11 ms·
Tarsnap logo contest
- prawn 13y agoA good way to make sure that the designer gets the full fee (without losing a commission to 99designs or by them participating in a design contest with no guarantee of getting paid) is to choose one designer and offer them the $500. Does the interest in design contests stem from a fear of paying and getting something you might not like? Or not knowing what you might like until you see it?
- cperciva 13y agoI have no idea what I might like. I'm hoping to get some discussion and sharing of ideas -- including from people who don't have any interest in or ability to actually produce a logo themselves. If I knew that, say, I wanted a graphic of a piece of tar being snapped in half, I'd look for an artist and say "here's $500, please draw this for me". But given that I have no idea what I want, I figure the more people I invite to provide ideas the better.
- Raphael 13y agoAll this time I thought it was tars-nap.
- cfqycwz 13y agoLots of people hire a graphic designer with no real idea of what they want--the point of a graphic designer is to talk to a client about the ideas and values of their business, think a lot about those things, go through a bunch of iterations, and then eventually end up with a finished product. That takes a lot of work--usually at least 30 to 40 hours for a good logo. Would you put in 40 hours of work for somebody on the off chance they might pay you? You can rest assured of this as well: people will definitely submit to your contest--but none of them will be great designers, because all of them will be people who place the value of their work at somewhere around "maybe 500 dollars."
- klawed 13y ago>You can rest assured of this as well: people will definitely submit to your contest--but none of them will be great designers, because all of them will be people who place the value of their work at somewhere around "maybe 500 dollars." This would almost certainly be true if content participants had no connection to the business. In this case, participants my be considering their work to be pro-bono work with a value much greater $500.
- cperciva 13y agoI figured that Tarsnap users had a head start on the "figuring out ideas and values" part, in that they generally know what Tarsnap is and how it works. It's possible that I'll find that someone has a nice idea but a poor implementation and award them the $500 but go off to hire an artist to draw the idea better.
- dpapathanasiou 13y agoBut given that I have no idea what I want, I figure the more people I invite to provide ideas the better. You can just do what Steve Jobs did with Next: pick a designer you like, and leave it entirely up to him. Ironically not because Jobs didn't have ideas on what he wanted but because the designer insisted: "I asked him if he would come up with a few options, and he said, 'No, I will solve your problem for you and you will pay me. You don’t have to use the solution. If you want options go talk to other people.'" http://www.logodesignlove.com/next-logo-paul-rand http://www.logodesignlove.com/next-logo-paul-rand
- tptacek 13y agoThat worked because Jobs could contract Paul Rand. Colin has $500 to spend.
- s0rce 13y agoI'd trust Paul Rand too.
- huhtenberg 13y agoNeXT logo is plain awful. I know it comes with 47 page manual explaining why the cube should be rotated by 17 (?) degrees, what the colors mean and all that, but the simple fact is that it simply didn't match the sleek nature of NeXTs themselves.
- lancer383 13y agoRight, but the issue is that 99 out of 100 designers will do work for you and not get paid for it, while one will. There are some good links to thoughts about speculative work here: http://www.nospec.com/articles http://www.nospec.com/articles
- tptacek 13y agoThe other thing that will happen is that the most credible submissions will come from places like Indonesia and Vietnam and Bulgaria. I wonder what freaks pro designers out more, concern over the wasted time of contest losers, or concern over the extent to which offshore piecework designers can drive the prices down for people like Colin who simply don't want the full 40-80 hour project.
- prawn 13y agoI'd prefer someone in this situation find a cheap, young gun abroad and pay them the $500.
- joelhooks 13y agoI wasted money this year on a designer, who had work we liked, but couldn't come up with anything we liked for our brand. Wish I had crowd sourced it.
- prawn 13y agoIs it about what you want, or about what best represents your product to your audience? e.g., you give the brief to a designer and they work from that. Would you run a code contest to have a software product built?
