.)
- arethuza 13y ago"other forms of online gambling such as poker are not" That, of course, depends where you are - in some countries online gambling is completely legal.
- jws 13y ago
- spindritf 13y agoConsidering that I upvote pretty much every gwern.net article I see (the guy rarely disappoints) and that there's probably a fairly cohesive Overcoming Bias/Less Wrong demographic doing the same, how long will it take before we're banned as a voting ring? (Anyone selling futures for that?)
- presidentender 13y agoIf I'm right about the HN readership, gwern.net articles are going to receive upvotes from a much larger population than just the intersection of HN and LessWrong. Furthermore, if there is cohesion with respect to gwern's stuff, then that cohesion would either disappear when it comes to other submitters (if it's simply tribal allegiance) or we'd see it with other articles of interest (if it's based on shared interests). If the cohesion disappears with other submitters, then any voting ring detection would have to be overly sensitive to pick up on your love of gwern. We'd hear about a lot of false positives. If the cohesion is strong enough to warrant mention and it persists across other domains, then you'd probably see some trouble even without gwern.net submissions.
- sker 13y agoIf daringfireball upvoters never got banned, I doubt you have anything to worry about.
- chm 13y agoDo you actually click on the link? Do you read some of the text, even if it's just a couple of paragraphs? Then I don't see a problem. If you just upvote without bothering to learn what the article is about, then I think it beats the point of the voting mechanism. Otherwise, there should be no problem, no?
- jedc 13y agoThere was a prediction markets company that YC funded in its second-ever batch: Inkling Markets. (http://inklingmarkets.com http://inklingmarkets.com) It's still going, from what I understand through enterprise sales. Also, for those of you that haven't heard Intrade is shut down and going through some complicated legal proceedings. Their former founder/CEO died climbing Mount Everest a couple of years ago, and I don't think the company ever fully recovered. (I used to do a lot of work in prediction markets.)
- joosters 13y agoNot just that, their financial situation suddenly became 'murky' and they shut up shop without letting customers withdraw their balances. As I understand, it is still unclear whether or not they have the cash to pay back everyone yet.
- gwern 13y agoThey don't, but judging from their messages on their homepage, they've gotten forbearance from their biggest creditors.
- laoheike 13y agonice article, but I don't use the same strategy as you describe... I was looking at prediction market recently, and tried a few free-to-play websites such as Inkling. I ended up on swissnoise (http://go.swissnoise.ch http://go.swissnoise.ch). They use virtual money for trade, but with real-money prizes which is very nice! Plus I have the feeling of helping research in this field (it's developed by some university).
- laoheike 13y agonice article, but I don't use the same strategy as you describe... I was looking at prediction market recently, and tried a few free-to-play websites such as Inkling. I ended up on swissnoise (http://go.swissnoise.ch http://go.swissnoise.ch). They use virtual money for trade, but with real-money prizes which is very nice! Plus I have the feeling of helping research in this field (it's developed by some university).
- JackFr 13y agoI predict that the sum of my cards will be closer to 21 without going over than the dealer's will.
- woodchuck64 13y agoWhat's the status of Intrade? Will it be back? (http://www.intrade.com/v4/home/latest-news/ http://www.intrade.com/v4/home/latest-news/)
- the_cat_kittles 13y agoThere were investigations of money laundering after the most recent presidential election. They ran into problems letting people from the USA make predictions. I think they are on their way out, they are basically gone already. Sad, since I loved going there!
- chimeracoder 13y agoTangential, but I took a class with one of the professors in the linked paper (Sethi). It was a great class - many of the homeworks and exam questions were based around Intrade. (We didn't trade any actual money, but it really helped to illustrate the concepts of financial economics, which can get very abstract).
- btilly 13y agoThis is a good article. However if anyone is interested in following it, they should know that when there are multiple bets available, the simple Kelly criterion falls apart. See http://www.elem.com/~btilly/kelly-criterion/ http://www.elem.com/~btilly/kelly-criterion/ for a much fuller explanation of the result, and why it is true. (I keep meaning to automatically optimize the multiple bet version of it.)
- joosters 13y agoGood link. I was writing a reply to make a couple of points but the page says it best: "Many people will tell you to bet less than the Kelly formula says to bet. Two reasons are generally given for this. The first is that gamblers tend to overestimate their odds of winning and so will naturally overbet. Betting less than the Kelly amount corrects for this. The other is that the Kelly formula leads to extreme volatility, and you should underbet to limit the chance of being badly down for unacceptably long stretches." The volatility is huge; you have a 50% chance of losing half your bank over time even if you bet correctly. Not many people can cope with those spikes in gains and losses!
