5 ms·
Watch Linux video go the way of Linux audio... Intel are 100% in the right to make a stand.
by gaius 13y ago
Watch Linux video go the way of Linux audio... Intel are 100% in the right to make a stand.
- drivebyacct2 13y agoA completely overblown exaggeration and really not an issue for 98% of users ever, let alone regularly?
- tinco 13y agoIt won't be like Linux audio, because all Linux audio drivers are open source. If Intel can't get AMD and NVidia to support Wayland, and Canonical spoke the truth when they said that AMD and NVidia will support Mir, then what reason will people have to use Wayland? It will only work with Intel cards. Intel is actively making a stand against Open Source. I know that's unlike them, but their stance just makes no sense from a free software perspective. When you look at it from the perspective of Canonical enabling AMD and NVidia to cooperate with introducing a new graphics driver interface, a shadowy doubt is cast over Intel's motivations.
- toyg 13y agoWell, what is stopping NVidia and AMD from cooperating on Wayland right now? When you look at it from this perspective, a shadowy doubt is cast over Canonical's motivations.
- ginko 13y agoThis is the part that irritates me most about Mir: By rolling their own display server, Canonical has set back efforts to get all display vendors on board for supporting Wayland. If Ubuntu would have switched used Wayland (along with the other distributions), there would have been a very strong incentive for all vendors to support this in their drivers.
- ikt 13y agoIf Red Hat had supported .deb packages maybe packaging wouldn't be such a pain in the ass and we wouldn't have a .tar, .deb and a .rpm for every program. There are a lot of things in linux land that don't make sense, I think picking on Canonical for choosing to do what they want as opposed to all the others who are choosing to do what they want, is very un linux like.
- ginko 13y agoThe difference is that the choice of package system is completely in the domain of open source software. Proprietary drivers require support by hardware vendors. If we had solid, feature-complete open source graphics drivers this wouldn't be an issue.
- synchronise 13y agoIf this were the case, then why is a large swathe of proprietary drivers supporting only Surfaceflinger? If it's the most popular display framework in terms of use, then why not simply make it the default? Not Wayland nor X11 could garner the numbers required to overtake SF.
- jmillikin 13y agoI wish Linux video would go the way of Linux audio. Linux audio just works. There's a single userspace API (PulseAudio), a single kernel driver API (ALSA), and all the old nastiness of the '90s (ESD, aRts, OSS) is dead and gone. In contrast, getting video to work properly involves figuring out what hardware you're running (nVidia? ATI/AMD? Intel? misc other?), then hunting down the drivers, installing them, rebooting, hoping the hardware gets detected correctly, and so on until the user gives up and settles for a half-broken system. I consider myself fairly skilled with Linux stuff, and I still can't figure out how to get my desktop to have both kernel modesetting and accelerated OpenGL at the same time.
- mhurron 13y agoThe only time I have hunt down video drivers for Linux is when I decide to use the closed nVidia driver. Other than that it's all kernel/X supplied drivers.
- makomk 13y agoExcept that it doesn't just work. Ignoring the hardware aspect altogether for a moment, PulseAudio itself is inherently buggy. If you run it for long enough with its volume control app open, the daemon sometimes crashes and everything stops playing sound. (It looks like that might be due to a bug in the peak volume reporting code resulting from an incredibly misleading variable name, but I'm not sure - none of it's commented, so it's impossible to figure out how it's meant to work). Resampling glitches out randomly and requires a restart of the daemon. There was a patch to the resampling code in the latest release which was outright incomplete and broken but got included anyway, and since the PulseAudio devs don't release stable versions, the only release with the fix in will be a major one with a whole bunch of new regressions. I've encountered major bugs with fixes in the Fedora package that weren't submitted upstream at all, and the patches were written and added by Lennart Poettering himself. Then there's the hardware-specific fun: headphone outputs that don't mute the speakers when they should due to driver or hardware quirks, outputs and inputs that plain don't work, weird volume glitches where exiting one app causes all the others to shift in volume due to PulseAudio's info about the hardware volume control being wrong...
- jlgreco 13y ago