5 ms·
People in general, perhaps. But for myself, my biggest problem with AGW is indeed the fact that its predictions have an ever-longer history of not coming true.
by jerf 13y ago
People in general, perhaps. But for myself, my biggest problem with AGW is indeed the fact that its predictions have an ever-longer history of not coming true.
As a person interested in science, I consider this a fatal objection to any theory. AGW is not excepted. Anyone who has the mental gymnastic strength to talk themselves past this problem is merely demonstrating that they are not actually interested in science at this point, as the disparity between theory and fact is pretty clear at this point.
If "the public" are having problems with AGW for the wrong reasons, well, it's hardly the first time the correct conclusion has been reached for the wrong reasons.
- saalweachter 13y agoWhat do you mean by "its predictions have an ever-longer history of not coming true"? Which predictions in particular have disappointed you?
- JackFr 13y agohttp://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2415191/Global-cooling-Arctic-ice-caps-grows-60-global-warming-predictions.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-2415191/Global-cooli...
- anon1385 13y agoThat article is complete bollocks. http://psc.apl.washington.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/schweiger/ice_volume/BPIOMASIceVolumeAnomalyCurrentV2.png http://psc.apl.washington.edu/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/s...
- 300bps 13y agoThat article is complete bollocks. At best, you are exaggerating. Tell me which of the following claims in the article are false: 1) BBC reported in 2007 global warming would leave Arctic ice-free in summer by 2013 2) Almost a million more square miles of ocean covered with ice than in 2012 You said it's complete bollocks so let me know how the two items above are false or kindly admit you were exaggerating which does nobody advocating for AGW any favors. There are obviously serious problems with the article - for example - I thought this part was ridiculous: The Northwest Passage from the Atlantic to the Pacific has remained blocked by pack-ice all year. More than 20 yachts that had planned to sail it have been left ice-bound and a cruise ship attempting the route was forced to turn back. Their apparent surprise of "The Northwest Passage" being blocked as being a major thing is just silly. It was blocked for most of the year until 2009. But I think it's better to point out things like that than to dismiss it as "complete bollocks" which is fairly easily falsifiable which reduces your credibility.
- anon1385 13y agoOh for goodness sake. The article is deliberately misleading. A few nuggets of 'truth' within doesn't change that at all. >1) BBC reported in 2007 global warming would leave Arctic ice-free in summer by 2013 Well that isn't strictly true. The BBC reported that some US scientists had made a prediction that the arctic 'could' be ice free by 2013. Of course the BBC reporting of that was pretty irresponsible, at least in the headline. Maslowski's actual prediction was for a range of years, with 2013 being at the low end and he is quoted in the article[1] saying "It might not be as early as 2013 but it will be soon, much earlier than 2040". For what it's worth I still think his productions will prove closer to reality than the not ice free till after 2040 ones. >2) Almost a million more square miles of ocean covered with ice than in 2012 I will assume that this statistic is correct, but it is still very misleading. That is not a 'recovery' when you look at the longer trend: it doesn't make up for the losses to extent over recent years never mind decades. That is why I linked the above graph to put it into context. An increase from the all time low is hardly surprising at all. So this is an example of a lie of omission: they neglect to put the figure into the wider context. We could also quibble about mentioning only extent and not volume. [1] http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/7139797.stm http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/7139797.stm
- saalweachter 13y agoThe "60% increase" story is mis-reporting regression towards the mean. Long story short is, 2012 was a particularly bad year for arctic sea ice, 2013 was significantly better, but still on the thirty year trend line. http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/capital-weather-gang/wp/2013/09/18/arctic-sea-ice-has-not-recovered-in-7-visuals/ http://www.washingtonpost.com/blogs/capital-weather-gang/wp/...
- 300bps 13y agoOh for goodness sake. The article is deliberately misleading. A few nuggets of 'truth' within doesn't change that at all. So here's the lesson. Say what you mean without exaggeration. Because when you said it's "complete bollocks" what you actually meant was that it was misleading. When you exaggerate like that, it makes it seem like you're pushing an agenda.
