4 ms·
This is interesting. By that argument, everyone visiting open source conference "sprints" should be deported? For that matter, if I travel, and happen to do wo
by e12e 13y ago
This is interesting. By that argument, everyone visiting open source conference "sprints" should be deported?
For that matter, if I travel, and happen to do work while in another country that would also be in violation of immigration laws?
I guess at least visiting heads of state get a diplomatic waver...
(Yes, I'm being snarky, but I'm also serious -- I wonder what the the technicalities actually are -- never mind that you'll probably only be deported if you're doing blue collar work...)
- einhverfr 13y agoAlso note that uncompensated amateur performances are ok, but paid ones are not. So presumably if you are doing symbolic work without pay (say, the first shovel of a groundbreaking) the fact that they could be paying someone doesn't make it employment. This leads to all kinds of interesting questions. If you are an artist and here on a business visa, are you allowed to paint on your own canvas? Are you allowed to buy or sell paintings that you paint here in the US? I would think so. You might not be able to paint a mural for hire though.
- dalke 13y agohttp://ciudadjuarez.usconsulate.gov/hnivb1.html http://ciudadjuarez.usconsulate.gov/hnivb1.html lists many categories of people who may be in the US under a B1 visa: > Artists: An artist coming to the United States to paint, sculpt, etc. who is not under contract with a U.S. employer and who does not intend to regularly sell such art-work in the United States.
- einhverfr 13y agoThat's more permissive than I would have expected.
- nknighthb 13y ago> By that argument, everyone visiting open source conference "sprints" should be deported? By which argument? What job are they doing? Who's paying them? If they're making money off it, then yes, they probably should be deported. If they're doing work someone else could be making money off of, they should also probably be deported. > For that matter, if I travel, and happen to do work while in another country that would also be in violation of immigration laws? You would have to consult the laws of the other country in question. I'm sure the only way you could even possibly hope to make this argument in the US is if the company has no US suppliers, customers, or other US-related interests whatsoever. But even that is extremely doubtful. The general rule for immigration is this: If it's not authorized, it's unauthorized. Unless you have clearly and unambiguously established that it's authorized, don't do it. > I guess at least visiting heads of state get a diplomatic waver... Hardly. In the US, they'll need an A visa, just like every other visiting official. http://travel.state.gov/visa/temp/types/types_2637.html http://travel.state.gov/visa/temp/types/types_2637.html
- mahyarm 13y ago> For that matter, if I travel, and happen to do work while in another country that would also be in violation of immigration laws? Usually yes. The clincher that it's basically unenforceable and undetectable is why it practically possible in the first place. I'm pretty sure enforcement starts happening when: you stay there longer than a typical tourist visa, money starts landing in their countries bank accounts. You'll still have to file income tax returns somewhere too. >By that argument, everyone visiting open source conference "sprints" should be deported? Usually that is covered by the B-1 visa they are entering. The B-1 visa is very expansive. The concept behind many US immigration laws is basically "Are you doing work a US person could do and getting money from a US source, be it corporation, person, etc? If your not, then we are far more OK with that than the opposite." If it's a conference hackathon where nobody usually gets paid anyway, then it should be ok.
- deleted 13y ago[deleted]
- e12e 13y agoHm. But the article/discussion relates to forming a company (that charges for services) and doing the work "for free". So it would seem either that is legal, or open source work is also illegal?