17 ms·
How Detroit went broke
- api 13y agoThe article skirts the obvious: Kwame Kilpatrick's corruption: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kwame_Kilpatrick http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kwame_Kilpatrick The guy went to jail for f's sake. I wonder how much graft and embezzling went on that nobody was ever charged with?
- bruceb 13y agoWhile Kilpatrick did commit crimes to say the whole downfall is due to him is joke. The article does cover his financial deals that now look to be costing Detroit a lot. At the time thought the paper was supporting those deals.
- danso 13y agoSorry, but what unmentioned corruption are you talking about? This is high up in the article: > Adding the last straw — Kilpatrick’s gamble: He’s best known around the globe for a sex and perjury scandal that sent him to jail and massive corruption that threatens to send him to prison next month for more than 20 years. The corruption cases further eroded Detroit’s image and distracted the city from its fiscal storm. But perhaps the greatest damage Kilpatrick did to the city’s long-term stability was with Wall Street’s help when he borrowed $1.44 billion in a flashy high-finance deal to restructure pension fund debt. That deal, which could cost $2.8 billion over the next 22 years, now represents nearly one-fifth of the city’s debt. And then there's a whole section headlined: "Kilpatrick’s award-winning deal turns into a financial disaster" Kilpatrick is quite famous for his sex and corruption. But are you arguing that those had more of an effect on Detroit's long term viability than a pension deal that blew up the city's obligation to swap holders from $770 million to $1.95 billion in four years? You could argue that only a corrupt bastard would make such a deal, but that deal was talked about at the time...and, the Freep notes, even its own editorial board approved of it. It was a politically expedient and irresponsible gambit, but let's face it, the corrupt don't have a monopoly on irresponsibility.
- chrischen 13y agoHe also gave city contracts to friends.
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoand Emmanual/Daley, Bloomberg, and Villaraigosa don't? Every big city suffers from quite a bit of corruption, from backroom deals to strong-arm unions. This doesn't explain Detroit.
- JackFr 13y agoBloomberg doesn't. As a mayor he's fairly incorruptible, at least in terms of money. He pays for his own elections, and basically does whatever he feels like. With a net worth of 27 billion it's unlikely that anyone could offer him a monetary bribe worth looking at.
- drzaiusapelord 13y agoExcept he's not dictator and favor debt is just as real as money debt. The members of the NYC council have their own interests, corruptions, etc that he need to work with. There's this idea that a mega-rich politician will be incorruptable. I'm not sure that's ever been true. The system is bigger than just one guy making decisions and even the head of an organization needs to keep a lot of people happy.
- JackFr 13y agoWell, the thing is trading favors with the city council is politics, not corruption. You might not like what he did to have the city council extend term limits so he could run a third time, but it was above board, and no different politicking to get the law passed to begin with. And I have no doubt that New York City's government has corruption, but comment I was responding to specifically referred to mayors. I get that the head of an organization needs to keep a lot of people happy and the executive may need to needle and cajole, but as I said, that isn't corruption that's politics.
- jfb 13y agoDetroit isn't circling the drain because of Kilpatrick, as corrupt as he was; the problem is fundamentally the cumulative effect of decades of reasonable if ultimately irresponsible decision making. I liked the freep article a lot; I was surprised by how little approbation Young came in for, all taken with all. There's a fairly serious principle-agent problem in elected government; I'm not sure how you get around things like e.g. Detroit's pension fund throwing the 13th check around, or US Representatives trying to force the US Treasury into default, given that the incentives for more long-term thinking just aren't there.
- bluedino 13y agoHe lives in Texas and works for CompuWare now.
- rglovejoy 13y agoNot for much longer.
- billybob255 13y agoHe was fired back in 2010 and will be going back to prison in October. I'm pretty sure he's in jail until then.
- jfarmer 13y agoDetroit has been losing 200k residents per decade since 1950. It's probably more useful to see Kwame Kilpatrick's administration as a symptom of Detroit's deterioration rather than its cause.
