9 ms·
Fake Reviewers Snared in NY Attorney General Yogurt Sting
- gcb0 13y agogreat. What's next? Tax money used to secure all of slashdot first posts to prevent trolls from getting it?
- conover 13y agoSo you're saying that government shouldn't attempt to identify and prosecute those who it believes "breached laws against false advertising and deceptive business practices."
- trysomething 13y agoYeah, in this case it should be Yelp's job to filter out fake reviews. Yelp should foot the bill for operations like this or for engineers to write better algorithms.
- avree 13y agoSo, if I run a car rental company, and people start stealing cars, is it my job to recover the cars or filter out the criminals? After all, I could write algorithms that used more and more information to determine criminality.
- ceejayoz 13y ago> So, if I run a car rental company, and people start stealing cars, is it my job to recover the cars or filter out the criminals? I'm pretty sure they do credit checks and run my license.
- aliakbarkhan 13y agoHow do you propose to credit check car thieves? Ultra effective car alarms that only deactivate for people with good credit?
- trippy_biscuits 13y agoAre you saying that you'd ignore all financial incentive to protect your assets and rely on the government to protect you? We already know how well that works. It doesn't! I'm not against the AG investigating and prosecuting fraud, but I certainly don't want to set a precedent based on entrapment or put more ink on the books to grow bureaucracy.
- gcb0 13y agopretty much you are. You would have to insure your cars against theft. If you get robbed a lot, your insurance company would raise your premium. it already works like your hypothetical scenario, so what's your point? edit: an analogy from your point to what happened would be the government setting up a fake car rental and calling up thieves to agree to rent and steal their cars.
- untog 13y agoSo you're saying we should rely on a private company for law enforcement? Presumably gun manufacturers should also be responsible for tracking down people who use their products illegally?
- Shivetya 13y agoany idea what this program cost? Does the 350k fully cover the costs?
- dnautics 13y agoisn't this yelp's job to police? Why is taxpayer money going into propping up yelp's reputation?
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- jlgreco 13y agoIt's not like they are going after these reviewers instead of people with drugs.
- chimeracoder 13y agoThat's too bad. I'd much rather the NY AG spend my taxpayer dollars by prosecuting fraud instead of fighting the war on drugs.
- tzs 13y ago> Why is taxpayer money going into propping up yelp's reputation? It isn't. It's going into catching people violating various criminal laws against fraud. That stopping such people happens to help Yelp is a side-effect.
- argumentum 13y agoI'm not sure how the reviewers themselves violated laws against fraud. If anything, the businesses that paid for the reviews violated said laws.
- criley2 13y agoBecause fraud means to be deceptive towards someone else for personal gain. I guess you could argue like a racketeering effect-- who is guilty of murder, the man who pulls the trigger or the mafia boss who orders the hit? (Spoiler: both). In fact, I'd love to see a State Attorney General use RICO to target not just a group of reviewers who are defrauding businesses, but the entire supply chain by which they get their targets and get paid for their illegal behavior.
- nostromo 13y agoIt makes much more sense for Yelp to go after spammers, in the same way Google does. Not the NY Attorney General.
- chimeracoder 13y agoThese aren't (just) spammers, though - they are people committing fraud against New York State businesses[0]. They just happen to be committing fraud on an online platform. [0] Or rather, New York State businesses themselves committing fraud (if they are the ones writing fake positive reviews about themselves) (Edited to reflect argumentum's reply),
- argumentum 13y agoCan you explain how the reviewers are committing fraud? If anything, it's the businesses falsely advertising.
- mynewwork 13y agoIf McDonalds runs an advertisement claiming Burger King serves horse meat, that's illegal. If McDonalds pays a company to post a review posing as a customer that says Burger King served them horse meat, how is that any different?
- chris_mahan 13y agoI'm French, I've had (and loved) horse meat. I guarantee Burger King is not serving horse meat. Edit to reflect responder: I do get the point.
- chris_wot 13y agoYou miss the point?
- dragonwriter 13y agoThe reviewers at issue in this case were largely SEO companies (or their individual paid agents) acting on behalf of the businesses (real or fake) involved, or the actual companies involved (or their employees). And false advertising (and deceptive business practices) were the actual charges.
