9 ms·
Mobile web design: The reign of morons, indeed
- badman_ting 13y agoYep, a major argument for Safari's "reader" feature. Of course, on these crappy websites that often doesn't work either (because they purposely structured their markup to defeat it).
- disposition2 13y agoOne of the reasons I love Pocket (Read-It Later) for pretty much every article with substance.
- arjie 13y agoI use Pocket too and I find it amusing that almost every time someone refers to it, they say "Pocket (previously Read It Later)" or some variant thereof. Does rebranding ever go fully successfully? Maybe it's just too early for Pocket. Also, the fact that they market themselves as "Pocket (Formerly Read It Later)" can't help.
- zenojevski 13y agoI think "Read it later" was too good of a brand. And because of how it is worded, it doesn't sound like a brand at all. I believe it has much less cognitive overload than "pocket". Edit: to add, I see many of the most well-remembered services tend to become verbs at one point or another. So a verb, like "read it later", will probably be more easily successful among all the noun brands which are usually favored.
- Sprint 13y agoAh, the great features Opera had for ages until they dropped everything. Safari adds them and it's all big news. Read a tech magazine recently that was so excited about this "amazing and ground-breaking new feature" that I wondered if they had ever used Opera before. With that being said, yeah, being able to apply custom stylesheets to websites easily is great!
- rmrfrmrf 13y ago> Ah, the great features Opera had for ages until they dropped everything. Safari adds them and it's all big news. Much like everything Apple does, amirite? > Read a tech magazine Sounds unlikely. > recently Safari Reader debuted in 2010... > that was so excited about this "amazing and ground-breaking new feature" I believe you. Really. > that I wondered if they had ever used Opera before. Statistically speaking, probably not. Then again, they weren't missing out on much. Unless you like your websites rendered incorrectly.
- Sprint 13y agoHush, go back to your cave.
- kyro 13y agoAnd hence, the field of marketing. There's a reason why it's so important.
- testbro 13y agoDoesn't Reader automatically infer which parts of the page to style rather than just applying a custom stylesheet?
- aaronem 13y agoFor browsers not offering anything comparable to Safari's reader mode, and also for sites whose markup it fails to recognize, I find invaluable the Squarefree "zap" bookmarklet[1], which forces black-on-white and also removes almost any sort of annoyance that gets past Adblock Plus. I don't know what moves jwz to stick with green on black (yes, very retro chic, but we have colors now! Use them!), but his content (writing, whatever) I find at least occasionally of some value; without this bookmarklet, the nearly instantaneous headache would entirely prevent me reading what he has to say. [1] https://www.squarefree.com/bookmarklets/zap.html https://www.squarefree.com/bookmarklets/zap.html
- binarymax 13y agoThe designer isn't to blame here. Its an executive decision designed to hinder use. They dont want you doing something obvious like reading content. They want you looking at all the other pages they have to offer where you also cannot read content. I've found that maybe about 10% of the time trying to scroll an article into view or pinch-zoom I accidentally trigger a click on a link or ad. More clicks! More revenue! Lets keep them struggling to find content and mine all the clicks we can!
- eksith 13y agoThis is true, unfortunately. I know quite a few designers who're absolutely appalled at some of the things they're asked to implement. Completely counter-productive and short-sighted. They really do browse their work on mobile so they know exactly what the end result will be.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoYep. Another approach is the dreaded list-type articles that are almost 100% of the content for some sites. You know, articles with names like "Top 10 Cities for Techies" or whatever. Instead of putting it all one page or even using an AJAX call to retrieve each list entry, the entries each load a new page, complete with ads, etc. A lot of these are butt slow in loading just one page, but hey, they just want those clicks. So they manage to stretch one lame article into 10 page views, complete with 10x the ad revenue and 10x the latency for the reader. On mobile, this can be even more painful.
- acqq 13y agoBeautifully said binarymax: Its an executive decision designed to hinder use. They dont want you doing something obvious like reading content. They want you looking at all the other pages they have to offer where you also cannot read content. They also think: "Wouldn't the world be nicer without these people who want to read our content over the internet." And they also think "OK the guy who followed the link has an iPad so he isn't among the cheapest bastards of all those who follow links to our glorious magazine, so let's try to make them subscribe." Anybody has any statistics that supports or disproves the above ideas?
