7 ms·
Starlite
- kefs 13y agoHere is the late Maurice Ward's YouTube channel.. https://www.youtube.com/user/mauricewardstarlite/videos https://www.youtube.com/user/mauricewardstarlite/videos
- nperson 13y agoHere's a site I've built for an artist who did "Episodes of Starlite" http://stopthebus.org/starlite http://stopthebus.org/starlite.
- Wingman4l7 13y agoSounds like aerogel.
- lutusp 13y agoYes, except that aerogel is well-understood, both as to composition and behavior. This stuff is a first-class mystery. Too bad the inventor, good at science, was so bad at business.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- yapcguy 13y agohttp://www.theguardian.com/notesandqueries/query/0,5753,-5575,00.html http://www.theguardian.com/notesandqueries/query/0,5753,-557... > Mr Ward came to my lab about a year before his death needing help to turn what was essentially a party trick into a useable & commercialy viable product. The problem he had was although the powder component did exactly as it said on the tin, he had found no way of applying a lasting coating. All he really has was some powder mixed with PVA glue, the problem being that although you could apply it to certain objects it's longevity was no more than 2 weeks. While testing we discovered that a sample he'd kept for almost 10 years could be destroyed in a matter of minutes under a methylacetylene-propadiene propane blowtorch. Unfortunately after many samples & tests we where unable to find a effective application method & we parted company on good terms. Sadly this is the true reason why Mr Ward was never able to sell or bring his incomplete product to market.
- rajivtiru 13y agoThe best heat resistant materials we have available to date are ablative materials. These materials "shed" particles of themselves as heat(kinetic energy) is applied. It looks like starlite while able to withstand more extreme temperatures, also ablates at relatively normal temperatures. From my quick research, this looks like, this is responsible for its longevity issues. EDIT: relatively normal temperature meaning a blowtorch vs. a rocket nozzle or re-entry heatshield
- justinator 13y ago> Mr Ward came to my lab about a year before his death > needing help to turn what was essentially a party trick > into a useable & commercialy viable product. So, this person heard a huge, "Whooosh" when Graphene hit the scene too, eh? "It's just Scotch Tape and pencil doodles!" I definitely Want To Believe. World-Changing technology always has its detractors. Remember the airplane? Silly, silly invention.
- idProQuo 13y agoThe quote is incomplete. Right after all that, he says: >But rest assured, as of this time I can say that there is at least 1 complete & superior product in testing, testing that so far is going remarkably well. So one day there will be a product on the market that will save life's while also having countless other uses. The inspiration behind this project.... Mr Maurice Ward I'm not sure when this comment was written, but perhaps he was talking about Graphene.
- Indyan 13y agoThe meeting happened in 2010, going by the fact that it happened one year before Mr. Ward's death.
- lingben 13y agofrom Anon in London, UK? that's a reliable source?
- alt_f4 13y agoSounds like vaporware
- pje 13y agoDuke Nukem: Starlite
- adamnemecek 13y agoIt kind of blows my mind that one (presumably) cannot reverse engineer things like this.
- brazzy 13y agoWithout a sample, it's not surprising.
- scotty79 13y agoNoone can reverse engineer WD40 with plenty of samples.
- nl 13y agoWhat do you mean? There are plenty of WD40-work-a-likes on the market. Additionally, the ingredients to WD40 are on Wikipedia[1] and Wired had a mass spectroscopy done and published even more precise details[2]. [1] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WD-40#Formulation http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WD-40#Formulation [2] http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/magazine/17-05/st_whatsinside http://www.wired.com/science/discoveries/magazine/17-05/st_w...
- eru 13y agoIt's in the same marketing category as Coca Cola's `secret formula'.
- scotty79 13y agoYou are right. My mistake. Second link you provided is very informative. Bonus: What people think they can use WD40 for: http://www.snopes.com/inboxer/household/wd-40.asp http://www.snopes.com/inboxer/household/wd-40.asp
- jakobe 13y agoIt's amazing how many people use WD40 as a lubricant. It's good for loosening stuck parts, but using it as a lubricant will wear parts quickly.