- noir_lord 13y agoI dropped you an email but just in case http://i.imgur.com/k6elBCU.png http://i.imgur.com/k6elBCU.png
- cam_l 13y agohttp://imgur.com/3v3lj9E http://imgur.com/3v3lj9E Here is a piece of tar being snapped in half.. it just makes sense, you know you like it. You can have this one.. its yours. If I were your designer-for-a-day, for 500 bucks i would do a few iterations once the concept is okayed to get it just right for you and give you all the svg / png / pdf or whatever other format you would like, and downscale to icon sizes etc.. but not until, in the immortal words of https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cP_GOoBPKfQ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=cP_GOoBPKfQ (c/o mike monteiro;)
- dmix 13y agoGlad to see Tarsnap investing in branding/identity. I like how Colin adopted prgmr.com style of appealing to the technical minded for it's website design/documentation. A simple logo wouldn't hurt.
- cperciva 13y agoA simple logo wouldn't hurt. I'm certainly not opposed to having a simple logo. I want to see what people come up with. :-)
- parennoob 13y agoI suppose tarsnap is named like 'portsnap', which you also wrote, but what is the thought process behind calling that 'portsnap'? That might help stimulate some ideas and suggestions. I am assuming it's not a piece of tar snapped in half. Although sometimes, having the FreeBSD ports system compile perl and python from scratch when I am trying to install emacs does make me want to snap it in half (yes, yes, I know I am not the model FreeBSD user, et cetera :))
- wrl 13y agoShort for "snapshot", I think?
- cperciva 13y agoportsnap = SNAPshots of the FreeBSD PORTs tree tarsnap = TAR backups, in a SNAPshotted model (vs. incremental backups). I also liked the fact that it reminded FreeBSD users of portsnap, which is a very popular tool.
- SwellJoe 13y agoI understood the name immediately, but always considered it an awful name for most "normal" users. But, maybe UNIX culture will win in the end and "tar" will become a word everyone knows.
- parennoob 13y agoFor what it's worth, I do know what 'tar' means -- I mostly use Linux (GNU/Linux if you're being pedantic), so the snap part was what I was asking about.
- cperciva 13y agoTarsnap users almost always already know what tar is. The fact that tarsnap has a tar command line -- i.e., one they already know -- is a big deal for a lot of tarsnap users.
- ericdykstra 13y agoI think you would end up with a better logo if you just did a call to your mailing list for designer recommendations, and paid a real designer $500 for a few hours of their work to come up with their best effort. By opening a contest, you're not only going to get a much lower quality of submissions, but in the end, the final decision is going to be made by you, someone "useless at anything artistic". Paying a designer $500 won't get you a full brand identity makeover, but that's not what you're going for. You should be able to find a talented designer who will spend an hour discussing what you want to get our of your logo, some time going over a number of their own ideas, and then wrap up the project and give you the sizes you need and a vector file if you ever need to scale your logo up or down.
- joelhooks 13y agoPaying a single designer directly can be really frustrating. $500 only buys you so many variations, and if none of them hit the mark, you are SOL, either settling for something "meh" or forking out more $$ for another round. At the low end, crowd sourcing logo design makes a lot of sense.
- unclebucknasty 13y agoYes. And possibly even through the mid to mid-high end.
- cperciva 13y agoin the end, the final decision is going to be made by you, someone "useless at anything artistic". That's a fair point... but I do know what Tarsnap is, and it's not exactly "typical". I don't know how many non-tarsnap-using designers would come up with something which is consistent with the rest of the "tarsnap brand".
- ericdykstra 13y agoWell, part of the $500 would presumably be talking through the goals of the project, what message you want to convey with the logo, how you might want to extend the Tarsnap brand in the future, etc. To put it another way, if you needed to roll out a new feature for Tarsnap but couldn't do it yourself, would you hire someone on contract, or do a contest for it?
- vicbrooker 13y agoConsidering Tarsnap doesn't have a GUI I'd suggest a text-only logo - something like Tarsnap_ for a full logo and then just T_ for social media icons/favicon/128x128. I can put something together but at the end of the day it's just changing fonts until there's a winner. Colin, if you're interested in the idea and there's a particular font/color you would like used let me know and I'll make the pngs for you. Don't stress about payment, it's quick and easy for me to do.