- 13y ago
- ChikkaChiChi 13y agoI'd comment on this article on web design if I wasn't straining my eyes on that terrible website. Glass houses = unreliable source.
- canthonytucci 13y agoI had to use safari reader to get through it. This guy needs to take some of his own advice.
- technifreak 13y agoThis. Complaining about how hard it is to read someone else's website when you use an awful green text on black background is reason enough for me to not take you seriously. It's a Wordpress site, for god's sake, and that is the template you came up with (or chose)? Glass houses, indeed.
- bradleyjg 13y agoIt's a design intended to recall the look of the author's original webpage, which has been on the internet since before the word blog was coined. The man was a pivotal figure in writing the first modern web browser, it wouldn't kill you to show some goddamn respect.
- ChikkaChiChi 13y agoIf Jamie's post had been about literally almost anything else web related, I would concur.
- bmj 13y agoThere is a difference, I think, between "I find green on black to be hard on my eyes" and "I can't read the content because it is obscured by ads and popovers."
- joosters 13y agoWhat? Sure, green-on-black may not be your colours of choice, but that's a matter of taste, not of usability. It's not like a grey-on-grey low contrast choice.
- blinkingled 13y agoJwz jumped the shark long time ago. (His site only looks marginally better than Esquire's BTW and all you can read there are rants and creepy things.)
- camus 13y agoupvoted,look who's talking...
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoNow if I didn't know any better I'd say you folks are jealous, I didn't see this anywhere else: http://www.jwz.org/blog/2013/09/hoping-that-the-monsters-dont-do-what-monsters-are-always-going-to-do-because-if-they-didnt-do-those-things-theyd-be-called-dandelions-or-puppy-hugs/ http://www.jwz.org/blog/2013/09/hoping-that-the-monsters-don... Horribly entertaining, maybe you don't like that sort of thing though.
- disgruntledphd2 13y agoMy god, that is probably the best article on processor design I have ever read (though that's not saying much). You should submit that as its own article (the paper, that is).
- blinkingled 13y agoThat's really entertaining and I was indeed exaggerating about things you find on jwz's blog - sometimes he does link to interesting things but often times it is what it is ;)
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- PaulHoule 13y agoThe ads and fonts aren't so bad as you can pinch them away by zooming in. Interstitial and popups are hell on mobile
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jmduke 13y agoHere's a notion: what if we assume that the entire staff of Esquire is, at varying levels, competent at their job? So jwz's use case is that he's an inbound link from a social media site, right? So Esquire is optimizing two things here: conversion rate to the downloaded app and amount of time spent on site. The first one is obvious -- people who have the app downloaded are going to spend much more time overall and are going to be more valuable; the second one is a bit trickier, since you play a balancing act between getting users to dive deeper into the publication while making sure they don't leave altogether. In this sort of case, it's pretty reasonable to assume that someone has either the data or intuition to say "Hey, if they're visiting our site from Facebook, they have a pretty big investment in trying to read the article than someone who Googled something vaguely related to the article." (The same goes true from mobile, where audiences tend to be slower and more captive.) So, if we understand the series of decisions that led us to such an experience, we then have to ask why were those decisions made? Clearly there's a backlash against this kind of thing -- nobody says "wow, what a great banner ad!" -- but its hard to argue against the financial straits of such a publication. Esquire doesn't have the circulation they used to, and its not a non-profit; they need to make money somehow. Either way, its hardly fair to pin this on Esquire's web designer. Esquire's management, maybe -- or maybe the legions of people addicted to AdBlock, the legions of people who put a low -- and getting even lower -- value on content. Now, everything is hinging on that assumption that people are vaguely competent over at Esquire. While it's entirely possible that such an assumption is invalid, I find its a more comforting one than the opposite assumption.
