6 ms·
I like the similar argument for Alien visitors, we are approaching saturation in terms of cameras that can take videos and a highly discoverable channel for mak
by ChuckMcM 13y ago
I like the similar argument for Alien visitors, we are approaching saturation in terms of cameras that can take videos and a highly discoverable channel for making such videos available (*tube) and so, like the neutrino detectors in mine shafts, if there is an "event" we'll catch it on camera. That gives us the ability to start computing the probabilities more accurately vis-a-vis alien visitation.
- wtvanhest 13y agoI was thinking the same thing while reading it. We do have a way to go before consumer camera technology is good enough to capture moving spaceships (or even jet liners at night). Cameras are not very good at catching sharp movement of low lit objects. Just to photograph sports clearly requires several thousand dollars in equipment and you can be as close as 50 meters most of the game. That will change a lot over the years as sensor technology continues to improve and eventually your point will be important.
- johnchristopher 13y agoYou are both forgetting Suliban and Romulan cloaking devices.
- mathattack 13y agoI thought cameras would be the death of paranormal, but then we have photoshop and facebook to convert a whole new wave of believers. I do like the thought process though - if it's supposedly this common but still unproven, it's less likely to be true. Do we put ghosts in the same category?
- dkersten 13y agoI always think about it the other way around: given we have photoshop and similar tools, every bit of photographic and video evidence is suspect. Just look at a movie - if that's what we can do, how could anybody ever believe a photo or video of, say, aliens unless they were there themselves.
- jlgreco 13y agoIf you see one video of aliens visiting Central Park^, then you can probably be sure that it is fake. If twitter is suddenly flooded with reports about aliens in Central Park^, and dozens to hundreds of people all upload different cellphone videos of it, then something just might actually be happening. There is still potential for mass-fraud, but repeated seemingly uncoordinated reports improves credibility. Maybe they're all Photoshopping the same thing from different angles, but that is less likely than a single person doing it. ^ I mean come on, if you were an alien, where would you go first? I'd totally go to New York. Here is another rule of thumb: if the aliens are doing something boring, like stealing cows or fucking with corn fields, they probably aren't real.
- kanzure 13y ago> There is still potential for mass-fraud, but repeated seemingly uncoordinated reports improves credibility Hmm. That would be an interesting piece of fraud (oops I mean public art) to architect. Make a Blender scene of Central Park, populate the scene with bystanders with phones (yes, this will take time to source realistic models and skeletal animations). Each phone gets to be a camera in the scene. Not all cameras start and stop at the same time, and a few of them will have to capture video before and after the event without the actual event included. Timestamp and tag the videos appropriately, including clock drift, then have fun with avconv/ffmpeg converting the formats to different video formats based on known phone sales and what default formats iOS/Android encodes to (ugh, I actually had to do this once back when zencoder/pandavideo). Create twitter accounts in advance, make them look real by copying other twitter users, and the day of the event just start uploading the youtube videos all at the same time and get your fake tweets flowing. Now, what could this pipeline be useful for? Suppose you know that the videos are fake, but also suppose you can be reasonably sure that others will accept this data as real news. What could you do with that? First idea is some killer marketing stunt..
- jlgreco 13y agoYeah, as I wrote that I actually began to think that it would be a pretty neat idea. I think maybe you could do it by actually filming in Central Park with some sort of structure with white balls on it, in a certain known arrangement, that you could automate a lot of the video editing from various angles.. I'm not sure about that but I suspect it is feasible. If you get everyone to film different angles at the same basic time then the scene would be the same (just from different angles) and you'd have everyone else filming in the background that would lend credibility.
- api 13y agoThere's tons of UFO videos on YouTube. The problem is that if you exclude the obvious CGI and other hoaxes, that leaves a data set of unidentified objects captured on camera. But that provides little evidence as to what that object might actually be. There are many prosaic explanations: illusions, imaging artifacts, really good hoaxes, top-secret experimental aircraft built by us, ball lightning, etc.
- ChuckMcM 13y agoExactly right. I went to a talk at the SETI institute where analysis of such videos left a very small residue of "unexplained" visual phenomena.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- givan 13y agoAliens are advanced and have cloacking ability, the only proof we have are stories from abductee hypnosis sessions. Professor Jacobs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_M._Jacobs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/David_M._Jacobs has researched the subject scientifically for decades.
- krapp 13y ago>the only proof we have are stories from abductee hypnosis sessions. That isn't proof of anything.
- jlgreco 13y agoSeriously. If we were to accept that sort of bullshit nonsense as evidence then we would also have "evidence" for widespread organized "Satanic ritual abuse" in the 1980's, devils which sit on the chests of sleeping people, ghosts and/or spirits of the dead, aliens riding DC-8's exploding hydrogen bombs in volcanoes...
- givan 13y agoI agree that even if millions claim that have been abducted this is not solid proof but I think that the main reason for the lack of solid proofs is the impact of such proofs on the human society. Also this is subject is very taboo, most people reject the subject immediately as ridiculous and compare it to fairies and ghosts. Maybe they are afraid, closed minded or really belive we are alone in this vast universe.
- krapp 13y ago>Maybe they are afraid, closed minded or really belive we are alone in this vast universe. You're asserting false dichotomies. The universe may be teeming with life, but that still wouldn't lend any credence to the scenario of alien abduction. You don't have to be afraid or close-minded to doubt it, you just have to be rational. It isn't proof, simply because it's entirely subjective. It exists inside people's minds.
- 13y ago
- 8_hours_ago 13y agoObligatory XKCD reference: http://xkcd.com/1235/ http://xkcd.com/1235/