- dnerdy 13y agoText-only is also what I was thinking. Implemented via the Web Inspector: http://static.deliciouslynerdy.com/tarsnap/logo-and-favicon.png http://static.deliciouslynerdy.com/tarsnap/logo-and-favicon.... http://static.deliciouslynerdy.com/tarsnap/styles.png http://static.deliciouslynerdy.com/tarsnap/styles.png
- cperciva 13y agoThat's certainly an option. Whether that's the best option, I have no idea until I see what people come up with. :-) But someone is going to get $500 (or $500 minus 99designs' cut), even if it's just someone who typesets "Tarsnap" is a way that I like more than anything else.
- gingerlime 13y agomy thoughts exactly. In my very non-artistic, unimportant opinion, the last thing tarsnap needs is yet another logo with a padlock / key / chain / castle / fortress / shield / guard / dog. These security-related icons are so frequently (ab)used that I'm getting a strong urge not to use any product that relies on them to symboloze its security.
- cperciva 13y agothe last thing tarsnap needs is yet another logo with a padlock / key / chain / castle / fortress / shield / guard / dog. I'm inclined to agree... I'm not saying it's impossible to produce a good logo with one of these, but I'd need to see something really inspiring to put up with a cliche.
- coherentpony 13y agoSlightly off topic, but is there a way to have tarsnap back up to my own server instead of S3?
- cperciva 13y agoNo, the tarsnap client needs the tarsnap server.
- X-Istence 13y agoWill you ever make the tarsnap server available?
- elehack 13y agoIf you want similar backup capabilities to your own server, check out obnam or bup. Both do de-duplicated remote backups with differing tradeoffs and capabilities in security, efficiency, etc.
- srgseg 13y agohttp://www.one-tab.com/web/images/tarsnap.png http://www.one-tab.com/web/images/tarsnap.png A castle and medieval font to convey security and resilience Use of a font with a distinctive R to help it appear as TAR-SNAP and not TARS-NAP A monospaced font with underscores to convey that this for the UNIX command line Subtle gold/silver colors that convey a history of widely acknowledged value and future longevity Font: http://www.fontsquirrel.com/fonts/metamorphous http://www.fontsquirrel.com/fonts/metamorphous (free) Castle: http://3docean.net/item/door-castle/4004680 http://3docean.net/item/door-castle/4004680 ($32 licence required) Please feel free to use/build on this concept if you like it, I waive my rights to this logo design.
- ape4 13y agoNot bad. I think that castle is somewhat busy for a logo.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- weaksauce 13y agoMaybe just the silhouette would work.
- tptacek 13y agoEvery time I hear the name "Tarsnap" I think of the long skinny dragons on heraldic crests, so I'm with you thematically. I think it's a bad idea to use a novelty display typeface for the name. Also, that typeface looks like something from a 1990s Front Line Assembly album. Also, any typeface you pick better mesh well with Times New Roman, because Colin can be trusted to set type in that. The castle will be hard to reproduce at different sizes, won't work at all in black and white, and is effectively clip art.
- srgseg 13y agoBtw the castle source is a 3D model, so this logo can be scaled infinitely.
