6 ms·
12 crashes is not a huge sample size. Also, potholes and other road hazards are so common that if 0.1% of encounters with them causes a fire that ruins the very
by IgorPartola 13y ago
12 crashes is not a huge sample size. Also, potholes and other road hazards are so common that if 0.1% of encounters with them causes a fire that ruins the very expensive battery pack, it is an issue. Overall, yes, superior engineering prevented the problem from being worse than it was. However, there is still a problem.
- sally888 13y agoIMHO, there is a major problem with Tesla's batteries. Boeing has had issues with its lithium-ion batteries catching on fire. I wouldn't be surprised if more Teslas have the same issues in the future.
- alexholehouse 13y ago> IMHO, there is a major problem with Tesla's batteries. Is this based on any kind of information, or just supposition stemming from the problems Boeing had (where, IIRC, Tesla offered to provide engineering assistance).
- sally888 13y agoWell, the Chevy Volts' lithium ion batteries also have fire issues too. Not to mention overheated laptops with li-ion batteries that have caught on fire.
- HeyItsJames 13y agoWe're still waiting on any categorical information from you, other than your baseless fears stemming from problems with wholly different companies using similar technology.
- smileysteve 13y agoNews, Every car has batteries that are potential fire/explosion/acid explosions. I've seen a standard 12v lead acid battery evaporating/boiling hydrochloric acid out of its vent holes, I've also seen one smoking about to explode.
- madaxe 13y agoOK, add every laptop manufacturer, cellphone manufacturer, and any variety of portable device manufacturer on the planet to that list, then, as lithium ion or polymer batteries are flammable no matter what. I assume you have a suggestion as to how this could be remedied? Or, actually, looking at your comment history, I see you are also a climate change denialist. So, which oil giant do you work for, for whom you are spreading FUD?
- sally888 13y agoYes, please accuse anyone who disagrees with you as being a paid shill. Saying that the IPCC has lowered estimates, which it has admitted in its report, is now climate change skepticism? Really? http://www.mercurynews.com/business/ci_24229744/tesla-says-car-fire-began-after-object-hit http://www.mercurynews.com/business/ci_24229744/tesla-says-c... "But lithium-ion batteries have raised concerns in other vehicles. Two years ago, battery fires broke out in three Chevrolet Volt plug-in hybrid cars after crash-testing."
- Amadou 13y ago"Two years ago, battery fires broke out in three Chevrolet Volt plug-in hybrid cars after crash-testing." "After" being the operative word. They crashed the Volts for testing purposes and then left them sitting outside with a nearly full but damaged battery. THREE WEEKS LATER a fire started. When testing gasoline powered cars it is standard procedure to empty the tank immediately after crashing it, if they had drained or removed the Volts' batteries in a similar fashion nothing would have happened. https://publichd.se/index.php?page=torrents&search=&active=0&category=9;20;14 https://publichd.se/index.php?page=torrents&search=&active=0...
- jlgreco 13y ago> ""After" being the operative word. They crashed the Volts for testing purposes and then left them sitting outside with a nearly full but damaged battery. THREE WEEKS LATER a fire started." Well damn, those sound like verified deathtraps! Seriously, the fact that she had to reach back two years probably says enough. On the general note of battery safety in crashes, there have been several Tesla Roadster crashes (to be expected with that style of car) (http://www.wreckedexotics.com/tesla/ http://www.wreckedexotics.com/tesla/), how many of them resulted in dangerous battery fires? Clearly these batteries do not present a serious safety concern.
- Tloewald 13y agoYour humble opinions appear to be (a) anti L-Ion battery and (b) climate change skepticism. Is this a fair summary?
- sally888 13y agoWhat a blatant ad hominem and straw man attack. Do you like to misrepresent someone's positions because they have differing opinions from yours?
- alexholehouse 13y agoSo these are not your opinions?
