9 ms·
A fascinating contrast to the announcment of Linux: http://www.thelinuxdaily.com/2010/04/the-first-linux-announcement-from-linus-torvalds/ http://www.thelinuxd
by samatman 13y ago
A fascinating contrast to the announcment of Linux:
http://www.thelinuxdaily.com/2010/04/the-first-linux-announcement-from-linus-torvalds/ http://www.thelinuxdaily.com/2010/04/the-first-linux-announc...
RMS starts with a grandiose vision, which (at the time of writing) he hadn't even begun. He then asks for time, money, and equipment, before the end of the first paragraph. The very first thing promised, a kernel, has never been effectively delivered.
Linus starts with a modest disclaimer, then asks for feedback as to what other potential users might want most.
Night and day. Yet, could we have had one without the other?
- sp332 13y agoI think HURD's kernel would have had more pressure to deliver something (instead of endless academic bickering) without a serviceable Linux kernel. And GNU userspace has been pretty good!
- sanderjd 13y agoOr it may have still fallen into endless academic bickering with nothing delivered and the GNU userspace may have therefore failed to take off at all. We'll never know what would have happened!
- polskibus 13y agoGreat contrast. Iterative vs waterfall software life cycle.
- wmf 13y ago...starts with a grandiose vision, which (at the time of writing) he hadn't even begun. He then asks for time, money, and equipment, before the end of the first paragraph. The very first thing promised ... has never been effectively delivered. That sounds like a Kickstarter pitch. RMS was ahead of his time in yet another way.
- dllthomas 13y agoIt'd be amusing if the FSF posted it verbatim to Kickstarter (or a "Free" participant in that space, anyway) now...
- ChuckMcM 13y agoI find it fascinating that RMS made his pronouncement in '83 and Linus in '91 (8 years later). At the time (and I was at Sun at that time) 'GNU' was still pretty much just a concept, all of the effort from 1983 -> 1991 was in C (gcc), binutils, and emacs. USL was on the verge of suing BSDi for their BSD project (AT&T had been lobbing threats at the GNU effort for years, especially their use of the word 'UNIX' in the description of their acronym) Post lawsuit RMS wrote his manifesto and the GPL was born, and the various BSD flavors of UNIX were the only UNIX kernels that had had their software provenance litigated. Into that Linus wrote his entirely new kernel which was 'unix like' but not UNIX at all on the inside (generally user land felt like UNIX because MINIX felt like UNIX). And because Linux had a pretty complete history from birth to present (making tracing software ownership possible) RMS annexed it as the GNU "kernel" trying to get everyone to call it GNU/Linux for a while. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USL_v._BSDi http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/USL_v._BSDi
- dllthomas 13y ago"RMS annexed it as the GNU "kernel" trying to get everyone to call it GNU/Linux for a while." This is not how I remember it. RMS has not, to my knowledge, ever pushed for the Linux kernel to be called GNU/Linux, but for systems running a combination of GNU software and the Linux kernel to be called GNU/Linux.
- ChuckMcM 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU/Linux_naming_controversy http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/GNU/Linux_naming_controversy
- dllthomas 13y agoAt a skim, none of that seems to support your position. Could you quote relevant bits?
- ChuckMcM 13y agoWhen Linus Torvalds was asked in the documentary Revolution OS whether the name "GNU/Linux" was justified, he replied: Well, I think it's justified, but it's justified if you actually make a GNU distribution of Linux ... the same way that I think that "Red Hat Linux" is fine, or "SuSE Linux" or "Debian Linux", because if you actually make your own distribution of Linux, you get to name the thing, but calling Linux in general "GNU Linux" I think is just ridiculous.[34] It came up in the documentary because there had been a huge firestorm over RMS saying everyone should call it GNU/Linux. Various allegations of 'usurpery' etc and generally bad feelings. Linus' counter, which he made in the documentary and I had heard in person at a Usenix conference was that if the GNU project made a distro (and this is still a valid point) where everything in it was free and wanted to call it "GNU/Linux" that would be great, but trying to change the kernel name from Linux to GNU/Linux is just silly (or ridiculous as Linus points out). [34] ^ Moore, J.T.S. (Produced, Written, and Directed) (2001). Revolution OS (DVD).