- AnotherDesigner 13y agoI've wrote about this a few times on HN before. You guys like to downvote me every time I do but here we go again ... Good designers, the ones you want if this is important to you, don't do contests. We have families to feed and bills to pay. "Winning" a popularity contest, not based on substance but instead on style, doesn't allow us to support ourself and our families doing our work. So, who are the designers doing these contests? Well, besides the large number of completely untrained laypeople, it's mostly students wanting beer money and portfolio pieces. And lets face it, most designers need many years beyond school before they're anything approaching "good" at their craft. Those years are spent doing grunt work with increasing amounts of responsibility under senior designers, art directors, creative directors, whatever. My second point about that is how rare it is to win a contest. Designers know that they're often designing blind here. They could spend all the time in the world creating the perfect brand and the client could choose something else because they don't like the color blue or they're scared of clown logos or whatever. Point is, the client is often hardly objective in these situations and the designers know this. What does this mean in practicality? They are going to put as little effort as possible in to this because the chances of reward are small. Personally, I'd love to see the average amount of time spent on these logo entries. I bet most of them are well under 10 minutes. Legal issues. I'll skim here because I don't have my links handy but most of these contest websites have been caught with stolen logos in their submissions. Companies have been sued for using these logos from contest websites costing them thousands of dollars they didn't expect. It happens and when the "designer" is some anonymous guy across the world, you have no recourse but to pay the fees, lawyer fees and then pay to do your logo all over again. Not to mention the embarrassment to your company when this happens. This stuff is very, very rare for clients working with designers face-to-face. Lastly, when you're missing the face-to-face collaboration between designer and client, you're also missing most of what makes design "design", instead of art. The research as well as most of the creative process tends to go missing. The designer starts to view the client as the ones to design for instead of the "user" and as a result, the logo/brand/whatever becomes less effective. And you know what? A lot of important questions go missing ... like what are your plans for the future? What is your strategy to deal with your competitors? Even simple things like "am I making the logo for the company, the product or both" ... changes in company strategy are rarely mentioned in logo contests and this could be the most important question in the world. Logos need to be adaptable to company strategy and that strategy needs to be talking out between company and designer. Often NDAs are signed beforehand, good luck doing that with on a contest.
- tvanantwerp 13y agoBy using a contest format and only offering $500 to the winner, you're significantly limiting the talent pool of designers. Designers who are good--and know that they are--probably wouldn't design a logo for a guaranteed $500, much less for an effectively random chance of payment. Maybe you don't really care if it's a very good logo, or if you're collaborating with a professional who can walk you through the process of discovering what you want. (You do want something, trust me--you just won't know it for sure until you start rejecting the things you don't want.) And that's fine--it's your choice. If your business is doing fine without an awesome logo or a slick brand, then good job! But if you really do want something professional, something that can be built out into a bigger brand, and something that someone put a lot of thought into, then this is the wrong way to go. I wouldn't hold a contest for $500 for a developer to write a piece of code for me. Why would I do it for a logo?
- niels_olson 13y agoBeastie leaning an elbow on a treasure chest, looking cool, as though it were a bar. Cool like he's taken down marauding hordes with his bare hands so keeping you away from that box isn't even a thing.
- cperciva 13y agoCan't do it -- beastie is trademarked, and Kirk only licenses it for BSD things.
- niels_olson 13y agoThen a turtle or a sloth.
- nilved 13y agoNothing on tarsnap.com will load for me in Luakit (WebKit) on Arch Linux. Has anybody else had this problem?
- cperciva 13y agoThis is the first I've heard of any problems... please let me know if you figure out what's breaking for you.
- jasonkester 13y agoI've said it before and I'm saying it again: It needs to be a parsnip. That's what springs to mind when you hear the name of your company, so that's what you need for a logo. Here are a few options: https://www.google.com/search?q=parsnip https://www.google.com/search?q=parsnip
- tptacek 13y agoI think a parsnip would also be an awesome logo. Before you discount it, remember that Sourcefire has a goofy looking cartoon pig.
- eps 13y agoYeah, but snout is a great concept for something that involves sniffing. Parsnip on the other hand just goes well with pancetta.
- eropple 13y agoTarsnap: for secure recipe storage.
- socksy 13y agoSo something like this, but less shit: http://i.imgur.com/30lVuJk.png http://i.imgur.com/30lVuJk.png
- tptacek 13y agoI like it! I came up with this: http://twitter.com/tqbf/status/384037360570089472/photo/1 http://twitter.com/tqbf/status/384037360570089472/photo/1 (I'd have used FF Scala). Vote parsnip!