- Camillo 13y agoWhat sort of scientific Scrooge chooses to take his invention to the grave like that? What has he gained in the end?
- nodata 13y agoI'm sure he didn't plan to die.
- vacri 13y agoNot having something robust sorted out for your invention to survive your death by the time you're 78 years of age? That's bad planning. Or, perhaps, being a scrooge.
- harrytuttle 13y agoIn this particular case, it's probably the fear of not profiting from your invention. Older patent holders I've seen tend to be paranoid or obsessed with the money rather than what they have created.
- ronilan 13y ago> What has he gained in the end? Nothing. Most dead people, not matter what they "achieved" in life, gain nothing in the end. They are just dead. The idea that your goal in life is to leave a "legacy" is not universal. Life happens as it happens. Apparently for this "scientific Scrooge" it didn't happen in a way that enabled him to share his invention, so when the time came, he just took his invention to the grave. Same thing most likely happened numerous times in history with inventions, works of art and other "legacy items" we never heard about...
- alan_cx 13y agoAges ago I spent a fair amount of time considering what would happen if someone invented a new power source. I was planning to try to write a short story based on the idea. In my imagination I invented a device the size of a fridge freezer capable of powering a small town for 100 years. The workings and science were irrelevant, but the politics of it was what interested me. I cant find the notes I made now, but essentially I ended up deciding that something so revolutionary, if proved and accepted as doing what it said on the tin, would take a life of its own. I came to the conclusion that once people know of its existence, the inventor will lose all control and become an instant target. Such inventions are the "babies" of such inventors, so loss of control is an issue. Becoming a target, more so. I'm not sure what the people who did the science that lead to nuclear stuff intended or thought, but if it were me, the idea that my science was used to make such evil devices as nuclear bombs would at the very least cause me trouble. Interestingly there is some relevance to what is happening now with the NSA internet spying issue. People may well look at this sort of behavior and conclude that there are no limits for certain nation states. So, if a Belgian, for a random small country example, were to invent such technology, and say this person decided that only small poor countries could have access to it in order to equalize small poor countries with rich ones, how might the likes of China, UK, USA, India, etc, react to that? What would be their limit to acquire such technology? The second you deploy such a unit, spies would be all over it. Perhaps, war. So in the end, unless you do as told, your good might end up slaughtering millions. Now, I'm not saying that starlite was or is for real, or that the inventor thought this way, but I can certainly see why such an inventor might be so paranoid as to get in to a position where the secret dies with him. Of course I am very open to the idea that this says more about my personal psychology that any general point...
- brennenHN 13y agoThis would make for a great mystery novel.
- gmaslov 13y agoSounds like a situation that the patent system was supposedly designed to prevent. But, from the article linked by yapcguy: > He refused to patent the recipe as that would mean making it public and risking its theft Wouldn't patenting the formula prevent it from being "stolen"? Or is our patent system truly good for nothing at all?
- vitno 13y agoSpaceX does not patent any of their stuff for the same reason; it can be stolen by people outside of the country and the patent is essentially directions on how to do so.
- mercuryrising 13y agoI forget the quote exactly, but there was an interview with Elon and the lady was asking him about not patenting things at SpaceX. He said something along the lines of "Patents aren't going to do you much good when your competitors are other country's governments".
- jackgavigan 13y ago"We have essentially no patents in SpaceX. Our primary long-term competition is in China—if we published patents, it would be farcical, because the Chinese would just use them as a recipe book." Source: http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2012/10/ff-elon-musk-qa/all/ http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2012/10/ff-elon-musk-qa/al...
- mercuryrising 13y agoI'm sure he's said it a few times. This is the one I was referring to - > Even more so when he tells us that none of the design innovations in the rocket are patented. “Since our primary competitors are national governments, the enforceability of patents is questionable,” http://blog.ted.com/2013/02/27/transforming-transportation-elon-musk-at-ted2013/ http://blog.ted.com/2013/02/27/transforming-transportation-e...