- Zikes 13y agoAlright, so New York's relevant offices get a lot of complaints of false advertising in various online forums in the form of fake reviews. Obviously this is bad for legitimate businesses in the area, because their reputation could be negatively affected to a fairly significant degree, especially if the practice is allowed to continue. So what should they do about it? It's a matter of fraud, it just happens to take place online, and probably in more places than just yelp.com. Since it's fraud, they have an obligation to investigate and prosecute it, and a sting operation like this is probably one of the most effective means of doing so. This is New York saying they care about their businesses, and that they're willing to take action to protect them. I mean, would you want to open a yogurt shop in New York if you knew it'd have to shut down in less than a year because of a bunch of false negative reviews online? What would be the potential economic impact of that hostile sort of environment?
- downandout 13y agoWho is the government to say that a particular review isn't authentic? Reviews are subjective. While it is in fact a difficult argument to say that a review for the fake business used in this entrapment operation is authentic, perhaps I love or don't love the name or location of the business, and give it a rating based upon that. Maybe I own a yogurt shop, and automatically hate all of my competitors. No one can tell me that I can't like or dislike any business for any reason, whether I have visited them or not. There is a reason that 100% of these cases were settled....these cases would have been laughed out of a courtroom on constitutional grounds. Personally, I would have forced them to take it to court, but most businesses don't want the headache.
- reustle 13y ago> Who is the government to say that a particular review isn't authentic? They set up a fake shop, didn't you read the article?
- downandout 13y agoYes....you apparently didn't read my entire comment. "While it is in fact a difficult argument to say that a review for the fake business used in this entrapment operation is authentic, perhaps I love or don't love the name or location of the business, and give it a rating based upon that."
- taopao 13y agoOh noes, think of the growth hackings!
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- alexqgb 13y agoEDIT: I see the idiocy to which this reply was aimed as been removed. Mmmm, yum. Delicious back-alley "underground" yoghurt. "Please, don't mind the urine smell on the way to the counter and no, of course we don't have any Botulism today." And this right here is where the anarcho-libertarian "logic" breaks down. In reality there is no "just go underground" where "just" means "do something with trivial or non-existant transaction costs." In reality, there are a whole host of problems that come with running a food service business that's outside the purview of the health authorities. First and foremost, you're also going to be outside the purview of a lot of potential customers. And the few who can see you well enough to find you are also going to see a whole host of warning signs before they reach the point of sale. Unless you're selling something so addictive that people will risk their lives for a fix, good luck running a viable business on the few who are foolish enough to hand over their cash. Remember, the point of regulations is not to eluiminate dangerous, fraudulemt, or otherwise undesireable conduct entierly. It's to drive up the cost to the point where the number of people doing whatever they're doing is low enough for the hazard the represent to fall below some commonly agreed-upon threshold. Obviously, the toxic idiots who find themselves getting marginalized by effective government regulations would love to get back into the mainstream. These are not people governed by any internal moral compass. They're fundamentally sociopathic, and they'll push back in whatever way they can. One of their favorite tactics is a form of psychological warfare where they try to convince people that efforts to police them are a waste of resources since they'll never be 100% successful, so honestly, why bother at all? Gun nuts use a variation on this tactic wherein they point out that some aspect of the mass shooting du jour means that some generally sensible legislation wouldn't have stopped that particular killing. And therefore, they conclude, all legislation is pointless and doomed to failure, so again, why bother? Rejecting the obviously absurd assertion that anything not 100% effective is 100% ineffective, it's clear that efforts to limit abusively self-serving conduct can make themselves worth the expense, even with a success rate that's well below perfect. It's not about each an every incident, after all. It's about creating conditions in which mayhem and death are statistically far less likely. Statistics 101. So yes, there will still be problems in even the best regulated environment. But they will be fewer and further between than they would be in some lawless free-for-all that only the staunchest libertarians would see as paradise.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- aurelius83 13y agoI find it very worrisome that the government views online anonymous postings on a private website as advertisement to be enforced by public agencies. But, I guess it's no different than the government regulating anonymous online speech about stocks.
- Zikes 13y agoSpeech is free right up to where it interferes with others' freedoms and liberties, which is why we have slander/libel laws, etc. The medium doesn't exempt people from those laws.
- thaumasiotes 13y agoBut false positive reviews are extremely unlikely to fall afoul of libel laws...