- nimble 13y agoThat's funny. The first thing that came to my mind was turnips. Maybe there should be a parsnip and a turnips in the logo. Maybe a parsnip pointing down between two turnips, in a T formation.
- 6ren 13y agoOn the topic of brand, I always read "tarsnap" as "tarsnip" - like a parsnip. I think I get the name (unix `tar` plus a snapshot or securely locked in). It's not lack of familiarity - I've known about it for years, and even have an account. I doubt you're keen on a name change, but "tarlock" would avoid this. Or... a parsnip as a logo. EDIT how bizarre! The instant I commented this, jasonkester made the same suggestion. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6462378 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6462378
- lazugod 13y agoAn asterisk encased in amber.
- eps 13y ago"Design contest" to a designer is what "prototype me my facebook idea" to a programmer. You will be laughed out of the room by professional designers at best, so what you will end up with a clipart logo based on a ripped concept done by someone who has zero idea of what tarsnap is (but who really needs your 500 bucks). Do the right thing, Colin, call this thing off, take an hour to go through logopond and dribbble and email a dozen of guys you like. $500 is a good budget to get a good logo. EDIT - alternatively, just pick a good sans font (something that you personally like and that matches well what you think tarsnap is about - simplicity, clarity, reliability, etc.), take a semibold or bold weight, type "tarsnip" in lowercase letters, kern it tightly and you got yourself a clean and concise wordmark.
- anologwintermut 13y agoAnd yet I bet he will get results and they will look good enough, even if you and everyone else who considers themselves a designer laughs at him. He can actually judge the logos he gets and choose the best one (or potentially non at all). Designs don't have anything close to a monopoly on good(enough) taste. Evaluating the quality of a code base, on the other hand, requires close to enough skill that you probably could write it your self. It's not analogous.
- neilk 13y agoDid a sketch of an idea here: https://github.com/neilk/tarsnap-logo/blob/master/tarsnap.png https://github.com/neilk/tarsnap-logo/blob/master/tarsnap.pn... I wanted to get away from castles and locks and such. You can check out the README if you want to know what my thought process was, but it should be distinctive and appealing without an explanation.
- jyap 13y agoI quite like it. Note that the font is not free. From the fine print: Use by more than 25 Users, or equivalent Website Visitors, is a breach of this Free Licence Agreement, and instead requires a commercial licence.
- neilk 13y agoThanks. About the license - you are correct. I was under the impression this font was already distributed via Google Fonts, but I was wrong. It's a very nice font, and just costs $67.00. But it could also be swapped for a font with a less restrictive license.
- bambax 13y agoNothing in the brief says the font has to be free...?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- daviddaviddavid 13y agoHow about snapping fingers? Something like: http://mobiusband.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/06/finger_snap.jpg http://mobiusband.com/blog/wp-content/uploads/2008/06/finger... But less detailed and with something that indicates noise emanating from the fingers. Sorry for being too lazy to take a stab at implementing the idea.
- sgt 13y agoHere's my proposal, very simplistic and based on the inconsolata font (which is licensed under an Open Font license). Original artwork is SVG. http://imgur.com/SVOZTC6 http://imgur.com/SVOZTC6
- noir_lord 13y agohttp://i.imgur.com/UP5d3gH.png http://i.imgur.com/UP5d3gH.png edit: http://imgur.com/k6elBCU http://imgur.com/k6elBCU with masthead Not a professional designer but I like mucking around in inkscape and it was a fun way to avoid work.
- dchest 13y agoTARSNiP? :) (I quite like it, but if you replace that keyhole with a simple "A", it would be much better.)
- selmnoo 13y agoOh Gosh, that was all done in Inkspace? Pretty impressive, I'll have to check that program out.
- noir_lord 13y agoYep entirely in inkcsape. It's a fantastic program even to a developer type like me, it also has really really good PDF import which is useful sometimes :).
