10 ms·
WikiLeaks Leaks 'Fifth Estate' Screenplay
- ihuman 13y agoJudging by the recaps of the film, I'm not surprised about what I see. The film is based off of books that make WifiLeaks look bad, so its not surprising that the movie does too. Also, Disney and Dreamworks gain nothing by making a movie that makes WikiLeaks look good; they gain attention by creating a movie that creates drama around it, like what is going on now.
- johnbm 13y agoAnd big surprise, NYTimes makes it seem like the problem is with Assange not being happy how he's portrayed, rather than it being based on discredited sources, putting people in key roles that never happened, and ignoring that it was a careless and clueless Guardian journalist (David Leigh) who leaked the key to the unredacted Cablegate files in his book, not Wikileaks. Look around and see if you can find that last little tidbit mentioned any time some journalist writes Wikileaks put people in danger.
- knowaveragejoe 13y agoIf that's true, it should be well documented somewhere for reference. Please share a source if you get a chance.
- dllthomas 13y agoThat is vaguely what I recall from my loose following of things, and wikipedia seems to more or less agree. The relevant citation is: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_diplomatic_cables_leak#cite_note-Greenwald2Sep2011-6 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/United_States_diplomatic_cables...
- acqq 13y agohttp://unspecified.wordpress.com/2011/09/03/wikileaks-password-leak-faq/ http://unspecified.wordpress.com/2011/09/03/wikileaks-passwo... A journalist leaked the password given to him by Wikileaks by publishing it in his book. At that moment the encrypted file was already all over the internet.
- pessimizer 13y agohttp://nigelparry.com/news/guardian-david-leigh-cablegate.shtml http://nigelparry.com/news/guardian-david-leigh-cablegate.sh... This is the full account.
- eli 13y agoI don't think it's reasonable to expect a movie about Wikileaks to be any more accurate than, say, a movie about Facebook. Yeah, they took some liberties and made a nice, tidy narrative. It's a movie. And whose fault is it that the journalist apparently didn't know a password he was given for files for his own use was being reused to secure a public insurance file? It does not speak well to their stewardship of sensitive documents that they were giving out that password to people who are "careless and clueless."
- pessimizer 13y ago>I don't think it's reasonable to expect a movie about Wikileaks to be any more accurate than, say, a movie about Facebook. That's why I have a problem with movies like The Social Network and Zero Dark Thirty. It's fine to composite, or eliminate less significant details, or even play some details up for their metaphorical significance. My problem is with movies containing counterfactual plot points that change the entire moral calculus of the events being depicted, often in favor of the status quo. It's as of you made a movie about the Iraq War, and based a key scene around how they find a bunch of WMD in the desert. Or depict Martin Luther King on the phone to his handlers in the USSR, or delivering "I Have a Dream" at a rally against racial quotas in hiring. These movies become history.
- stefantalpalaru 13y ago> the journalist apparently didn't know a password he was given for files for his own use was being reused to secure a public insurance file I think he got the file from bittorrent so he knew it was public. Not making an ecrypted archive just for him with a new password was Assange's mistake, no doubt about it, but publishing that password in a book takes it to a whole new level.
- mpyne 13y agoThe fact that Bittorrent is used for distribution doesn't automatically make a file fully public. But as far as I know the file was provided to the journalist in the equivalent of an FTP /pub folder, not via Bittorrent. But Assange never removed the file afterwards and it eventually got backed up and publically-trawled afterwards somehow.
- tzs 13y agoAssange is not blameless in the leak of the unredacted cables. The procedure he picked for handing a copy of the data to Leigh was terrible. Proper use of public key cryptography could have made it much safer.
- eliasmacpherson 13y agoGiven cables were leaked, assuming it was totally Assange's fault, and sources were revealed. Were any revealed sources harmed? If so, would it not have come out at the Manning trial? It's the same Disney who made racist propoganda during WW2, it's surprisingly blatant if it comes out like WikiLeaks reading of the script signals it will.