- cwsteinbach 13y agoStarlite, meet FOGBANK: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fogbank http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fogbank
- cwsteinbach 13y agoIn 1996, the US government decided that large numbers of its nuclear weapons would require replacement, refurbishing, or decommissioning. Accordingly, the Department of Energy set up a refurbishment program aimed at extending the service lives of older nuclear weapons. In 2000, the National Nuclear Security Administration (NNSA) specified a life-extension program for W76 warheads that would enable them to remain in service until at least 2040.[2] It was soon realized that the FOGBANK material was a potential source of problems for the program, as few records of its manufacturing process had been retained when it was originally manufactured in the 1980s, and nearly all staff members who had expertise in its production had either retired or left the agency. The NNSA briefly investigated sourcing a substitute for FOGBANK, but eventually decided that since FOGBANK had been produced previously, they would be able to repeat it.[2] Additionally, "Los Alamos computer simulations at that time were not sophisticated enough to determine conclusively that an alternate material would function as effectively as Fogbank," according to a Los Alamos publication.[3]
- icambron 13y agoSecrecy: not always a good idea.
- cromwellian 13y agoI'm skeptical. There are a lot of bullshit free-energy and reactionless drive "inventors" who exhibit the same pattern. Super secretive and paranoid that the traditional scientific review process will steal their invention, will only allow third parties to experiment under very controlled conditions, etc, won't produce working patents, etc. Remember Dean Drive? I often think they either known they're peddling something bogus and are straight out charlatans, or they actually really believed in what they have, but are too afraid of it being debunked. Science and secrecy don't go together. A material with twice the melting point of tantalum halfnium carbide sounds like an ablative heat shield to me.
- Eliezer 13y agoI remember the Dean Drive. Does anyone else remember the Dean Drive?
- abrahamsen 13y agoI didn't: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dean_drive http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dean_drive
- eksith 13y agoThis sounds an awful lot like Firepaste https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troy_Hurtubise#Firepaste https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Troy_Hurtubise#Firepaste There seems to be a common trend among these types of inventors that border on paranoia, eccentricity and at the same time, accidental brilliance.
- jackgavigan 13y agoA cautionary tale for any aspiring entrepreneur who won't share their world-changing idea without a signed NDA.
- yogrish 13y agoJust read abt Starlite and other Amazing man made substances at this URL thru reddit. http://listverse.com/2013/06/20/10-awesome-man-made-substances/ http://listverse.com/2013/06/20/10-awesome-man-made-substanc...
- adaml_623 13y agoWhy the downvotes? The other 9 substances on that link are just as interesting. I recommend people have a look. The video of the amorphous metal is quite interesting. (Yogrish. I saw the link elsewhere first as well but maybe we're not meant to use the R word here)
- yogrish 13y agoDidn't know about R word. sure will take care of it next time.
- tomelders 13y agoI remember this being on Tomorrows World (which is a show that needs to come back), and practically every year that memory pops into my head and I wonder whatever happened to it. I think the segment ended with him showing it to NASA. If I remember correctly, he created it in his garden shed using off the shelf products that you could buy on the high street, and he just started mixing them together and testing the results... and I think hairspray was mentioned as being an important ingredient. Or maybe my mind is full of holes.
- duylamnguyenngo 13y agoSounds like a recipe for amateur experimentation...or a real Walter White.
- rplnt 13y agohair products were mentioned: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W4nnLP--uTI http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=W4nnLP--uTI
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoWard certainly believes in his product, claiming publicly that it could have prevented the space shuttle disasters. 'Starlite has a Q-value [an energy absorption rating] of 2,470. The space shuttle tiles have a Q-value of 1.' Not only that, but because Starlite is so lightweight – 1mm thick, compared to 75mm for the space tiles – it's actually '2,470 x 75 times better'. http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/5158972/Starlite-the-nuclear-blast-defying-plastic-that-could-change-the-world.html http://www.telegraph.co.uk/technology/5158972/Starlite-the-n... What is a "Q-value" in this usage?
- jzwinck 13y agoQ is the heat transfer rate; see http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_transfer_coefficient http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Heat_transfer_coefficient
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoThanks! But, if that's the case, a higher value means a worse insulator, so why would he brag about that? (It's also a dimensionful quantity, but the reported value has no units -- maybe it's relative to some specific value...)
