11 ms·
Judge tosses Apple motion, allows patent troll Lodsys to continue rampage
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- freyr 13y agoApple is not a patent troll. A patent troll, by definition, does not provide any products or services that use its patents.
- x0054 13y agoApple should hire a nation wide law firm to defend any and all apple developers who are sued by Lodsys fore these patents. Instruct the lawfirm to never settle and actively file actions on beheld of each client against Lodsys. It's simple, once they realize that no one will settle with them, they will go away. Now, where on earth is that patent troll bill congress has been promising?
- warfangle 13y agoCongress is too busy attempting to filibuster the debate period to get anything done.
- ajross 13y agoIf Apple is "instructing" that firm, then they aren't representing their clients' interests correctly. That sort of relationship is actually very hard to manage in the courts, which is why it's quite rare (and usually limited to true pro bono work by established non-profits).
- fbuilesv 13y ago> If Apple is "instructing" that firm, then they aren't representing their clients' interests correctly. Sorry to pick on just one phrase of your comment but I'm honestly curious. How is the "not-representing the client's interests" thing a problem inside a court? Is it because the other side or the court will pick on it, or is it because it honestly does not represent a client's interests[0]? [0] In this case, I can't imagine an app. developer not wanting help dealing with this specific problem, but I've never been in that position.
- x0054 13y agoOk, instruct is probably a bad term, I know what you mean. What Apple can do is promise to indemnify the individual developer for any out of pocket expenses above and beyond the initial settlement offer, as long as the developer chooses to use the free legal defense apple would provide, and not settle the case. If the lawyer and the developer, for what ever reason, decide that it's best to settle, it's fine, in that case the developer would have to pay out of pocket for the settlement, but they would be no worse off, and they would get a free attorney helping them in either case. For apple this arrangement would be relatively inexpensive, as long as they hire a nation wide firm. Since the causes of action in each case are exactly the same, the defense would be exactly the same, same expert opinions, same motions, etc. For developers that publish to both Google Play and App Store, it's only fair if google would kick in 1/2 the costs, but if they do not, then it would be a huge PR win for apple. Basically, they would be saying, develop with us, and we will take care of you.
- josephlord 13y agoYes they could do more to help but at least they are doing more than Google.
- justinpombrio 13y agoHere is what Lodsys has to say about the creator of the patents it asserts: > Abelow is not an officer or manager of Lodsys Group LLC, he has no interest in Lodsys patents, and he does not receive any revenue from the licenses granted by Lodsys in the patents he created.
- jevinskie 13y agoSo Abelow is either a fool for not getting a cut from Lodsys or he is a patent gifting fairy.
- randomfool 13y agoNeither- he already cashed out. He sold the patents years ago. Just like you can sell stock to people completely unrelated to a company, you can sell patents too. Patent trolls are just efficient monetization of patents. The real problem is patent law (and judges preventing class-action to allow more efficient judgement of the validity of patents).
- geuis 13y agoWhy hasn't anyone addressed the probable criminal activity going on with these handful of judges in this one district of Texas? Just because someone has the title "judge" doesn't give them untouchable super powers. There's a giant reek of illegality coming from that area and someone needs to look under the covers. My hypothesis is there's a payoff racket going on. There's a multi level system setup with a few insiders who know how to pay off the local judges to dismiss certain cases. This is Texas. These people don't have some sense that big bad companies are beating up on little old inventors trying to protect themselves with patents as has been portrayed in the media. These people are generally small minded Jesus followers who can't name 20 states outside of Texas and would be hard pressed to remember the name of the Vice President. I'm not speaking out of my ass either. I've lived in Texas. I have family there now. There's some serious corruption going on and it needs looking into.
- efa 13y agoJust because you lived in Texas doesn't give you a pass in saying such a hateful thing. This is the most ignorant thing I've seen on HN in a long time.
- geuis 13y agoYou're partly right. I'm not particularly happy that a) I expressed myself this way and b) its the top voted comment on this article. There's a deeper message that I was trying to get across but this came out pretty badly.
- benologist 13y agoThat seems highly unlikely given that Apple etc aren't retarded and would have pursued that theory if they thought it was possible.
- andybak 13y agoThis is the worst quality top comment I've seen on HN in a while. I hope it doesn't stay top.
- javajosh 13y agoThe threat that Lodsys represents to anyone doing technology is so large that it would seem to make sense to band together. I'm thinking along the lines of creating a "Patent Defense Cooperative" where members pay a certain amount every month for the three purposes of a) patent lawsuit insurance, b) to fund lobbying efforts to reform the patent system, and c) scrutinize a judicial apparatus that seems biased in favor of patent trolls. I would certainly join such an organization as an individual inventor and technologist. This can't be a new idea. Has anyone else thought of doing this?
- randomfool 13y agoSweet- so Apple can join this and infringe on anyone's patents and get their legal bills paid for? Seriously though, it would have to have some clear definition of patent troll. It would be interesting to have some sort of insurance- say $5million to be spent in case of patent lawsuit. Make a clear public statement- we will never settle and WILL spend $5m in case of a lawsuit. Would make it very counter-productive for small-time trolls. This is essentially what NewEgg did and it makes sense.
