8 ms·
Bitcoin is Worse is Better
- josephagoss 13y agoNot really sure that Bitcoin involves "no major intellectual breakthroughs". Perhaps no breakthroughs for independent parts (Satoshi did not create a new cryptographic function, for example) but the placement of known parts into a working system is in itself an intellectual breakthrough. I don't understand how the author can say that Bitcoin is in no way an intellectual breakthrough. Perhaps I misunderstood the article. Maybe the author misses the creative and novel system that Satoshi built just because the bricks are not all brand new. Even Bill Gates called Bitcoin a techno tour de force.
- ferdo 13y agoAgreed. The blockchain itself is an intellectual breakthrough, at least in application.
- drcode 13y agoExactly: Saying that the blockchain was not an intellectual breakthrough is like saying the lightbulb wasn't an intellectual breakthrough because it relied on the invention of electrical wires.
- gnaritas 13y agoDid you read the whole article?
- olalonde 13y agoThis is addressed in the article: http://www.gwern.net/Bitcoin%20is%20Worse%20is%20Better?2#objection-bitcoin-is-not-worse-its-better http://www.gwern.net/Bitcoin%20is%20Worse%20is%20Better?2#ob...
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- gmaster1440 13y agoThere's been an increase in gwern articles on Hacker News recently, I like it. Just curious why now?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- watizdat 13y agoCheck the username of the OP.
- perturbation 13y agoI, for one, am suspicious. Gwern's posting of old articles from his site (which are nonetheless articulate, intelligent, and interesting) makes me think that this is step 437 of a 21352 part plan that ends with him as Emperor of the Moon, laughing as he abuses the escape from Earth's gravity well to extract utility via threat of kinetic bombardment. To paraphrase Arthur Weasley: "Never trust anyone if you can't see where they keep their utility function."
- gwern 13y agoPerturbation, I am hurt by your comments. What did I ever do to deserve such well-founded paranoia?
- Eliezer 13y agoWhat is non-well-founded paranoia? Is it when you think there's a conspiracy behind the conspiracy behind the conspiracy... and so on indefinitely?
- pjscott 13y agon+1 conspiracies are strictly less likely than n conspiracies, for obvious reasons. There's got to be some length of the conspiracy chain beyond which you're forced to assume that either (a) you've postulated too many conspiracies, or (b) there's a conspiracy whose main goal is the creation of ridiculously long chains of conspiracies behind other conspiracies, and it's doing a good job.
- cs702 13y agoI agree with much of this essay, but it only hints at a key point: the most brilliant elements of Bitcoin's design are not in the realm of technical achievement, but in the realm of social engineering. Bitcoin is not just a "technology" but a social platform with built-in incentives for attracting miners and transaction processors, and therefore end-users; growing demand from end-users attracts even more miners and transaction processors -- a self-reinforcing feedback loop. All other prior crypto-currency efforts failed because, not because they were technically "inferior" (in the narrow sense of that word), but because they lacked the incentives necessary to attract a sufficient number of adopters.
- gojomo 13y agoI agree Bitcoin's approachability and incentive structure were crucial. The interesting question now: is Bitcoin sui generis (like say TCP/IP, and further cemented in place by network effects) or the harbinger of many similar systems (like say Napster/Gnutella)? A lot of people were deterred from trying things in this sphere because of a (flawed) conventional wisdom that there was no room for success — that various academic attacks would be fatal, and social/institutional barriers too strong. But now that Bitcoin shows that an ugly "Minimum Viable Cryptocurrency" with the right balances/incentives can take off, we're already seeing lots of new interest and experiments. I strongly expect some of these will discover new workable tradeoffs, in some cases even better than Bitcoin's brilliant+lucky mix, that will then either coexist with Bitcoin in overlapping domains, or feed into the evolution of 'Bitcoin Prime'. Lots more fun ahead.
- maxerickson 13y agoIf the legal issues are not a big deal, one big competitor will be a low fee, price stable, zero coin like system underwritten by a commercial entity. Commercial backing will be more interesting to many consumers than the network of miners.