- VLM 13y agoLook into the concept of failed states. Usually as applied to 3rd world countries, but most of it applies to Detroit just as well. Seems to be an open question if the cause and effect is failed states result in corrupt administration, or corrupt administration results in failed states. Probably a lovely intense feedback loop. But it takes more than just one crook.
- JonSkeptic 13y ago>Detroit’s leaders engaged in a billion-dollar borrowing binge, created new taxes and failed to cut expenses when they needed to. Simultaneously, they gifted workers and retirees with generous bonuses. And under pressure from unions and, sometimes, arbitrators, they failed to cut health care benefits — saddling the city with staggering costs that today threaten the safety and quality of life of people who live here. That is eerily, if not disturbingly, parallel to our national problems. Though, hopefully, we have a bit more time to fix the national problems.
- jfb 13y agoYes, but. The Federal government has many monetary tools available to it that Detroit doesn't. It's not clear to me that making the analogy between the way the Federal government and a non-soverign entity like Detroit work does anything but confuse the issues.
- NoPiece 13y agoI think the analogy is useful, because the financial problem has some of same roots. That the federal government has more solutions available to it doesn't excuse following the same path. It's useful to to look at Detroit to try and avoid the problem, it's not useful to look at Detroit for solutions once it hits critical mass.
- wutbrodo 13y agoIt seems to me that the proximate cause of Detroit's problem is this massive flight of high-value (in the economic sense) population. I don't see even an echo of that happening in the US; certainly not at the level that it could be considered a problem.
- NoPiece 13y agoThe problem with Detroit is unsustainable debt. Depopulation is just one of many contributing factors. The depopulation has been slow, very long term, and predictable. The debt could have been avoided by scaling back spending as the the population decreased. Or an effective Detroit government might have even taken steps to improve the city so people didn't leave or even moved in.
- ffrryuu 13y agoSpending more than taking in, plus inability to monetize debt like the Fed (simply print more money using a computer).
- jacobquick 13y agoFinally someone gets it right. There's already a bunch of comments in here comparing the federal government's "debt" to city, state, corporate, or individual debt. It's ridiculous and incredibly damaging to try to draw parallels between entities that have to account for their borrowing and a central bank that can extend infinite credit without collateral, debt or repayment any time it feels like it.
- penrod 13y agoPutting scare quotes around sovereign "debt" doesn't change that fact that bondholders are actually expecting to get paid. Though there's no force of law behind that expectation, if the government defaults no-one will lend to it any more without hefty sweeteners. Similar deal if we debase the currency with inflation.
- seoguru 13y agoWarren Mosler explains a bit on how "lending" to the US works: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1uWVj0YJ3M http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Z1uWVj0YJ3M Warren and Stephanie Kelton on "governments are not households": http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ba8XdDqZ-Jg http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ba8XdDqZ-Jg current "net financial assets" (national debt) are not sufficient for our current level of productivity as evidenced by our unemployment rate.
- penrod 13y agoGovernments are not households? Who knew. Maybe you could rebut some statements I did make? Tags: strawman, appeal-to-authority
- onebaddude 13y ago
- vkou 13y agoSomehow, I don't see increases on municipal taxes (Which, all in all, make up a small part of our overall tax burdens) to the main cause of the exodus... Compared to the lack of employment - from, say, the demise of the Detroit auto industry. It doesn't matter if your municipal tax bill is 0, if you don't have a job.
- dantheman 13y agoI don't have it the information at hand, but I believe many people moved to the towns just outside of detroit to escape the taxes. IIRC those towns/cities are doing fine.
- vkou 13y agoIn which case, I'd cite the ability, and the desire of the American middle class to raise their children in a gated suburbia to be a far more likely factor. Think of it as a typical parent - would you want your kid to go to school in Detroit? (The same school that Balanced Budget politics is more then willing to defund.)
- philwelch 13y agoThat trend lasted from the 50's through the 90's or so, but the trend now has been to move back into cities, except for Detroit.