- javajosh 13y agoYou are right. Luckily there is a fairly well known, small list of patent trolls (the people mind you, not the meaningless shell companies) that could be simply enumerated, with the charter of the cooperative allowing additions (but never removals). I mean, I'd pay $20/mo for Lodsys protection alone.
- AnthonyMouse 13y ago>Sweet- so Apple can join this and infringe on anyone's patents and get their legal bills paid for? Presumably it would cover litigation costs but not liabilities. So if you lose at the end, you still lose and have to pay damages out of your own pocket. >Seriously though, it would have to have some clear definition of patent troll. Not necessarily. You might not classify the likes of IBM as a "patent troll" under some definitions, but having some sort of litigation expenses insurance when they come knocking would certainly be welcome. Why not avoid the hair splitting exercises and just have the insurance kick in whenever someone makes a patent infringement claim against you?
- chetanahuja 13y agoThe texas east district stuff is fascinating. What if the app and software developers start licensing their apps with a license and technical measures explicitly excluding East Texas (or the entire state of texas, for extra safety) from the operation of the app. It could be enforced by some soft of geofencing at app startup that splashes a "You're from East Texas, our app doesn't work there" type language. Will that affect the ability of the trolls to venue shop at least (if not to bring the suite in the first place). Of course an even better response would be if smartphone vendors disable their entire OS's in that district. That might be fun.
- possibilistic 13y agoI like this idea a lot. If the population living in the causative region understands the nature of what their governing body is doing to impact and infringe upon on the rest of the world, maybe they'll change who holds the relevant positions of power. It would be great if we could do this to websites and technology in general as well. Maybe we can start with this kind of campaign [1], but utilize geo-IP targeting. [1] http://internetdefenseleague.org/ http://internetdefenseleague.org/
- saryant 13y agoIt's a federal court, the State of Texas has nothing to do with it. These judges are appointed by the President.
- anologwintermut 13y agoWith the recommendation and consultation of the representative for the district and the two Senators for the state. Who clearly have something to do with this. How else can you explain east texas being the venue of choice?
- saryant 13y agoA friend of mine who's a patent lawyer explained it to me once. Some time back the chief judge started putting patent cases at the top of his docket so his district became known as a having "rocket docket" and began attracting patent cases from across the country. A cottage industry sprung up in the area and the rest is history.
- josaka 13y agoI think these patents have expired. US 7,620,565 and 7,222,078 date back to an August 1992 parent application, and were themselves filed in 1999, after the 20-years from priority date rule went into effect. Neither was granted patent term extension. So they should have expired last year.
- 31reasons 13y agoMicrosoft -> Nathan Myhrvold (former CTO) -> Intellectual Venture (founder) -> Lodsys -> Threatening Apple Developer Hmmm.
- SeanLuke 13y agoYou forgot to include the Modernist Cuisine link.
- rsynnott 13y agoGoogle and Apple also have links to Intellectual Ventures. I suspect Lodsys would be happily going after WinPhone developers if not for the platform's relative irrelevance; so far they've concentrated on iOS and Android developers.
- Iftheshoefits 13y agoHow are any of these patents valid, especially in application to mobile application technology? I'm not a lawyer; I'm seriously baffled as to how any of them, in application to mobile "pay to upgrade" (or any other "customer interaction") flows, aren't obvious. It's the first thing I thought of when I first thought to write a mobile application and how to make money off of it.
- robomartin 13y agoSix million developers in the US iOS ecosystem? If that's the case that is a massive number of people, particularly if you consider employees and contractors they might work with. Perhaps I am being a simplistic moron. To me the solution to these problems is to make a lot of noise. A lot of it. And to do it continuously. And to do it through all available media and channels. And not to stop until the issue is dealt with by legislators. You want coverage by every single media outlet on a daily basis. This community can make something like that happen. It's isn't that difficult if top level companies take lead. With one simple addition to their websites the entire world would become aware of the issue that is killing innovation in tech circles. This is a community that has the power to do this. If this community unites behind a common message tomorrow the entire world could start to feel the pressure. Political leaders will have to both acknowledge and act to solve the problem. This is not a war that will be won one battle at a time. This is a war that needs to be won through legislative action. There are far more people affected by bullshit patents than most imagine. All we need is an organization under which we could all unite and start making noise. Banners on all websites. Pop-ups on all apps. Whatever it takes. Would it be inconvenient to our users? Possibly. However, you have to consider the idea that there's a huge opportunity here to educate everyone and, at the same time, highlight the fact that a more sensible patent system would actually improve things across the world. I am not going to do them math, but I am sure one could easily show economic advantages which will include job creation. I wish I had the standing, time and resources to launch such a thing. I don't. There are well-funded companies with more than enough resources to devote to such an effort. To borrow from Bravehart: Help us. Help yourselves! Now is our chance, now! If we join, we can win. If we win, well then we'll have what none of us have ever had before; freedom to create; freedom from the fear of trolls; the ability to innovate to the extent of our abilities; the freedom to create whatever our minds can imagine. You are the technology leaders and there is strength in you. Unite us. Unite us!