- dragonwriter 13y ago> I find it very worrisome that the government views online anonymous postings on a private website as advertisement to be enforced by public agencies. Why? I mean, in which of the cases where they were specifically treated as "advertisement" were the facts of case such that the postings should not have been viewed as an advertisement? Why, particularly, would any of these facts make an advertisement any less an advertisement, or any less subject to any regulation that applies to advertisement generally? 1. The fact that the source is concealed ("anonymous postings") 2. The fact that it is published via a privately owned channel ("private") 3. The fact that it is published on the web ("website")
- aurelius83 13y agoI find it very worrisome that the government views online anonymous postings on a private website as advertisement to be enforced by public agencies. But, I guess it's no different than the government regulating anonymous online speech about stocks.
- aurelius83 13y agoI find it very worrisome that the government views online anonymous postings on a private website as advertisement to be enforced by public agencies. But, I guess it's no different than the government regulating anonymous online speech about stocks.
- aurelius83 13y agoI find it very worrisome that the government views online anonymous postings on a private website as advertisement to be enforced by public agencies. But, I guess it's no different than the government regulating anonymous online speech about stocks.
- downandout 13y agoThis operation seems like a complete waste of taxpayer money. While paid reviews are a violation of Yelp's TOS, since most businesses didn't add themselves to Yelp (they were added by reviewers or Yelp itself), they have not agreed to and are not subject to those TOS. Some incredibly blatant actions may qualify as fraud, but the bar for avoiding such accusations is very low. Businesses can simply ask paid reviewers not to post inauthentic reviews, and they have met their burden.
- criley2 13y agoLying about a business in a public forum with the sole motivation of harming the business... that's fraud. "fraud is intentional deception made for personal gain or to damage another individual;" Not a legal definition, but a good enough definition for now. I think it's a decent use of taxpayer money to help combat the defrauding of businesses in the area. If they were printing these fake derogatory reviews in local newspapers or on local TV, would your opinion of the fraud change?
- r00fus 13y agoThe NYT article shouldn't say "fake" but "fraudulent", as that's the crux of the issue. I can put up a fake review, but if it's with the intent to harm, it's fraudulent. Now what do we do about fake reviews that are puff pieces intended to goose ratings?
- chris_mahan 13y agoI agree. There's a difference between review one: "I tried their yogurt, and it tastes like New Jersey Shore Sand", and review two: "Go to my_shOes.cOm and get great sneakers for chEap." One is obviously lousy to the business. The other, just SEO.
- CamperBob2 13y agoI'm of two minds about it. It doesn't seem like a solid legal argument for the state to make on a criminal-law basis -- who's to say that bogus reviews aren't "free speech?" -- and I don't see how they have standing to bring civil actions. Perhaps an attorney could comment to fill in some of the many blanks left by the NYT article? The other side of the coin is that from the perspective of the victimized businesses, fake reviews are equivalent to any other form of organized crime. Same effect, in that the business (metaphorically) burns down if you don't pay off any of the numerous entitles laying claim to your customers' mindshare... entities among whom Yelp itself is the least shady. There's got to be some way to stop this behavior before we all live and work under the online version of the Russian mafia.
- o0-0o 13y agoDoes anyone have a list of the names of the companies?
- lawnchair_larry 13y agoVery happy to see this. These companies are shameless, and there needs to be a deterrent against businesses trying to deceive consumers doing research. This has nothing to do with free speech.
- 205guy 13y agoWow, the comments here are a story in-and-of themselves. I have to wonder if the people questioning state involvement are not astro-turfing here as well (in defense of the companies that got snared). To make a bad pun, it's not free speech if you have to be paid for it. The state will go after those who pay or receive money for what they say.
- anotherbadlogin 13y ago"Astro-turfing"? Maybe they're just non-wording.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- nlh 13y agoHere's a question, based on an experience. Two scenarios: A) A company posts fake reviews about itself, through whatever means. Consumers get a false representation of the business. The company and its associates are the bad guys, Yelp is the good guy. B) Yelp's filters hide most positive reviews about a company, leaving only negative reviews. All reviews are legitimate. Consumers get an equally false impression of the business. Yelp is the bad guy. Why is A) illegal and deserving of state interference, but B) is totally legal and continues today?
- RP_Joe 13y agoSo now its a crime to post false info on the Internet?