- tptacek 13y ago(a) The Taliban literally did a press release that the NYT ran saying they were using the documents to find informers. (b) The Taliban are known --- famous for, in fact --- operating death squads; it is almost their whole M.O. Common sense applies here as well. (c) No media service and no police force in the world has meaningful penetration into society in places like Ghazni, Helmand, or Paktika province. So you should be aware that you've set an unrealistic bar here. It's probably not relevant to the case here but I think also worth knowing: Assange told the chief investigative editor at the Guardian, in a room full of named reporters, none of whom appear to have contradicted the Guardian editor's story, that Assange believes murdered informants were collaborators who got what they deserved.
- EliAndrewC 13y agoStrong agree that those documents had the potential to lead to the murder of informants - this alone convinces me that the mass release of those cables without any edits or redactions was irresponsible. However, I've previously assumed that we (incredibly) made it through the aftermath of the leaks without any of those potential murders taking place, for the same reasons listed in the grandparent comment; the media would have reported it, and the government would have surely cited it at Chelsea Manning's trial. So I'm skeptical but intrigued by your assertion that informants may have been murdered, but that there's be no way for us to know whether this had happened. My (uninformed) expectation would be that we WOULD know, since: - we had (previously but not anymore?) informants in those places in the first place - such murders would be (easily?) dicoverable after the fact, especially since the Taliban would have motive to tout them - the government had a strong motive for wanting to portray the leaks in the worst possible light, and therefore would want to discover and verify such murders Your observation that we have very little knowledge of these places does make me more uncertain about whether any murders occurred, but at this point we're far enough out from the leaks that the burden of proof lies with anyone asserting that murders probably DID take place, for the reasons listed above. (As opposed to the question of whether the leaks were irresponsible in the first place, which for me is a resounding yes even if we somehow made it through without any murders.)
- clicks 13y agoI was made aware of how much propaganda there is in Western movies by a comment here on HN: "The major exception here is the Department of Defense, which has an ‘open’ but barely publicized relationship with Tinsel Town, whereby, in exchange for advice, men and invaluable equipment, such as aircraft carriers and helicopters, the Pentagon routinely demands flattering script alterations." http://www.globalresearch.ca/lights-camera-covert-action-the-deep-politics-of-hollywood/11921 http://www.globalresearch.ca/lights-camera-covert-action-the... http://original.antiwar.com/sean-a-mcelwee/2013/04/28/propaganda-and-censorship-the-hollywood-industrial-complex/ http://original.antiwar.com/sean-a-mcelwee/2013/04/28/propag... Do you recall any big American movie in the last decade (or even more) that painted America's military in a non-positive light? I don't. I do remember Zero Dark Thirty (if you watch carefully you'll see how they basically say that torture works great in getting prisoners to hand over information), I do remember The Hurt Locker, and a whole list of other movies, Iron Man and Captain America being the latest examples (Iron Man originally used to be about fighting communism, now it is about fighting terrorism). Hollywood output is a very valuable export to the world in this way of framing America's image in the world, and I'm betting America is becoming even more aware of this and will put even more resources to this effort in coming time. To me, truly the most amazing thing about this is that pretty much no-one knows about this! Tell someone that there's a lot of American propaganda in Western movies and they'll take you for a conspiracy nut.
- adamors 13y agoThere was a documentary about Apolcalypse Now and I think it was Coppola who said that they had to remove footage which showed US soldiers desecrating vietnamese corpses (even though these shots were based on actual photographs/eye witness accounts) because otherwise the US government refused to give them helicopters and whatnot.
- cleverjake 13y agohearts of darkness? http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0102015/?ref_=fn_al_tt_4 http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0102015/?ref_=fn_al_tt_4
- mike-cardwell 13y ago
- AsymetricCom 13y agoI thought 300 was better
- noname123 13y agoSo is it art imitates life which is imitated by life again?
