3 ms·
So you are misinterpreting Einstein by modifying his sentences, the actual quote is from 1934 and together with the parts you omitted is: "If one purges the Ju
by acqq 13y ago
So you are misinterpreting Einstein by modifying his sentences, the actual quote is from 1934 and together with the parts you omitted is:
"If one purges the Judaism of the Prophets and Christianity as
Jesus Christ taught it of all subsequent additions, especially
those of the priests, one is left with a teaching which is capable
of curing all the social ills of humanity."
Wikipedia at least didn't omit the parts that you do -- you omitted "If one purges the Judaism of the Prophets and" and "of all subsequent additions, especially those of the priests, one is left with a teaching" -- so you're more malicious in this occasion, intentionally omitting Einstein words which are important the parts of the whole sentence.
Completely different context. Try to purge the teaching of both from the later additions -- almost nothing would remain -- the earliest written records of Christianity are Paul's writings, and he was a main priest. The Gospels are even later written, obviously by priests too. The rest of the Bible is even later, everything written by priest. Of course, once the humanity would accept such a purge (to drop everything written by priests) it would result in much higher level of global consciousnesses and therefore curing of social ills.
And again the "Spinoza God" quote is published 1930, his 1954 response is clear "I do not believe in a personal God." and "If something is in me which can be called religious then it is the unbounded admiration for the structure of the world so far as our science can reveal it." That are his words in 1954 written by him directly, he died in 1955.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoThere was no malice I assure you. AFAICT my edit was entirely in line with what he said, as for example "as Jesus Christ taught it" already means "free of all subsequent additions" that part (for example) is just emphasis. I read the quote as applying equally to either Judaism or Christianity but I can see how it can be intended to include both sets of teaching taken together. The only point of the quote was to show that he wasn't "simply an agnostic" in the same way that Russell was "simply an agnostic". That's it. Can you demonstrate to me what malice I performed? Perhaps your massive axe got in the way while you were grinding it and you misread my comment. Now you're paragraph beginning "Completely different context" absolutely does put words in to Einstein's mouth beyond that shown in the quote. Presumably you have an additional source you didn't mention that enlarges on the point made in that minute quote? A corollary of what you state is that none of the Gospels nor Epistles represent Christianity - how then did Einstein know what Jesus taught. Your interpretation makes the quote in question nonsensical. I await your source with interest.
- acqq 13y agoOnce again what Einstein wrote is: "If" (condition) "one purges" (action to be done: purge) "the Judaism" (object 1) "of the Prophets" (of what) "and" "Christianity as Jesus Christ taught it" (object 2) "of all subsequent additions, especially those of the priests," (of what for object 2) (then) "one is left with a teaching which is capable of curing all the social ills of humanity." He didn't claim "to know what Jesus taught." He suggests the benefit to humanity in purging the teachings of all additions especially of those of the priests and prophets. That clearly means also to purge the teachings of Paul's writings and of Gospels as they were written by priests, and then of course of the rest of the Bible and everything written by Christians in the following 2000 years. In Judaism, that also means practically everything. Try it yourself. As soon as you can't believe the priests and use their interpretations you'll have to turn to the scientists or to use scientific methods yourself.
- pbhjpbhj 13y agoWell. Let's start with the Wikipedia version of the quote as if it were canonical. >Nevertheless, he also expressed his belief that "if one purges the Judaism of the Prophets and Christianity as Jesus Christ taught it of all subsequent additions, especially those of the priests, one is left with a teaching which is capable of curing all the social ills of humanity." The disjunctive arrives from the first comma and that there aren't any conjunctive prepositions linking your object1 and object2. Thus the disjunct statements combined in this form are A) "if one purges the Judaism of the Prophets one is left with a teaching which is capable of curing all the social ills of humanity". Wherein I'm not sure which group of prophets are antecedent here. "The prophets" in Christian theology refers to the minor prophets of the latter part of the OT. and B) "if one purges Christianity as Jesus Christ taught it of all subsequent additions, especially those of the priests, one is left with a teaching which is capable of curing all the social ills of humanity." As I said I accept the alternate reading that these two teaching, those arrived at through A and B, combined should instead be used to create the ultimate teaching. However you appear to believe that he said it didn't create any teaching, it created an absence of teaching. You've heavily modified the scope of his intent without there being any indication as to how it should be modified. You say the Gospels were "written by priests" and so should be purged. Yet they are primary sources of what "Jesus Christ taught" (and indeed were not written by priests). He claims this process leaves one with an ultimate teaching. But your bowdlerised version of the methodology leaves one with nothing. You appear to want this to say "imagine no religion" (or words to that effect), that such a thing would cure humanity of all social ills - despite this being outside of Einstein's area of genius I still can't believe he was such a fool. Primarily the point was that based on my reading Einstein and Russell take importantly distinct positions, both agnostic. That categorising their attitudes to religion, and hence the scope of agnostic beliefs, as indistinct is unhelpful verging on disingenous. I'll hold that position for now unless you have much better arguments than you've so far put. >Try it yourself. // Ha. I became an atheist as a child until I realised that position is scientifically unsound. Going forward I studied philosophy, maths and physics. Then I became a Christian based on personal experiences. Studying - and being presented as trustworthy - Haeckl and Hubble at high-school taught me not to trust someone for their reputation; neither the teachers nor the purportedly eminent scientists. I use scientific methods which rather preclude me "turn[ing] to the scientists" who are as likely as any priest to have a bias. Ultimately I'm a pyrrhonist but practically, beyond first axioms [trustworthyness of sensedata, continuity of time dimension(s), and such] I'm a Christian as that is the empirical conclusion.