- brudgers 13y agoThe world of computing had changed a lot in the 8 years between announcements: Consider the number of "Americans Online," the massive drop in the cost of computing power, and the increase in the number of computers in homes and offices between 1983 and 1991. Stallman, a seasoned academic researcher talking to a small community, was quitting his job. Torvaldes was a student finishing his undergraduate degree at a time when Unix was widespread, Usenet had become popular, and computing power was ubiquitous enough that writing a kernel made sense.
- emiliobumachar 13y agoI don't get what computer power has to do with how much sense does it make to write a kernel. (Except for the performance benefits of going bare metal, but that does not apply to a free alternative to an existing kernel.) Please elaborate.
- joezydeco 13y agohttp://sivers.org/zipit http://sivers.org/zipit "Announcing your plans to others satisfies your self-identity just enough that you're less motivated to do the hard work needed." That's not to say Stallman didn't do any work, but I'm wondering if this observation applies here.
- ajross 13y agoConsidering that the same guy then went on to write both emacs and gcc1 from scratch, mostly unassisted, seems to argue against the theory. What I find interesting about RMS isn't that his productivity was suspect, but frankly that it just ended in the late 80's. He still writes code, surely, but there's a big wall in his history where he just decided that the code was there and what the world needed was moral evangelism. That's a fairly alien attitude to most of us, I suspect. I certainly could never have been happy with a pivot like that. More generally the idea that the FSF was just lolling about not getting anything done until Linux landed in their lap is a weird modern fantasy. And ironically it's exactly the kind of thing they tried to treat by publicizing (or "stealing" if you swing that way) the "Linux" brand with the "lignux"/"GNU/Linux" nonsense. They wrote a ton of working code, most of which we're still using today. What they didn't write was Linux.
- joezydeco 13y agoOh please don't get me wrong, Stallman's contributions are immense and shouldn't be ignored. Was the problem just in the different approaches between Stallman and Torvalds? That being: Stallman wanted to create GNU from the outside in (editors, then tools, then compilers, then the kernel) whereas Torvalds went inside-out?
- dllthomas 13y agoI think it boils down to two differences in approach: 1) Linus was more radically open about including others in development of the kernel, and 2) Linus was more focused on "working" than "right" in kernel design. These happened to combine beautifully, as a working kernel meant people using the system and wanting to make it better. Linus also benefited tremendously from having the GNU toolchain and userspace already available.
- gwu78 13y agoLinux met the need of people wanting to run UNIX at home, on a PC. To that market, it became available earlier than BSD by a couple of years. And it was free (save for the cost of a long-running internet connection to download it). Were BSD to have been available at the same time, there might (=would) be no Linux. Linus himself has said he would have just used 386BSD. I'm not sure that demand for running UNIX at home, on a PC existed in 1983. What was the status of the 386 architecture in 1983? And if it's true that the demand for a UNIX to run on a PC was absent in 1983, then it makes RMS's suggestions all the more interesting. As others have said, RMS was as much ahead of his time as he is weird.
- scardine 13y agoThis thread made me nostalgic. I live in Brazil. I remember when I went to the local university in order to grab a 40+ diskette copy of slackware. A few months later I subscribed to a CDROM compilation (can't recall the name, something like imagemagic) that would mail me a 6 CD case containing many of the early distros every couple months - back in the day downloading it was too expensive (things improved a lot but telecommunications here are still very expensive compared to EUA).
- dllthomas 13y agoGiven that I remember when we upgraded from a 286 to a 386, and I was born in 1983, I feel pretty confident the status of the 386 architecture in 1983 was "non-existent". Though certainly there were PCs at that point (wikipedia says original "IBM PC" was an 8086 in 1981, and personal computers predated that). Was GNU even targeting PCs originally, though? I recall that RMS's joke bio (early 80's) said he was recently separated from his PDP, which was a mini-computer.
- gwu78 13y agoYes, non-existent. That's what I was suggesting. As I remember it, a lot happened between 1983 and 1991. I did not own a PC that could run UNIX in '83, but I did in 1991. Perhaps it was the same for Torvalds. No, I don't think RMS's GNU was targetting "PC's", i.e., non-shared computers, in 1983. Few people would have owned them. My point, perhaps missed by others, was that Linux was aimed at a new bit of hardware that many people had acquired by 1991, the 386 PC.