9 ms·
This has been the case for some time and has been getting worse year after year. It is pretty shameful the extent to which the US tries to attach itself to the
by jandrewrogers 13y ago
This has been the case for some time and has been getting worse year after year. It is pretty shameful the extent to which the US tries to attach itself to the income and wealth of people who are not even living in the country solely because they are American citizens. In some cases, compliance with US tax laws (even though not in the US) are in direct conflict with laws in jurisdictions where people actually reside. In essence, a US citizen is indentured to the US state regardless of where they live.
US law should not have jurisdiction beyond the border. It is creating a growing amount of complications for US citizens that are not within US jurisdiction but which can be held criminally liable for not following US laws even when those laws are in conflict with local laws where they actually live. The indifference of the US government to the consequences to US citizens of their overreach is typical these days.
- pekk 13y agoPayment of one's taxes is not the same as, or equivalent to, indentured servitude. Or slavery.
- binarymax 13y agoNo, but it is extortion
- bobwaycott 13y agoNo, it is not.
- ekianjo 13y agoIt is. No matter how you'd like to see it. The State has no legitimacy over your life and your earnings. It did not do anything to deserve it. This misconception comes from "Monarchy by Divine Right" from Old Europe, where it was your duty before God to support your King with your earnings. It has become more and more of an extortion as the amount seized by your rulers far exceeds (in percentage) what was paid during the Middle Ages.
- bobwaycott 13y agoYour grasp of history and political theory is lamentable. No matter how you'd like to see it. The state has legitimacy granted to it by those who organize it and continue to live under its rule until such time as they decide to no longer recognize it, delegitimize its power, and establish a replacement state. But even when this occurs, another state is erected in its place. Taxes have been around so much longer than Old Europe--by about 4000 years. Read some history.
- alexmat 13y agoNot equivalent to, but certainly shares similar characteristics through coerced surrender of the fruits of one's labor.
- foobarbazqux 13y agoLiving inside the state, you wouldn't have those fruits if it weren't for the state. Living outside of the state, tribute of fruits is the fee for belonging to the state. If someone were truly being forced to pay US taxes, they wouldn't be able to renounce their citizenship while living outside of the state. And inside the state, it's like complaining that your parents insist you buy your brother a present with your allowance, or better yet, the money you earned mowing the front lawn. The reason the US economy is so deep and liquid is because the US state is so powerful, and to stay powerful it needs to collect taxes.
- ekianjo 13y ago> Living inside the state, you wouldn't have those fruits if it weren't for the state Nice theory but it's not even like you have a remote possibility to live outside of the State. Every country require you to BELONG to a State. You'd rather look back in History how people were actually able to survive and thrive before advanced State powers even existed. The Human Race was not born with a State and Government to direct themselves. This is all a very recent creation in History. Let's not invert the logic and pretend that without State we would have nothing. This is what Socialism wants you to believe.
- bobwaycott 13y agoOh please. Spare us the shitty history lesson. The state has existed in human history for more than 10,000 years. The survival and thriving of the human race prior to the establishment of states is incomparable to the last 10,000 years--except to say that they evolved, survived, and propagated the species. They did not thrive. The human race was hardly shit before it began establishing states in order to organize, centralize, protect, expand, and make its way in the world. Before that? Humans were nothing. Ten thousand years of history does not qualify as a "recent creation in history" unless you're being really particular about establishing recent on a universal and geological time scale. Without the creation of states, humanity had and left little to nothing behind. It merely existed. You would not be here if it weren't for the creation of the state. This is not in any way, shape, or form what socialism would have anyone believe.
- ekianjo 13y agoYeah, but failure to pay your taxes leads to servitude and slavery in prisons. It's just one step before.
- pixelcort 13y agoDo you have any examples of specific laws that are in direct conflict with laws other places?
- seanmcdirmid 13y agoI live abroad, and US tax laws cause me huge problems...especially since the tax treaty with China is incompletely in a couple of places (e.g. if I go to the US on a biz trip). Let me educate you a bit: > In some cases, compliance with US tax laws (even though not in the US) are in direct conflict with laws in jurisdictions where people actually reside. This is why countries have tax treaties, to work these issues out (though there are some bugs, see above). If you don't earn that much, the ~$95k foreign income tax exemption is also very useful. > In essence, a US citizen is indentured to the US state regardless of where they live. Thankfully, I'm mostly an indentured servant to the CCP and every year I get to write a big fat +/- $0 on my US tax returns. But I'm just a worker bee. > It is creating a growing amount of complications for US citizens that are not within US jurisdiction but which can be held criminally liable for not following US laws even when those laws are in conflict with local laws where they actually live. What are you talking about? The only law I can think of: US citizens are not allowed to participate in corruption (by US law), while some countries require bribes to avoid sending you to jail. Very few laws affect us abroad, the only other ones I can think of relate to child rape and pornagraphy.
- gamblor956 13y agoConsider the taxes (after the very generous $90+k exemption) a fee for services offered to expatriates. You may never use such services, but your fee pays to make those services available if you ever need them. The U.S. Embassy system offers world-class services to U.S. citizens with legal, medical, and (depending on the circumstances) financial problems in foreign countries. They will negotiate your release if you are arrested for foreign crimes. They will work with your health provider if you become gravely sick. They will help you reorder credit cards if you are robbed and even provide you with cash advances or a place to stay.
- Afforess 13y agoAnd hence why more people are renouncing their citizenship. The services are unwanted, the fee ridiculous.
- sanswork 13y agoThe same can be said for every western nation. They don't require taxation of non-residents though.
- seanmcdirmid 13y ago> The U.S. Embassy system offers world-class services to U.S. citizens with ... The embassy explicitly states that they do not offer these services. > They will negotiate your release if you are arrested for foreign crimes. Ha ha! You are joking right? > They will help you reorder credit cards if you are robbed and even provide you with cash advances or a place to stay. They MIGHT call home for you so you can get some cash. But otherwise, don't expect much from the US Embassy beyond expected services, unless your case is exceptional somehow (or maybe if you know Gary Locke personally). The US does offer other services for our taxes; e.g. I got my PhD via NSF grants, basically, so I don't mind paying for that. And keeping the world safe via military (if you think that's a service), or even foreign aid. But its a myth that I pay any US taxes at all, because I don't, I just have to fill out that damn 1040 every year.