- Tloewald 13y agoYou said "IMHO ..." and then asserted something with no evidence. So the only germane information is the quality of your opinions. I made no assessment of those opinions, I simply listed what I found, based on your posts, and asked for confirmation. If merely listing these things constitutes an ad hominem attack, then it says more about your opinions than it does about me.
- nilkn 13y agoLet's be fair here. "You said "IMHO ..." and then asserted something with no evidence." Why would you expect something else when someone starts their post with IMHO? > If merely listing these things constitutes an ad hominem attack, then it says more about your opinions than it does about me. Your post had an obvious tone to it.
- Tloewald 13y agoTone, obvious or otherwise, does not constitute ad hominem either.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- loceng 13y agoElon Musk mentioned the battery problems that Boeing had / has, and offered to work with them to solve the problem that they had solved themselves..
- sally888 13y agoYes, but it seems that that may have the same issues themselves. Li-ion batteries are notorious for catching on fire. Yes, the sample size is too small to make a determination on Tesla but I suspect they may run into the same issues as Boeing as they sell more cars.
- sambe 13y agoThis is why people call you 'shill'. You aren't disagreeing, just using leading speculation. These are specifically not the same issues as Boeing, whose design Musk criticised for ability to produce 'domino effect' fires that get out of control very fast. That did not happen here. Casting aspersions like 'li-ion are notorious' also stinks, much like the smell of gasoline before it (notoriously) explodes. Ignoring the facts of the particular case whilst hugely generalising about the technology isn't a good foundation of debate.
- toomuchtodo 13y agoWhat are your qualifications with regards to battery chemistry and energy management system engineering? I ask only because you said this is your opinion.
- meric 13y agoThe sample isn't 12 crashes. It is the 12 cars that crashed plus all the other cars that didn't.
- epi8 13y agoThat's... not true. The question is "how likely is there to be an electrical fire in the Tesla, given that it has crashed (or is crashing)" not "how likely is there to be an electrical fire". It's easy enough for things not to catch flame when they're being used properly; the real test is how things behave when other things are going wrong. That's not to say that this means all Tesla cars are fiery death-traps of doom. Just that the sample size really is the number of crashed cars.
- meric 13y agoFollowing your logic, we can ignore Tesla cars that catch fire without crashing, because we can assume they're not going to catch flame when they're used properly; We can assume cars that don't crash aren't going to catch fire anyway, so, even if they may happen, let's throw that data away, because we know our assumption holds true. That's ridiculous.
- IgorPartola 13y agoThat is besides the point. We are talking about what happens when your Tesla S does crash. There is on "if" in the certainty that Teslas will be involved in accidents. The questions are "will they catch fire when they crash?" and also "how bad will that fire be for persons and property involved?"
- meric 13y agoThere's also "Under what conditions when Tesla cars crash will they catch fire", and then you only look at your 12 crashes, and that's when everything goes wrong. The Space Shuttle Challenger exploded shortly after take-off in January 1986. Subsequent investigation determined that the cause was failure of the O-ring seals used to isolate the fuel supply from burning gases..... NASA staff had analysed the data on the relation between ambient temperature and number of O-ring failures (out of 6), but they had excluded observations where no O-rings failed, believing that they were uninformative. Unfortunately, those observations had occurred when the launch temperature was relatively warm (65-80 degF). http://www.datavis.ca/gallery/missed.php http://www.datavis.ca/gallery/missed.php Let's look at this question "how bad will that fire be for persons and property involved?" You look at your 12 crashes where fire occurs, so (e.g.) 6 crashes. Of 6 crashes 3 were accompanied with injuries. All 3 crashes that were accompanied by electrical fires and injuries occurred was when the car's speed was between (e.g.) 40mph and 50mph. Does that mean when the speed is not between 40mph and 50mph, people won't be injured when there's a crash and a fire? It means nothing like that but it's too easy to make a wrong conclusion; you're skipping all the other data where injuries and/or fires happen independently of crashes.