5 ms·
I think he's genuinely suggesting that if journalists are getting so excited about the amplituhedron, they should get even more excited about this, and probably
by derefr 13y ago
I think he's genuinely suggesting that if journalists are getting so excited about the amplituhedron, they should get even more excited about this, and probably can only do that if they have a fun word for it. No joke.
(If it was a joke, the paper he linked to -- http://www.scottaaronson.com/papers/pp.pdf http://www.scottaaronson.com/papers/pp.pdf -- probably wouldn't be exactly what he described it as.)
- acadien 13y agoIt is 100% a joke. He seems to be pointing out that you can get the press to over hype a scientific/mathematical advance by giving it a neat name, e.g. dark matter, anti matter, god particle, quantum-anything, electro-anything, super-anything, hyper-anything.
- Dylan16807 13y agoBut wasn't the point of the other one that representing it as a multi-dimensional volume was novel? That had nothing to do with the name. What's the point of mocking the name?
- acadien 13y agoHe's not mocking the name or the finding, he's mocking the press coverage. This seems clear to me from the opening paragraph, maybe I'm missing something?
- Dylan16807 13y agoI don't see how he's mocking the coverage and not the concept itself. Shrug.
- scythe 13y agoIf you read some of the links in the first paragraph you'll get a feel for the intent of the article. Aaronson probably expects his audience to follow traditional physics sources. See for example: http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6260 http://www.math.columbia.edu/~woit/wordpress/?p=6260 Yesterday in QFT class the professor [0] explained the name by saying that the guy who came up with it was a "very good salesman". The reality is that probabilities can in a great deal of cases be expressed as the volume of something in some phase space, for a trivial example, consider the area under the curve between two x-values on the normal distribution's probability density function -- it's the 2-volume of a section of the Gaussiohedron. So after branding quantum information science as the study of the "unitarihedron", Aaronson dragged out one of his more miraculous results, which is that PP is closed under union and intersection as a direct result of PP = PostBQP, where PostBQP is a complexity class derived from BQP using an idea called postselection. That proof was actually in his dissertation (if I recall correctly), written in 2006, and it was an extremely impressive proof which did not use a word like "unitarihedron" to describe its methods. So, while it was a joke, if you read the article in the context of the physics community's reaction to the amplituhedron story, the included proof really just helps to drive the point home. The methods now called "amplituhedron" have been under continuous development for the past ten years or so. My QFT professor[0] seemed sort of enthusiastic about the development. They do seem to represent a step forward in our understanding of quantum field theory, though the reaction of the media has been, in the eyes of some commentators, characteristically buzzword-driven. [0]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predrag_Cvitanovic http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Predrag_Cvitanovic
- acqq 13y agoAlso interesting: http://arstechnica.com/science/2013/05/earning-a-phd-by-studying-a-theory-that-we-know-is-wrong/ http://arstechnica.com/science/2013/05/earning-a-phd-by-stud...
- carlob 13y agoAre you sure your professor authorised you to quote him on calling one of the most powerful persons in his field: 'a very good salesman' on a public forum of sorts?
- gajomi 13y agoThis particular professor, as far as I am aware, would probably not be considered as active in QFT. He has been working on turbulence and chaos recent (albeit, employing techniques from field theory). At any rate, I don't really see the quip as taking a knock on these guys (he is known for his witty banter). This is really good salesmanship and the media are having a filed day with it.
- carlob 13y agoJust checking, sometimes people banter, but they don't want to see such banter spread in print. FWIW I have met Arkani-Hamed and he didn't strike me for his salesmanship.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- cwp 13y agoYou don't need authorization to quote someone.
- scythe 13y agoThere is an archive of his quotes related to various topics: http://www.its.caltech.edu/~mason/wisdom/predrag.txt http://www.its.caltech.edu/~mason/wisdom/predrag.txt As he has not objected to this in the ten or so years it's been around, I doubt he'd object to my quoting him either. I thought what he said was illustrative.