- NoPiece 13y agoI think it is way too early to call a trend. And to the degree cities are growing just barely faster than suburbs (.2%) for the last couple years, that can largely be explained by the housing bubble and recession. While there is some data showing young people moving to cities, there isn't much showing families returning to cities. According to his analysis of the 51 metropolitan areas with more than 1 million people, the primary cities in those metros grew an average of 1.1 percent, compared with 0.9 percent growth in the suburban areas of those metros between July 2010 and July 2011.* http://www.theatlanticcities.com/neighborhoods/2012/06/urban-or-suburban-growth-us-metros/2419/ http://www.theatlanticcities.com/neighborhoods/2012/06/urban...
- specialist 13y agoAdditional, perhaps complimentary, analysis: The Real Story Behind the Decline of Detroit … And Yes, Great Things Are Happening There Too http://www.alternet.org/economy/real-story-detroits-economy-good-things-are-really-happening-motown?paging=off http://www.alternet.org/economy/real-story-detroits-economy-... TL;DR: Detroit was set up to fail. An example: "One dramatic example of the cost of racism born by Detroit is this: Detroit has an income tax on those who work within the city limits. The two-tier tax is lower for those who work in the city but live in the suburbs. In enacting the tax, the state legislature required employers based in the city to collect the tax via payroll deduction as they do with federal and other taxes. Suburban based employers are not required by the law to collect the tax. Most of them don’t. The revenue lost to Detroit per year is estimated to be as much as $142 million."
- JonSkeptic 13y ago>TL;DR: Detroit was set up to fail. ... The nation's 10th largest city was set up to fail? Did the Illuminati do this, or was it an inside job? http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detroit http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Detroit
- jfarmer 13y agoDetroit was the 10th-largest city in the US in the 2000 census with a population of ~900k, but was the 18th-largest in 2010 with a population of ~700k. It was the 4th largest in the 30s and 40s and reached its peak population of approximately 2MM in the 1950s. Since then it has been losing approximately 200k residents (think: taxpayers) per decade like clockwork. So any story about Detroit has to explain that. There are systemic things at work and there have been for over 60 years, although I agree "set up to fail" has a rather conspiratorial tone to it.
- specialist 13y agoI agree "set up to fail" has a rather conspiratorial tone to it. Sure. By default or by design, intent is unknowable and unactionable. I only judge outcomes.
- drcode 13y agoOne thing that bothers me about this is that they have the concept of "retiree costs" but track those at the time they became due, when instead they should be blaming earlier administrations who promised higher benefits at the time but didn't put money aside to cover these future costs. Retiree benefits are essentially "loans" and should be (but aren't) included in all the debt graphs.
- mathattack 13y agoYes. Both cities and corporations are guilty of this, especially on the Health Care side. I recall attending a recruiting presentation of a Detroit automaker who bragged about how they were purposefully not funding their Health Care liabilities because they thought the cash was better spent elsewhere and the government would eventually pick up the tab.
- mikeash 13y agoI just absolutely adore how this comment currently sits right next to one saying that this sort of thing is purely a government problem.
- ianstallings 13y agoWell at the time those programs were created the tax base was capable of supporting them. Then when the tax base decreased in size significantly the city did not, in turn, change those programs to acknowledge the fact that the money simply would not be there. They were put in place on the assumption that the tax base would increase as it does in a lot of major cities. My point? I think they should be included because the government failed to take them into account, or ignored the looming problem.
- prostoalex 13y ago> instead they should be blaming earlier administrations That's one of the main differences between public finances and private finances - administrators who over-promise in private space get audited and corrected, administrators who over-promise in public space get financed and elected.
- georgebonnr 13y agoAt least anecdotally, things like this don't help. https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6293170 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6293170
- VLM 13y agoFrom the article: "Other cities also have profound problems today — Chicago, Providence, R.I., Baltimore. But only Detroit is in bankruptcy court." Meant to write "... in bankruptcy court, so far." or something similar. It's mathematically impossible for Chicago and Baltimore and a couple others not to join Detroit in the near future in bankruptcy court. I donno about the finances of Providence RI. I'm only aware of one tech company in Detroit which is a place that makes what amounts to a small Xylinx FPGA dev board on a DIP-64 PCB so it just plugs into a circuit board or breadboard. I own one and haven't used it much but so far its a good product. But its the only tech company I'm aware of based in Detroit. There may be others who spend even less on advertising, donno. Cool as that place may be, I don't think it makes up for the collapse of auto industry employment and lack of mobility. Most of the unemployed people in Detroit originally came from the South because there were no jobs in the South, but there were jobs in Detroit. The "real problem" is there's no where better to go than Detroit for those people. If they had jobs in Minneapolis, there wouldn't be a problem with unemployment in Detroit, but there are no jobs, anywhere, for anyone not in tech, so, they sit, expensively, in Detroit.
