4 ms·
The "Linux userland"? Really? I wasn't aware Android had a hard dependency on systemd. I'm all for opinionated design, but I hope we don't end up with a "Linux
by e12e 13y ago
The "Linux userland"? Really? I wasn't aware Android had a hard dependency on systemd.
I'm all for opinionated design, but I hope we don't end up with a "Linux userland" in the sense we have a GNU userland -- that would be going towards too tight coupling of things that really shouldn't be coupled at all.
- kazagistar 13y agoIts not about tight coupling. It is about one system supporting a feature, and the other "alternatives" not supporting it. So the choice becomes one between better software and compatibility. "Choice" just means you are stuck coding for the lowest common denominator.
- bitwize 13y agoTight coupling is the whole point. The Unix Philosophy is based on building well-factored parts that fit together with small, knowable interfaces (e.g., simple text protocols communicating over pipes or sockets). Yet, the success of Mac OS X as the only relevant Unix on the desktop goes to show that whole, well-integrated systems are much more valuable than well-factored parts. GNU/Linux needs to become a whole, integrated system. A platform for applications, not a framework for parts. Systemd is an essential part of that vision. In short, everybody needs to suck it up because this is how things are done in Linux now.
- dragonwriter 13y ago> the success of Mac OS X as the only relevant Unix on the desktop goes to show that whole, well-integrated systems are much more valuable than well-factored parts. Certainly not as clearly as the success of Linux in the server world shows the opposite. > Linux needs to become a whole, integrated system. If the priority for Linux is to capture a bigger share of the dying desktop market at the expense of the server market, sure. On the server side, the whole "framework for parts assembled ad hoc by a recipe for a task" model is becoming more, not less viable.
- bitwize 13y ago> If the priority for Linux is to capture a bigger share of the dying desktop market at the expense of the server market, sure. RHEL's next release will come with systemd. The server market is not threatened by systemd, and the growth market in personal devices -- mobile -- will benefit from its power-management features. > On the server side, the whole "framework for parts assembled ad hoc by a recipe for a task" model is becoming more, not less viable. systemd units are much easier to write than init scripts.
- dragonwriter 13y agoI perhaps wasn't sufficiently clear; my issue was with the sweeping generalities about what MacOS X supposedly proved in terms of Linux needing to become that kind of integrated OS rather than a framework assembled from parts, not the specific idea that broad generality was offered to support about systemd (I don't really have a strong opinion on systemd either way.)