- astrodust 13y agoWhatever. Esquire has a great print experience, but their web one, mobile especially, is awful. I'm sure their lead print designer gets final say for what goes to press. If their web designer is caving in to every ridiculous demand of management, that's the fault of the designer, not management. So either the lead "webmaster" has no idea what they're doing, in which case they should get a new job, or they know exactly what they're doing but are hamstrung by management, in which case they should get a new job.
- untog 13y ago
- ianstallings 13y agoI agree with a lot he said there. But I would like to comment on this: .. it launches the App Store application, presumably trying to get me to go download their custom app. Which is undoubtedly just a wrapper around a WebKit view of this exact same web site, except with more surveillance built in. Actually the app store version of that magazine uses a custom display view that parses a JSON structure that itself is created by a parsing tool for InDesign files. It's the same structure used by a few other well-known published apps and I inherited that project while I worked at a company called ScrollMotion in NYC. The content package for each magazine ends up being around 500MB to 1GB! Mainly insanely large image files. It does usually include some things like games and embedded videos. But the main reason it wasn't web-based was a requirement for offline viewing. Content is pre-cached. Just wanted to add that. It was a very early platform and we went on to create a much better one with an HTML5 content creator that could create much smaller packages, but that one is AFAIK, still a legacy app. It's now under the control of Hearst.
- pavel_lishin 13y agoSo, why does that pop-up still come up inside the app: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6484924 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6484924 ?
- ianstallings 13y agoBecause, as that post you pointed out says, he clicked a link. That will open a web browser. They can embed links in the content and the app will open a browser just like most apps. To clarify even further: We used a custom URL scheme that could signal that the content was local. Then they could also use a regular web address if they wanted.
- rocky1138 13y agoOn a PC/Mac, this is easy enough to avoid by adding crappy websites to your hosts file, pointing them to 127.0.0.1. I do this for Wired and a few others. Or, install Ghostery. Can you do either on an iPad? I'm assuming no, but I'd love to proven wrong.
- rubyn00bie 13y agoNot directly, but if you have a router that runs linux (or has an equiv. to /etc/hosts) you can filter them at the router level.
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoGhostery has a browser for iOS: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/ghostery/id472789016?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/ghostery/id472789016?mt=8
- shortformblog 13y agoThe reason why many media websites are terrible is because the ad/biz dev department sets the parameters. It's a mistake to blame the web designer for being told they have to work in those parameters.
- nish1500 13y agoChrome should really speed up the browser back button. I almost lost my eyes.
- untog 13y agoOne slight nit-pick: when he says he uses the term "writing" instead of "content" he is talking about two different things. The photo at the top of the article is very much part of the content, and is very much visible. He may not care for the photo, but others do.
- hawkharris 13y agoBy the time I reached the third paragraph, I had to stop reading because of the font colors.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- bchjam 13y agoAs much as I agree with what he said, his neon green on black blog style really isn't pleasant to read. I almost didn't finish reading it because of it (and it's pretty short). But the point stands, don't hurt your users! (even if you technically have a user/customer differentiation, the customer relationship is likely predicated on you having users)
- abbazabba 13y agoInteresting sidenote: the author invented mozilla (the name), and was a founder of netscape. It might not excuse the hypocrisy of his own blog's design, but I like the point he makes. Is this becoming a common practice? I've had my own frustrations when I double-tapped content which triggered a giant subscribe/paywall ad to cover everything in my view.
- malyk 13y agoOf course, but the time you've decided to hit the close button you've been exposed to all of the ads and esquire has gotten exactly what they want out of you. Hell, if their lucky you try to go back to the site and wait to zoom in and get to see all of the ads a second time!
- RyJones 13y agoExcept you can't scroll far enough to close it.