- throwaway_yy2Di 13y agoI think it's more likely to be a measure of heat absorbed, rather than heat transferred across a boundary. (The Telegraph's wording is "an energy absorption rating"). Starlite is apparently ablative; if this means an endothermic phase change -- the organic polymers vaporizing, without combusting -- it could absorb an extremely large amount of heat. A space shuttle tile is non-ablative (I think?), and can absorb heat only by increasing temperature.
- Elrac 13y ago> but because Starlite is so lightweight - 1 mm thick Just what about a substance determines how thick it is? How thick is concrete, then? Glass? Is there a reason Starlite can't be manufactured 75 mm thick, and would it then not be even more amazingly effective? Or alternatively, what's the thickness value for concrete? Glass? What's the Q-value of 75mm of paper tissue?
- Elrac 13y agoI call bullshit. Here's a list of the points in the article that jumped out at me as uninformative, pseudo-scientific or misleading: > a laser beam producing a temperature of 10,000 degrees Celsius. Scientifically, that's meaningless. It's meant to convey a powerful heat source to the reader, but as another reader pointed out, a strong focused light source on a bit of well-insulated black material might be able to raise it to several thousand degrees; the same source pointed at a well-polished mirror could leave it cold to the touch. In other words, the "10,000" degree figure tells us nothing useful. > (from the allegedly supporting New Scientist article cited on the talk page): The first thing Lewis and his colleagues did was fire powerful laser pulses at the material. What person with scientific training would set up a laser to conduct his first test on an unknown material? I admit to not being a professional NASA egghead, but if confronted with a substance alleged to be highly heat resistant, I'd start off by holding a sample of it into a Bunsen burner flame, or better yet pop it into a crucible and into a high-temperature furnace. If a temperature of 10,000°C had really been achieved, that would have been quite impressive: according to elswhere in Wikipedia, the "best" known heat-resistant ceramics lose stability around 3,000°C. This Tech Radar article http://www.techradar.com/news/world-of-tech/future-tech/10-mindblowing-uses-for-the-world-changing-substance-that-never-was-1156955 http://www.techradar.com/news/world-of-tech/future-tech/10-m... claims a more modest 2500°, achieved with a blowtorch and not a laser. What are we to believe? As a (hypothetical) egghead, I would certainly object on moral grounds to using an egg for a scientific test of heat resistance. I would instead strive to measure the two characteristics actually relevant to heat resistance, namely thermal conductivity and thermally induced ablation. As an amateur scientist completely unprepared for such a test and working out of an ordinary household, I would have urged the inventor to use his amazing compound to coat not a chicken's egg but the tip of a thermometer. And I would have attacked this assembly not with a laser but with a burning match. And I would have reported on how much of a rise in temperature was observed, and in which time. Certainly no non-crackpot scientist would subject his or anyone's hand to a blowtorching without considerably more convincing previous tests. But maybe that claim about the human hand was just rhetoric - it's hard to tell. Later in the supporting article, the claim is toned down to a much more modest 1000°C. Still, there's a fundamental problem here with the basic chemistry: Plastics, or more formally polymers, are organic compounds, chemically held together by covalent bonds. Because of the physics that underlies chemistry, covalent bonds cannot be as heat-resistant as ionic bonds (as found in salts and other inorganic compounds). All-organic diamond is the hardest substance known to man (I think) but burns at relatively low temperatures. High-temperature plastics break down at around 150°C. If the compound contained a mix of polymers, as stated, then it contained some organic compounds with known low melting/burning points. Mixing several such compounds doesn't make any of them more heat resistant; their chemical properties (including heat resistance) would not be changed unless you'd created new and different compounds that would then _not_ be polymers. Similarly, mixing in about 10% ceramics might change the compound's mechanical properties, and polymer-ceramic composites are indeed useful materials for this reason, but it doesn't change the fact that part of the mix is low-melting, burning, smoking plastic. I'm sorely tempted to pick a fight on the Wikipedia Talk page as well, where the most ardent defender of the Starlite story lambastes skeptical commenters as "bigoted" and "ignorant."
- spyder 13y agoIs this the same? Man torches hand with 7000+ degree flame and then eats the material: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SO7NVC23Stw http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=SO7NVC23Stw