- anon1385 13y ago>the fact that its predictions have an ever-longer history of not coming true. Which predictions in particular?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jerf 13y agoThe important ones, basically. It's not 1990 anymore. There have now been many predictions made for times now in the past based on the same climate models being used to predict disaster, and they are now almost uniformly wrong. The Met Office in Britain is one of the clearest. Are they predicting a wet summer for Britain? Brits should buy suntan lotion. Are they predicting a hot, dry summer? Brits should plant something that likes wet, dark conditions. They are the source of one of the models in the IPCC report, and they're predictions for a year or two out are wrong, consistently. And I find the idea that a climate model can't predict a year in advance, consistently, but can be used for 10 or 100 years in advance to be absolutely ludicrous. Utter mathematical illiteracy is required to think that is true of a chaotic system. It remains unclear to me whether climate researchers actually understand that "a chaotic system" is actually a mathematically meaningful statement and not "an excuse for why we were wrong, again". (No sarcasm, it truly remains unclear to me. Chaos theory is a real thing, and I'd really like to think that climate researchers would know a lot about it, but I've only seen faint traces of it, where I expect the terminology to dominate the discourse.) Given the utter failure of these predictions on a year and a decade scale (as I've said before, had the climate scientists said "hey, there's going to be a 15-year plateau because of this and this which will mask the problem but then this is going to happen", I'd be fine with that), I see no reason to believe they'll work on a century scale. At the moment, the most reasonable explanation is that the models used by the IPCC up to this point have been grossly wrong about their positive heating feedback claims, which if you dig, were never really that well substantiated by actual evidence, they have always been modeling choices. In the real science world, those claims are being walked back quite rapidly with a variety of peer reviewed studies providing both evidence of this and potential models for explanations; this has not penetrated to the political portion of the AGW crowd yet. This is probably because the science, to my eyes, is rapidly converging on "global warming is unlikely to be a problem in this century, and may even be a net benefit to humanity". I wouldn't be surprised this is the dominant science consensus in ten years.
- mcv 13y ago> my biggest problem with AGW is indeed the fact that its predictions have an ever-longer history of not coming true. Are you saying that global temperatures aren't rising? Is the arctic icecap not rapidly getting smaller? I believe even the rising sea level is already measurable (though still small at this point). The predictions are coming true in a quite alarming fashion.
- gd1 13y ago>Are you saying that global temperatures aren't rising? They haven't for the last 15 years, so that may be exactly what he is saying. >Is the arctic icecap not rapidly getting smaller? It is, but is the antarctic icecap not rapidly getting larger?
- anon1385 13y ago> is the antarctic icecap not rapidly getting larger? To the best of our knowledge the East Antarctic Ice Sheet is gaining mass[1] due to increased precipitation and the West Antarctic Ice Sheet is losing mass[2] due to acceleration of glaciers. I believe there is also an increase in Antarctic sea ice extent [3]. As far as I know these increases are not enough to offset the reduction in mass in the Arctic but I don't have a comparison to hand. Wait a few days and the IPCC report will probably have a decent summary. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Antarctic_Ice_Sheet#Ice_mass_changes https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/East_Antarctic_Ice_Sheet#Ice_m... [2] http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2012/12/the-heat-is-on-in-west-antarctica/ http://www.realclimate.org/index.php/archives/2012/12/the-he... [3] http://tamino.wordpress.com/2013/03/16/antarctic-sea-ice-gain/ http://tamino.wordpress.com/2013/03/16/antarctic-sea-ice-gai...
- mcv 13y agoI don't see how they could offset reduction of mass in the arctic; they're different systems. Note that loss in sea ice doesn't lead to rising sea levels; it's land ice that matters. If Antarctica indeed has a net gain in land ice, then it would be interesting if that offsets the projected loss in glaciers on Greenland. Also relevant is to what extent it's really long term gain in land ice.
- specialist 13y agoDo you object to climate change in general, or just the anthropocentric portion?
- jerf 13y agoMore the catastrophic portion. Is Man affecting climate? Sure. So are ants. Probably less so. Does Man have a good track record predicting what his effects are? No. Do we currently appear to be on a catastrophic course? No.
- anon1385 13y agoYou specifically said that climate scientists had made predictions that hadn't come true. Now you repeat again that we don't have a good track record. Which predictions in particular are you talking about? How good do our predictions have to be for you to accept them as good enough? What is your evidence for the current course not being catastrophic? How are you defining catastrophic? To the human species? Or to the daily lives of a couple of billion people? Those are quite different, and the first at least isn't seriously being suggested by scientists that I'm aware of.
- jerf 13y agoSee my other reply. And to be honest, as far as I'm concerned one must seek out predictions that have come true, quite selectively. If you randomly sample the ones that have completion dates in the past, they are almost uniformly false. You speak as if you feel yourself in a position of moral authority, but I do not accept the moral authority of people who choose words over the plain science. And there's always the big one... those big curves drawn where temperatures go up, up, up over this entire century, where instead they've stayed flat, flat, flat, and we've fallen out of most of the confidence intervals (and very nearly out of the rest). The spinning on how this really is what we predicted all along is getting quite mind boggling. No, the temperature trend of the last 15 years is never what was predicted. It is merely what actually happened. Goodness help us all if those who think the solar activity level actually sets our temperature on a several-year delay are correct, and the global temperature starts going down. How will that be spun, I wonder? (Though that is merely one possibly theory. At this point I consider the late-1990s catastrophic model that still dominates the discourse plainly false, but it remains rather unclear what is true. I'd still put quite a bit of probability on "the chaotic system is fundamentally unpredictable past a few years" myself. It's been the smart money for the past 20 years and I don't see a lot of reason to move it.)