- btilly 13y agoThat is why the JavaScript tools I wrote to go with the article can give you percentiles on where you would be after different numbers of trials. That's explicitly so that people can develop intuition about how much they need to underbet to stay within their comfort levels.
- jasich 13y agoHey, I've created a site for making/tracking predictions called The Red Book (http://rdbk.net/ http://rdbk.net/). It's simple, just Will/Won't votes on predictions with a little gamification added to encourage community involvement. Just thought I'd plug it here if anyone is interested.
- ptype 13y agoIf you are interested in prediction market type betting and got friends who like the same, you might like http://www.bespokebets.com http://www.bespokebets.com which lets you setup your own market easily and for free (play-money - and yes talking my book)
- hooande 13y agoThere are several fundamental problems with prediction markets: 1) Every market participant is not a savvy investor. InTrade was notorious for political bias and emotional trading (check out the comment section). The idea is that a true insider will place a large bet that provides valuable information to the market. This is rarely the case. Most of the people bet based on what they want to happen rather than what they know will happen. [1] This problem is compounded by the fact that most of the bets on intrade in particular were rather small, hundreds of dollars. People tend to speak more accurately with their wallets as opposed to their mouths, but only with significant amounts of money on the line. 2) The markets themselves are never large enough. The system doesn't work unless the people that place big bets are experts or insiders. The majority of people aren't familiar with the concept of prediction markets, much less any particular sites. One of the best cases for an information market would be someone who works on a political campaign placing a big bet for or against their candidate based on inside knowledge. But something like this can't happen until the average political staffer has heard of a prediction market site, which we are still a long way away from. 3) The best way to make money from a market is to out think the other participants. Accurately calculating prices based on the current supply and demand situation works too, but it's slower and more difficult. Instead of asking "Who do I think will be elected president?" people might themselves "Who do the other participants think will be elected president?" This leads to a functioning market but it doesn't do much for the goal of aggregating knowledge to make accurate predictions. I like the concept of prediction markets because I love the idea of utilizing collective intelligence. But I'm constantly disappointed by the implementations that I see. It's a very tricky thing to do but I think that whoever finally figures it out will have built something valuable for all of us. [1] http://go.bloomberg.com/political-capital/2012-06-29/intrade-bettors-lost-on-health-care/ http://go.bloomberg.com/political-capital/2012-06-29/intrade...
- l1ghtm4n 13y agoAll very good points. I had worked some years ago on a prediction market site which attempted to merge 3 mechanisms for gaining collective intelligence: Polling, paramutual betting, and full buy/sell market. It was motived by the fact that full blown market simulations are a steep learning curve for the non-investor, but that person has a valuable opinion nonetheless. Never did much with it.
- joelthelion 13y agoI'm still waiting for a good Bitcoin-based prediction market. I think that would be a nice application for the cryptocurrency.
- nyan_sandwich 13y agoA friend of mine is "working" on that. I can put you in touch if you want to encourage him.
- gigq 13y agoIsn't this what http://betsofbitco.in http://betsofbitco.in does?
- gwern 13y agoThey do, but extremely poorly. I criticize them in the OP: > One might wonder why I don't use the fairly active [Bets of Bitcoin](https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Bets_of_Bitcoin https://en.bitcoin.it/wiki/Bets_of_Bitcoin) prediction market; that is because the payout rules are [insane](http://betsofbitco.in/help http://betsofbitco.in/help) and I have no idea how to translate the "total weighted bets" into actual probabilities. Betting blind is never a good idea.
- joelthelion 13y agoIt's not a prediction market. It's just a badly-designed betting site.
- mapt 13y agoI saw this mentioned the other day: https://www.predictious.com/ https://www.predictious.com/
- ffrryuu 13y agoGambling.
- dimadima 13y agoThis site needs to get away from the whole 10pt Georgia thing. Not only is the content about banal evil shit, but the type also makes that banal evil shit even more unpleasant to read.
- peterjancelis 13y agoNow imagine prediction markets with the twist proposed by Jim Bell: everybody bets on a day a person will die. If that day passes or the person dies before, you lose the money to those who predicted the right day. Now who can know for sure when somebody dies? Exactly. Frankly I'm amazed something like this hasn't taken off on the deep web yet. Tor + Bitcoin should do it. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_market http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Assassination_market [2] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Bell http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Jim_Bell