- Joeri 13y agoI often wish websites would abstain from doing a mobile-optimized version. The many ways of messing it up: 1. Redirecting to the mobile page after the desktop page loads, taking up to ten seconds before i can start reading the content 2. Using some clever swiping / panning mechanic that relies on javascript animation. Yeah, let's build the heaviest ui on the slowest platform, great thinking there. 3. Preventing panning side-to-side and then having content too wide for the page (got this today on arstechnica, cutting off the bars on a benchmark graphic) 4. Asking me to install an app via a popup. On a content-driven site this is never, ever, ok. No site visitor likes this, and it doesn't bring in revenue. It is indefensible. 5. Presenting less content on mobile and offering no clear path back to the full content. Dell does this, i couldn't find out hardware details of their laptops from my ipad. No details, no purchase. Ofcourse, there are cases where a little attention to mobile goes a long way. My phone operator redesigned their flash-driven website with html5 ... where the primary navigation are dropdown menus triggered by hovering and half the content doesn't load on a mobile device.
- Coincoin 13y agoThat's why I turn off mobile version in my browser.
- shawnreilly 13y agoI feel your pain, and I've experienced some of these problems myself. In my opinion, many of these problems relate to a (poor) assumption that Responsive Design = Mobile Design. So the train of thought is to fit the Old Design onto a Smaller Screen. Instead, they should be thinking about how they can re-design the UI/UX to compliment Mobile, and deliver a better Mobile Experience overall.
- Emass12 13y agoPossibly because many designers don't understand what "mobile-optimized" should mean. It often (at least for a content oriented site) doesn't have to be anything other than a resizing of some elements and content areas, easily done with a good layout design and media queries.
- pearjuice 13y agoClicking the link, something made me feel I landed on some sort of obscure hacker blog. I wonder what could have caused that!
- nathanb 13y agoSo I see two sorts of comments here: * The article is invalid because I find the author's website hard to read. This is the ad-hominem fallacy and is not at all relevant to the correctness of his point. * Don't blame the web designer, blame X What is the role of a web designer? To design (hence the name) the experience of the user on the web (again, hence the name). The experience on the Esquire mobile site is very poorly designed. If higher-ups request more-visible ads and higher conversion rates for the app, there are ways to funnel this traffic without making the site difficult or impossible to use on a mobile device. This is the job of a web designer. (If higher-ups are mandating the design itself, they have assumed the role of web designer and relegated the titular designer to simply a web design implementor). This mobile website is poorly designed. Thus, by definition, it's the fault of the web designer. And nothing is going to change with finger-pointing or blame-passing or the victim mentality so blatantly evident in this comment thread.
- mmanfrin 13y agoThis is the ad-hominem fallacy and is not at all relevant to the correctness of his point. I don't think it's an ad-hominem to critique design of the site critiquing anothers' design.
- tedsanders 13y agoIt sort of is. If I say George Bush is stupid, and you reply that I'm stupid, you haven't really refuted my point. Though maybe if I say George Bush should recycle, and you reply that I don't recycle, you've indirectly challenged my point by bringing attention to my contradictory hypocrisy. Hmm.
- talmand 13y agoSaying you're stupid for calling someone else stupid can sometimes be a proper response. I think you have to state why you think the person is stupid and for it to be a valid reason to avoid the response. Sort of like you did with the recycle version of the statement.
- 13y ago
- keithpeter 13y agoJust went to look at the Esquire article itself on Firefox with noscript installed on a laptop. 73 scripts and 1 object, that is a record (but I don't usually use Web sites like Esquire). Does iPad not have a noscript like thing?
- Samuel_Michon 13y agoYou can turn off JavaScript in iOS Safari. Go to Settings > Safari > Advanced > disable JavaScript. There’s also a Ghostery browser for iOS: https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/ghostery/id472789016?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/ghostery/id472789016?mt=8
- avty 13y agoSays the guy with the green on black page...
- Steko 13y agoApple could easily remedy this by denying approval to media apps for websites that offer degraded experiences for iOS users. Problem solved.
- jlgreco 13y agoSeems non-trivial to effectively enforce in practice. Does not having a dedicated mobile site count as "degraded experiences"? Does having a mobile site that only offers limited functionality count? A mobile site with full functionality, but that takes twice as many clicks to do anything than the desktop version? A mobile site that is technically usable but has large and frequent ads? Or is this only for mobile sites that actually aren't usable, like the one in the article? Depending on where you draw the line, companies could just degrade their site in the next less egregious way.
