4 ms·
We don't need to give "due process" to enemy soldiers before we kill them. How are al-Qaeda members different? If you're at war, you should only target enemy f
by grey-area 13y ago
We don't need to give "due process" to enemy soldiers before we kill them. How are al-Qaeda members different?
If you're at war, you should only target enemy fighters in uniform, not civilians, and try to minimise civilian casualties at all times.
If you're not at war, people should be tried in open court and found guilty of crimes if they have committed them, not assassinated on suspicion, along with civilians nearby.
If you're proclaiming total war against anyone who is on a secret list, and leaving the power to decide in the hands of Obama, you are proclaiming the US a dictatorship where life and death rests in the hands of one man, and there is no recourse to justice before or after the killing. In the wrong hands and combined with total information awareness this would be a terrible power.
- gadders 13y agoIf the enemy refuses to wear a uniform? Do we just let them go?
- grey-area 13y agoIf the enemy refuses to wear a uniform, and blends in with the civilian population, are we at war at all? Terrorism is very difficult to counter, but I'd argue the way to do so is not to accept battle on the terrorists' terms - war amongst the people does not tend to end well for the government responsible.
- dingaling 13y ago> If the enemy refuses to wear a uniform? Do we just let them go? The British policy on this, under which I grew up, was to treat such a scenario as a 'police action' wherein military presence was used to bring the situation to a point where the police could intervene. Certainly troops operated checkpoints, patrolled streets and operated intelligence gathering, but all actions were in assistance to the constabulary. The ROE for line soldiers were extremely strict and even firing in self-defence was not automatically assured. A soldier could pin a suspect on the pavement but only a police officer could arrest him.
- gadders 13y agoAnd if the terrorists are in a country which does not want to launch military action against the bad actors within their borders?
- lmm 13y agoThen either you go to war - actual, declared war - with that country, or you put up with it.
- jryle70 13y agoSo what do you think if US wages war against Iran, Syria, Pakistan, Egypt, Somalia, Sudan, Lybia, at the same time? As a US citizen, do you approve of that? How about the US public?
- lmm 13y agoOk, I was simplifying; diplomatic sanctions are an option, and, I think, the appropriate way to handle the case of "this country is generally ok apart from harbouring some international criminals.