- da_n 13y agoHere is the idea I submitted, uses Deja Vu monospace for the font. The shape is a bolt, and I am trying to go for the idea of industrial strength and security. http://dev.bitmono.com/tarsnap/tarsnap.png http://dev.bitmono.com/tarsnap/tarsnap.png
- graue 13y agoThis one is my favorite so far :) Very sleek. But I wish it distinguished "tar" and "snap" to give a subtle cue as to pronunciation. What if the "tar" part were set in a slightly heavier weight?
- da_n 13y agoThanks and an interesting idea, I can see where you're coming from. I have tried it with a bolder font on the tar, it does hint more as to how to pronounce it. http://dev.bitmono.com/tarsnap/tarsnap-variation.png http://dev.bitmono.com/tarsnap/tarsnap-variation.png
- da_n 13y agoAnother screenshot showing it on the website, a simple black and white version. http://dev.bitmono.com/tarsnap/tarsnap-website.png http://dev.bitmono.com/tarsnap/tarsnap-website.png PS: Created in Inkscape, font is Deja Vu.
- contextual 13y agoDesign a logo contests are tacky. It reveals a lack of understanding of your own brand and it's bad marketing. Go out and hire a professional graphic designer.
- underdown 13y agoI have used tarsnap for a while now and id be willing to bet this hacker news post will get him more business than a well designed logo. Have you seen the site? It looks like ass. Didnt stop me from trying it great service btw.
- samweinberg 13y agoI'm normally against the idea of spec work, but I think it makes sense for an open source project. People contribute code, sometimes even copy and graphics to open source projects, so what's the problem with crowd-sourcing a logo?
- moonie1 13y agomy take, a bit simple: http://imgur.com/JBnLjgL http://imgur.com/JBnLjgL Font is consolas
- cromulent 13y agoChoose one of these: http://codepoints.net/mathematical_operators http://codepoints.net/mathematical_operators I suggest ⊷ "Image of". http://codepoints.net/U+22B7 http://codepoints.net/U+22B7
- cperciva 13y agoInteresting idea! I think "multiset union: might be the most appropriate: http://codepoints.net/U+228E http://codepoints.net/U+228E
- currywurst 13y agotrue, but the "image of" gives ideas of "two entities related by a link".
- currywurst 13y ago"image of" is just great !! Really scalable figure that can even be used in an e-mail sig :)
- AdamMeghji 13y agoMy version of the logo: http://imgur.com/Laxvw7E http://imgur.com/Laxvw7E The logo is the wheel on a cassette, which is a fun throwback to the tape days, inspired by TAR -> Tape ARchiver.
- cschmidt 13y agoHow about: Tarsnap: a guard dog for your backup data An then your logo is the very stylized face of a bulldog, looking straight on. The word tarsnap is set to the right of the dog face for the full logo. You can use the face by itself for the favicon etc. I think the word 'snap' has a lot of dog connotation to me. A dog snapping at your heals. The dog snapping at the mailman. And a guard dog is a pretty good metaphor for your product. It keeps things safe and protected from the bad guys. Also, to have a 'mascot' like logo fits in with the penguins, devils, ponies, etc. You can make it stylized to project a "serious, reliable" image, rather than cartoon like. If you like my suggestion, take the $500, and hire my favorite designer, tywilkins.com. You get a much better result than me trying my hand. The problem with a $500 budget is you don't have a the time to explore a lot of options. At $100/hour, you just have 5 hours. But that might be enough time to draw an already fleshed out idea.
- ihenriksen 13y agoHave a look at http://logo.designcrowd.com/ http://logo.designcrowd.com/ for logo design crowding, my company did it and is very happy with the result. Don't cost much.
- webehpi 13y agohere's a sketch of a small idea that came to my mind: http://i.imgur.com/ZaIR5yD.png http://i.imgur.com/ZaIR5yD.png ... basic idea was: "box" - not very original, but imho appropriate when thinking of storing things. as illustrated on the right, the form is the intersection of the shapes on the three visible faces of the box. the two in the front make up the "T" and on top is a very minimal "S". i thought of this intersection as a simple visual analogy of encryption. wouldn't consider this a final logo - probably there could be done some more work on the details.