- gojomo 13y agoDefinitely, or a consortium of backers. I could also see USGov offering a FedCoin (guaranteed redemption for USD) or TBillCoin (instantly tradable, divisible, interest-bearing USGov debt as currency). They might even be able to cook up something that's more anonymous than Bitcoin (ZeroCoin-like) most of the time, but deanonymizable sfter some 'CoinCourt' due process legal proceedings. (Think ClipperChip/key-escrow, but for cryptocurrency.)
- bachback 13y agoI find it fascinating that this invention is still not understood and when then only through layers of tech. BTC allows transactions in a network without a central party. that is it. the real question is why we haven't seen any real major new use case, but for instance the new micropayment protocol points in that direction. I believe there is a sort of tail end of this development which will come much later. BTC is a kind of hackers utopia, because the whole economy could be reshaped with code.
- oscargrouch 13y ago> that is it. the real question is why we haven't seen any real major new use case Because its ahead of its time.. When we got the first cars, what kind of road did we have back than? Roads for horses and bandwagons.. Its the same with this centralized internet design.. and the ones that profit the most with this design, wont do any move to change things in that Did you see any Google product that its p2p? or Apple? or MS? why? an army of smart people and none of them could create new products thats are not proxyfied over their clouds, or make us dependent of them somehow? Its the same Office Package model, just that its one from the age of internet.. specially the ones that are "free"
- bachback 13y agoInteresting. At the same time it took Ford to build cars. But perhaps we will have new types of collectives instead of corporations. I think there could be new types of systems of laws. So Bitcoin in the end could become something like a protocol for software agents to act in the real world. Mike Hearn has spelled some parts of this out. It's a bit of a shame that Satoshi didn't write more, because these ideas were close to the original cloud of ideas.
- javert 13y agoBitcoin is a major intellectual breakthrough, in that it is a "heuristic" for Byzantine consensus that can scale arbitrarily. Moreover, Satoshi understood enough about economics (not, not social engineering, economics) to set up the correct incentives to get tons of people to participate in the concensus algorithm (mining). The reason it took forever to come up with a viable digital currency is the obvious one: deep insight into both economics and crypto and major, creative intuitive leaps were needed. Bitcoin is one of the single most impressive works of computer science I've ever seen. Gwern's article stoops to an unfathomable level of intellectual masturbation.
- nly 13y agoI don't think I've ever seen such a comprehensive summary of opinion on Bitcoin from so many different names inside what could easily be from the digital cash chapter of a yet-unborn history textbook. Zooko (known, to me anyway, for Zooko's triangle), Stefan Brands and Wei Dai are all names I recognise from casual research on e-cash, and it's great to see such a rich set of citations.
- cmccabe 13y agoWhenever I see the "worse is better" meme, I know I'm in store for a criticism of some engineering decisions or other by someone who doesn't understand the decision criteria. (And often, someone who was pushing an alternate solution that failed because of this lack of understanding.) Engineering is more than just implementing theoretical work. It's about making tradeoffs in the real world.
- teashorts 13y agoIs there an actually usable RSS feed of the essays on the site? Importing http://www.gwern.net/atom.xml http://www.gwern.net/atom.xml into i.e. The Old Reader gives me a feed of all changes to the site - not really what I want.
- gwern 13y agoSuch an RSS feed can only be written in retrospect, after time has passed and I know whether I'm done with an essay or not, so it doesn't exist. http://www.gwern.net/Changelog http://www.gwern.net/Changelog is probably what you want.
- anotherbadlogin 13y agoBitcoin: Get over it. "You're posting too fast" You know what HN? FUCK YOU.
- bachback 13y agoCouple of missing data points: * the number of connected internet clients. compare the years 2008 and 2000. In the year 2000 the idea of Bitcoin would have been pie in the sky (although it would be an interesting thought experiment of alternative history of Bitcoin appearing during the INET bubble) * eGold peaked in 2008 * bandwith. identification methods. opensource collaboration. we speak of the internet and the web but they are not constant through time.
- dbg31415 13y agoHate the title.
- gwern 13y agoComplain to rpg. He invented & named the concept, I'm just using it.