- talmand 13y agoThat's an extremely bad idea.
- Steko 13y agoWhy? Because FREEDOM!? It funny how many here react to any move by Apple to improve their customer's experience as Evil Incarnate. Maybe Matt Cutts can come by and explain what happens to your website on Google Search when you have a 'download our app' popup. http://econsultancy.com/us/blog/62902-google-avoid-download-app-pop-ups-or-lose-mobile-search-rankings http://econsultancy.com/us/blog/62902-google-avoid-download-...
- talmand 13y agoHow exactly is requiring approval from Apple for your app based on their wishes of what your website should do or not do be considered freedom?
- busterzzz 13y agoThis happens notoriously on a Facebook I own. Always popping shit up about promoting posts and running campaigns.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- evolve2k 13y ago'And, to be clear, I then never read the article. Because I know that whatever they have to say will be said better by someone else who isn't such an asshole.' Here here!
- nostromo 13y agoHere's one mobile annoyance I'd love to see go away: fixed nav bars on mobile. Here's what Wired looks like on my iPhone: http://i.imgur.com/pvgWa0p.png http://i.imgur.com/pvgWa0p.png
- talmand 13y agoHah! I just recently finished a project where we made the header and footer become unstuck on mobile for that very reason.
- talmand 13y agoAs one who has worked as a web designer and now currently occasionally designs in my fits of development work, I take offense to the first sentence. This sentence heavily assumes that these decisions were made by a web designer. Or anyone who knows design or usability for that matter. I can't tell you how many times over my career that I've stated "this is a bad idea" to no avail. Now this wonderful critique is out there, on a popular blog, that points the finger directly at someone without really knowing if they were the cause of the problems.
- shawnreilly 13y agoThe title is a little misleading; Just because one Website has a bad Mobile Experience does not mean we have a 'reign of Morons'. There are lots of Websites out there that have awesome Mobile Experiences, this just (apparently) is not one of them. But even with this said, I think it's important to note that designing a great Mobile Experience is no easy task. To me, it all starts with the Viewport, which is not necessarily an easy thing to understand. It seems as though the original Use Case for the Viewport was to provide the capability of zooming, presumably to account for Websites that were/are not mobile friendly. Over time, it seems as though the preferred User Experience has shifted to a set (non-zoomable) Experience, which is common with Web Apps. In fact, many of today's common Web Frameworks (example: Bootstrap, jQuery Mobile, etc), set the viewport to a 1.0 scale, and prevent zooming with the max and min scale set to 1.0, and/or an explicit user-scalable=no. So it stands to reason that there are grey areas between the original use case, and how people use it today. This could explain why some of the "Bigger Name" Websites still have Mobile Experiences that require Zooming. But this is still no excuse for the overall User Experience described here, which does not sound good. Just like an App, I believe that Websites (or Website Projects) should have someone dedicated to a User Experience role, which would identify some of the issues raised here, and solve them. When the Advertising in conjunction with the Design makes the Website un-usable, that really is sad.
- istvanp 13y agoEsquire UK recently launched their redesign and has much better UX: http://www.esquire.co.uk/ http://www.esquire.co.uk/ Perhaps they might apply the same design for the US sometime in the future.
- kristianp 13y agoNo one is mentioning the elephant in the room, which is that with declining online ad revenue, and now that sites have just about reached the limit of how much advertising they can put on a page layout, they have resorted to "Subscribe to my newsletter" popups, and the one that irks me almost as much, the unmoving bars at the top and bottom of the page to try to keep the user on the site, by providing ever-present links. (Damn you google news,mail,blogger,etc!) The things jwz is complaining about aren't just a problem for tablet browsing, they are a problem for all browser types.
- benjash 13y agoComing from working in a publishing company... It's definitely not the designers fault. This is purely the result of mixed objectives and committee design. There will be fighting between a publisher, editorial, marketing, sales, designers and tech team. Each dept. will have a trump card to have there say. Trapped in a false numbers game of milking the most pageviews out of whatever they can. While giving media buyers whatever they need to sell the space to there clients. The designer will usually have a little or no say in what goes where. fact.