- hackula1 13y agoI suppose they could go back south where the cost of living is significantly cheaper. I live in a house one block away from beachfront on an island and probably pay about what a one bedroom studio in Detroit costs. There is also a growing manufacturing base around here as well that employs a lot of the sort of people that would have worked in Detroit (welders, for example). Also, you don't have to live in Detroit ;)
- ipince 13y agoWhere do you live?
- hackula1 13y agoCharleston, SC
- tesseractive 13y ago
- jareds 13y agohttp://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compuware http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Compuware It's not enough to employ anyone in Detroit who might want a tech job but it is a decent sized tech company based in the city. Quicken Loans is also bringing a bunch of people down and buying up a lot of the empty office buildings. Down town appears to have turned around somewhat but since I'm one of the people who lives in the suburbs I can’t speak to weather there’s any kind of meaningful trickledown effect to help the rest of the city.
- billybob255 13y agoCompuware's been struggling lately though, and are going to be making cuts for a couple years at least.
- brewdad 13y agoCompuware has been struggling since Y2K ended. In some ways it has mirrored Detroit's decline.
- c0nsumer 13y agoTheir location downtown is the exact reason why I haven't yet applied with them. I live in the suburbs where downtown Detroit is a 1hr drive (on a normal day) each way. Something in the north/east suburbs is a much more reasonable 30 minutes. I'm not willing to move into or closer to the city just for the couple more jobs there, as living in the city proper is not so great, and just another place in the suburbs would be a lateral move. I strongly suspect that many who live in the Detroit suburbs feel the same way.
- goodviking 13y agoI hate these in depth "Here are the 50 reasons that Detroit is bankrupt ..." that try to parse every speck of dust on the city payroll. Here's why Detroit is bankrupt: because anyone smart enough to get out left a long time ago. The schools are terrible, the crime is terrible, the racism is terrible, the infrastructure is terrible. Why would anyone willingly stay? It's like a sticking around Carthage after the ground has been salted. You can argue a thousand different reasons about why it's the way it is, but it doesn't change the facts on the ground. Smart people leave and don't pay taxes to keep the corrupt apparatus afloat.
- todd2012 13y agoI grew up in inner city Detroit, many years ago. It was terrible even then, and once I got out I never went back. I learned practically nothing in school and had to dodge violence everyday. I feel sorry for those that were never able to get away from there. (Class of '69 at Highland Park High School)
- mgkimsal 13y agowow - it was that bad then? that's my dad's era, but they'd moved to east detroit (sorry, "eastpointe") by then.
- bluedino 13y agoFor the true Detroit experience, stay the weekend at the Motorcity Hotel and Casino. It's just a few blocks outside of what is considered 'downtown' Detroit. It's not an overly fancy or even large hotel but it has the weirdest vibe to it, it's as if you're in this dystopian movie about the future where there's a 1:1000 difference between the haves, and the have nots. Inside the hotel there's food, booze, gambling, and bright lights. As you leave the hotel you see security forces (hotel security as well as a fairly large presence by the Detroit PD). But once you're outside, that's it. Barren wastelands. Empty city blocks, fields of grass and weathered concrete, and the ruins of entire neighborhoods. Exactly what you see when you Google 'Detroit slums'. In the daytime you'll see people walking around like zombies, carrying grocery bags, walking between stores (despite what you read on the internet, there are grocery stores in Detroit). You'll see them talking to each other on the corner, sitting under trees, or hunched over on a curb. They have nothing. They do nothing. There is nothing for any of these people to do. There's nowhere for them to work. There's nothing even for them to have. Everything is gone or destroyed. At night time you won't see anything. Almost all of the streetlights in the city have been turned off, because Detroit can't pay the bill! The city is pitch black at night. You can drive around with the highbeams on. You can't see the roads, you have to make sure you don't run over anyone who's in the street, it's incredibly unsafe but it's just so dark it's unbelievable. And then in the midst of the darkness you see the multi-colored lights of the hotel, and you know you're back to your version of Detroit. The police let you back in, you park your vehicle in the guarded garage, and you walk back to your room to eat $4 bags of M&M's and $5 bottles of water. And once you think about how fucked up that is, you almost lose your appetite.