- mylorse 13y agoFor those looking for the source: http://wikileaks.org/IMG/html/wikileaks-dreamworks-memo.html http://wikileaks.org/IMG/html/wikileaks-dreamworks-memo.html It might change, with all MiTM that occurs on the domain.
- zerooneinfinity 13y agoIt seems like any inaccurate portrayal of somebodies life would be slander. How do people get around this? If I wanted to make a movie about Barrack Obama and say he was apart of terrorists groups would that be legal? Isn't this the reason movies have to say "Any characters in this movie were purely fictional etc."
- danso 13y agoNo...in America, the standard to prove defamation against a public figure is very high: the plaintiff has to prove actual malice (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Actual_malice http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Actual_malice) was used in publication. I imagine the standard for a movie, which besides using the "based on real events" disclaimer, has the additional benefit of artistic license on its side.
- zerooneinfinity 13y agoAh I see, so if a classified report/email was released that said, "Make this movie, and make sure Assange look bad" then he would have grounds to sue?
- danso 13y agoI just watched the trailer for the movie (http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZT1wb8_tcYU http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ZT1wb8_tcYU)...without knowing WikiLeaks' and Assange's distaste for the movie, it's hard to see the trailer as anything but positive for Assange. No mention of the sexual assault charges, but instead, a prominent focus on the early revelations that earned Assange the sympathy of many: leaking the footage of the U.S. Apache attack (http://www.collateralmurder.com/ http://www.collateralmurder.com/) and of internal documents from the Kaupthing Bank (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaupthing_Bank http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kaupthing_Bank).
- jlgreco 13y agoThe purpose of a trailer isn't to convey the message of a movie. The purpose of a trailer is to get you to watch a movie.
- argumentum 13y agoWhat a brilliant (if unintended) publicity stunt for the movie ;) More seriously, I think Assange is acting a bit like Zuckerberg vis a vis The Social Network. All in all, Zuckerberg was the hero of the movie .. he was portrayed as a brilliant hacker and visionary (if flawed) businessman. My feeling is that Assange will be similarly portrayed (except of course replacing "businessman" with "journalist"). If a movie were ever to be made about me, it would feel insulting to be portrayed as flawless. There are no great characters without flaws.
- kbenson 13y agoI think the point is that to some people, having an extremely flattering view of them put forth is less important than having an accurate view. In part, that may be because people assume if their reasoning is exposed then the public would be with them, so that's flattering enough. (Logically, it's not possible the public would always agree, because otherwise we would never have disagreements).
- argumentum 13y agoI think the Social Network, for example, is quite accurate about the most important things (the zeitgeist of how a startup like Facebook comes about .. the energy, the betrayals (both perceived and real), the craziness, the attitude of great founders etc). This is a movie and not a documentary .. for my money I expect the Director to put his creative efforts into making something enjoyable to watch. As long as it's not a blatant fabrication, fact for fact historical accuracy isn't why I'm going to watch this movie. Aaron Sorkin viewed Zuck & co as a vehicle to tell a larger (and more important) story about modern culture .. if The Fifth Estate accomplishes the same, it will be a great movie.
- belorn 13y agoIts a film based on Daniel Domscheit-Berg book. Daniel, the person who covered up potential war crimes out of spite in his falling out with Wikileaks. Beyond the war crime video, he also indiscriminately destroyed leaked documents such as US government's No Fly List, 5 GB of Bank of America leaks, insider information from 20 right-wing organizations and proof of torture and government abuse of a Latin American country. Lets just ignore the sacrifice that people must have done to provide those documents in the first place. DreamWorks and Disney going to glorify this behavior and produce a film baed on Daniel book, and likely make him rich from royalties? Meh.
- trobertson 13y agoThe establishment rewards those who aid the establishment.
- Zigurd 13y agoDaniel Domscheit-Berg's behavior is extremely suspicious. What kind of person would do what he did on principle or other personal motivation?