- jessaustin 13y agoMaybe the Freep should have done this in-depth investigation like a decade ago?
- tesseractive 13y agoTen years ago, a report like this would have been greeted with something like "Detroit is in decline? In other shocking news, it's raining in Seattle." The vast majority of people don't care about long, ongoing stories that they know the basic story of until there's some notable event that makes it news right now, which in this case is the bankruptcy. I would expect they've been reporting on the various aspects of the problem all along -- that's what local papers generally do year in and year out. It's just no one cared about consuming in one big report like this until it became a notable event.
- ksherlock 13y agoThey did their part... Council members at the time — Maryann Mahaffey, Barbara-Rose Collins, Sharon McPhail and JoAnn Watson — blocked the original pension certificates deal for months. They warned it was too risky because of the stock market’s volatility and accused Kilpatrick of political gamesmanship. The Free Press editorial page in February 2005 also applied pressure, calling the reluctant council members “heads-in-the-sand” politicians who “have become a threat to the stability of the community.” The editorial described the transaction as a “sound deal” that was “akin to refinancing a mortgage.”
- jessaustin 13y agoHaha nice head-fake in the intro. You had me going. No matter the municipality, the "smart" money will always be in favor of the most outlandish deal the market could possibly bear. After all, it's the general public's money at risk. In 2005, you could refinance your mortgage at a drive-through window. I doubt they would have used that language in 2009. Refi once, you might be fine. Refi twice, you might be fine. Keep going, and you'll lose your house.
- Kudzu_Bob 13y agoOdd that Pittsburgh, another Midwestern industrial town of about the same size as Detroit, has faced very similar difficulties, but is now doing pretty well for itself, so much so that some now consider it America's most livable city. Why the huge difference in outcome?
- Pxtl 13y agoI live in Hamilton, ON - basically Pittsburgh of Canada. Well, Pittsburgh with a time-machine back to that confused period when Steel City was on the pivotal moment where it could decay into Detroit or become what it is today. Local activists and even the CBC point to Pittsburgh as basically Hamilton's to-do list, and former mayor Tom Murphy in particular. Basically, his approach was this: cut spending brutally, raise taxes (especially parking tax, which improves revenue, cuts traffic, and gets more people into bikes and buses), call in favors from philanthropists, bulldoze the steel mills into profitable waterfront land. Too late for Detroit to make those changes, though.
- Kudzu_Bob 13y agoBut I am still left wondering why Pittsburghers not only made different choices than did Detroiters, but made ones that were so vastly superior as to lead to their city's becoming the best town in America even as Detroit transformed itself a post-apocalyptic wasteland whose denizens hunt raccoons for their flesh.
- Kudzu_Bob 13y agoIn other words, one cannot really explain why the Western Roman Empire fell if he cannot account also for how the Eastern Roman Empire managed to last another thousand years.
- Daniel_Newby 13y agoDemographics. Detroit is 82% African and 31% minors. Pittsburgh is 26% African and 20% minors. And Pittsburgh has not had an insurrection in living memory.
- educating 13y agoI would have shared this post with others, but the first graph is serioualy racist-looking. Regardless of how accurate it is, there is no reason to show faces with the names that show skin color going with a significant rise in debt.
- lifeisstillgood 13y agoa similar debate existed with New Orleans after the flooding. do we bother to rebuild was the question - one of the more interesting ideas was instead of spending x billion on (indfficient) government reconstruction give each citizen x billion / population. if enough people decide to stay and rebuild fine, if they all leave and buy flats in NYC it's also fine. It's interesting - but certainly not the first thing I would suggest if I was a congressman